Kerala CM Dismisses Karnataka's Fears Over Malayalam Language Bill

Kerala Chief Minister Pinarayi Vijayan has stated that Karnataka's concerns over the new Malayalam Language Bill are unfounded. He clarified that the law does not impose Malayalam in Kannada-medium schools and protects the rights of linguistic minorities. Vijayan emphasized that students from other states are not required to take Malayalam exams and that government correspondence can be in Tamil or Kannada. This response comes after Karnataka CM Siddaramaiah warned of opposing the bill to protect linguistic minority rights in border districts.

Key Points: Kerala CM Rejects Karnataka's Concerns on Language Bill

  • Kerala CM says concerns are baseless
  • Law upholds minority rights, says Vijayan
  • No Malayalam exam mandate for outsiders
  • Karnataka vows to oppose the bill if passed
3 min read

"Karnataka's concerns unfounded:" Kerala CM Pinarayi Vijayan on Malayalam Language bill

Kerala CM Pinarayi Vijayan says Karnataka's fears over the Malayalam Language Bill are unfounded, clarifying protections for linguistic minorities.

"Love for one's mother tongue does not stand in the way of promoting other languages. - Pinarayi Vijayan"

Thiruvananthapuram, January 28

Kerala Chief Minister Pinarayi Vijayan said that the concerns raised by the Karnataka government over Kerala's decision to make Malayalam a compulsory first language in schools are baseless.

In a reply letter sent to Karnataka CM Siddaramiah, he pointed out that the legislation contains no provision that violates the constitutional rights of linguistic minorities.

The Kerala CM also dismissed allegations that the Malayalam language is being imposed in Kannada-medium schools, calling them unfounded. He clarified that while the law designates Malayalam as the official language, students whose mother tongue is not Malayalam are simply being given the opportunity to study it alongside their primary language.

The Chief Minister also clarified that, in line with the national curriculum, students are free to choose their preferred language. Those coming from other states or from abroad are not required to take Malayalam examinations at the Class 10 or higher secondary levels.

He further noted that linguistic minorities are permitted to use Tamil and Kannada for correspondence with government offices, and the law mandates that replies be issued in the same language. Love for one's mother tongue, he said, does not stand in the way of promoting other languages.

The legislation, Vijayan added, was framed while upholding the cultural ties between Kerala and Karnataka and the spirit of cooperative federalism. Protecting the constitutional rights of citizens is the responsibility of the legislature, which the Kerala government is fulfilling through this law, the Chief Minister said.

Earlier, Karnataka Chief Minister Siddaramaiah wrote to Kerala Chief Minister Pinarayi Vijayan, expressing grave concerns about the Malayalam Language Bill.

The Karnataka CM highlighted that the compulsion of making Malayalam the first language even in Kannada-medium schools, particularly in border districts such as Kasaragod, could undermine linguistic minority rights. He also stated that if passed, the bill will be opposed by Karnataka.

"I wish to convey my serious concern regarding the proposed Malayalam Language Bill, which mandates Malayalam as the compulsory first language even in Kannada-medium schools, particularly in the border districts such as Kasaragod," CM Siddaramaiah wrote in his letter on January 10.

In its appeal to the Kerala government, the Karnataka CM asked for reconsideration of the proposal, stating that Karnataka will oppose the bill if it is passed to protect linguistic minorities.

The letter stated, "I urge the Government of Kerala to reconsider the proposed approach and engage in a broader, inclusive dialogue with linguistic minority communities, educators and neighbouring States. Such engagement will reinforce India's unity while preserving the dignity of every language and every citizen. If this Bill is passed, Karnataka will oppose it by exercising every constitutional right available to us, in defence of linguistic minorities and the plural spirit of our Republic. This position flows not from confrontation, but from our duty to the Constitution and to the people whose voices must never be marginalised."

- ANI

Share this article:

Reader Comments

R
Rahul R
Karnataka's concerns seem a bit overblown. Every state has the right to promote its official language. The provisions for Tamil and Kannada in official correspondence show Kerala is being considerate. We need to trust our states to handle their linguistic affairs. 🇮🇳
S
Siddharth J
Respectfully, I have to side with Karnataka CM Siddaramaiah on this. Even the perception of imposition in border areas like Kasaragod can create unnecessary tension. While promoting Malayalam is good, the implementation must be absolutely clear and non-coercive to avoid any friction between our sister states.
M
Meera T
This is a sensible move by Kerala. Learning the local language helps integration and is practical for daily life. The exemptions for Class 10 exams are a good balance. Love for one's mother tongue and learning another can coexist, just like CM said.
D
David E
Interesting debate. As an outsider, it seems Kerala has built in safeguards. The key is how it's enforced on the ground. Dialogue between the states is always better than confrontation. Hope they find an amicable solution.
A
Aditya G
The spirit of cooperative federalism should prevail. Both CMs are right in their own way—one to protect state language, other to protect minority rights. The detailed provisions for replies in Tamil/Kannada are a positive step. Let's not make this a political issue.

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Minimum 50 characters 0/50