NewKerala.com

SC Stays HC Order, Clears Way for Kerala's Nava Kerala Survey

The Supreme Court has granted significant relief to the Kerala government by staying a Kerala High Court order that had halted the 'Nava Kerala Survey'. The apex court observed that governments are entitled to conduct such surveys to evaluate the impact of welfare schemes. It questioned the basis for judicial interference, stressing that political criticism alone cannot restrain governance functions. The court permitted the survey to continue but directed the state to submit a report detailing the estimated Rs 20 crore expenditure.

Key Points: Supreme Court Allows Kerala's Nava Kerala Survey to Proceed

  • SC stays HC order halting survey
  • Court backs govt's right to evaluate welfare schemes
  • Survey cost estimated at Rs 20 crore
  • HC had called survey unlawful
  • Next hearing on April 13
2 min read

Big relief for Vijayan govt as SC stays HC order, clears way for Nava Kerala Survey

Supreme Court stays Kerala HC order, permitting Vijayan govt's Nava Kerala Survey. Court backs state's right to evaluate welfare schemes.

"governments are entitled to undertake such surveys to evaluate the impact of schemes - Supreme Court Bench"

New Delhi, Feb 24

In a significant relief to the Government of Kerala, the Supreme Court on Tuesday stayed the interim order of the Kerala High Court that had halted the state's proposed 'Nava Kerala Survey', allowing the government to proceed with the exercise.

New Delhi, Feb 24 (IANS) In a significant relief to the Government of Kerala, the Supreme Court on Tuesday stayed the interim order of the Kerala High Court that had halted the state's proposed 'Nava Kerala Survey', allowing the government to proceed with the exercise.

The High Court had last week restrained the survey following petitions filed by leaders of the Kerala Students Union (KSU), who alleged that the data collection drive, undertaken ahead of elections, amounted to a politically motivated exercise funded by public money.

The High Court struck down the controversial 'Nava Kerala Survey', calling it unlawful and questioning how it was funded and executed. The Court had made it clear that there was neither a proper budget allocation nor a financial sanction for the programme.

Challenging the High Court's stay, the state government moved an appeal in the Supreme Court.

Appearing for the state, senior advocate Kapil Sibal contended that the government has the authority to assess how effectively welfare schemes are reaching beneficiaries and to collect data for administrative evaluation.

Accepting the broad thrust of this argument, the apex court observed that governments are entitled to undertake such surveys to evaluate the impact of schemes on which crores of rupees are spent.

The Bench questioned the basis for halting the exercise, asking what was wrong with gathering information to determine whether welfare programmes were yielding the intended results.

It underlined that political criticism of a survey cannot be the sole ground to restrain a state from performing governance functions.

The court also made pointed remarks against unwarranted judicial interference in administrative matters, stressing the need for restraint unless there is a clear constitutional violation.

While permitting the survey to continue, the Supreme Court directed the state government to submit a report detailing the expenditure involved, estimated at around Rs 20 crore.

The case has been posted for further hearing on April 13.

The ruling marks a crucial legal victory for the Pinarayi Vijayan government and reinforces the executive's authority to undertake policy evaluation exercises, even in politically sensitive periods.

- IANS

Share this article:

Reader Comments

P
Priyanka N
While I agree the government should evaluate schemes, the timing is suspicious. Right before elections? And 20 crores is a lot of money for a survey. The SC is right to ask for an expenditure report. Transparency is key.
R
Rahul R
As a Keralite, I welcome this. We need data-driven governance. How else will they know which areas need more focus? The opposition is just creating hurdles for the sake of it. Let the survey happen.
A
Anjali F
The Supreme Court's point about judicial restraint is very important. Courts shouldn't micromanage governance unless there's a clear violation. This sets a good precedent for other states too.
D
David E
Interesting case. The principle of evaluating welfare schemes is sound globally. But the HC's concerns about proper budgeting are also valid. The SC's balanced approach—allowing the survey with financial oversight—seems correct.
K
Karthik V
Victory for Vijayan govt, but the real victory should be for the people of Kerala. I hope this data is actually used to improve lives and not just become another political tool. We'll be watching.

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Minimum 50 characters 0/50