Kerala's 'War on the Poor': State to Lose Rs 1,600 Crore Annually in Rural Jobs Overhaul

Kerala's government is sounding the alarm over a proposed overhaul of the rural jobs scheme. The state's minister claims the changes will cripple their finances by shifting a massive burden onto them. He argues the new law dismantles the fundamental right to work that the original program guaranteed. The minister warns this move will effectively punish Kerala for its successful implementation of the scheme.

Key Points: Kerala Minister Slams MGNREGS Overhaul as War on Poor, Cites Rs 1600 Cr Loss

  • New bill replaces legal right to work with central targets and labour budgets
  • Funding shift to 60:40 ratio imposes Rs 1,600 crore annual burden on Kerala
  • Minister warns the change punishes efficient states that generate excess workdays
  • Bill removes Mahatma Gandhi's name, erasing the scheme's original spirit and intent
3 min read

'War on the poor': Kerala to lose Rs 1,600 crore annually with new rural jobs law, says minister

Kerala Minister M.B. Rajesh warns the new MGNREGS bill dismantles the right to work, shifting a Rs 1,600 crore annual burden onto the state and punishing its efficiency.

"The present Bill is the final step to dismantle the scheme altogether. - Minister M.B. Rajesh"

Thiruvananthapuram Dec 16

The Union government’s proposed overhaul of the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme (MGNREGS) amounts to a "declaration of war against ordinary citizens" and will severely cripple Kerala’s finances, as it stands to lose nearly Rs 1, 600 crore every year if the new law is implemented, Local Self-Government Minister M.B. Rajesh said on Tuesday.

Rajesh said the employment guarantee scheme was conceived during the first UPA government under sustained pressure from the Left and was designed as a demand-driven, rights-based programme.

"But systematic attempts to weaken it began during the second UPA regime and intensified after the BJP came to power. For the past decade, wages were delayed, arrears were allowed to pile up, and workdays were cut to discourage workers. The present Bill is the final step to dismantle the scheme altogether," he said.

The new Bill removes the very idea of a legal right to work, replacing it with employment based on Central targets and labour budgets, he said.

"The Centre is washing its hands of the responsibility to provide work," Rajesh alleged.

He noted out that while the Bill speaks of increasing workdays to 125, this would apply only to areas notified by the Centre, not all panchayats, rendering the promise largely meaningless.

A major concern, Rajesh said, was the change in the funding pattern to 60:40, shifting 40 per cent of the total cost to the states.

For Kerala, where MGNREGS expenditure averages Rs 4,000 crore annually, this would mean an additional burden of about Rs 1,600 crore.

"This is being imposed by a Centre already subjecting Kerala to financial strangulation," he said, adding that states would also have to bear the full cost of unemployment allowance and compensation for delayed wages.

Rajesh underlined Kerala’s exemplary performance under MGNREGS. In 2024–25, the state generated 9.07 crore person-days, spending over Rs 4,011 crore, and provided 100 days of work to over 5.19 lakh families, securing second place nationally.

In the current financial year, Kerala has already exceeded the approved labour budget of 5 crore person-days by generating 5.53 crore days.

"Earlier, the central law protected states that generated work based on demand. The new Bill punishes efficiency by forcing states to pay for excess work," he said.

The Minister also flagged progressive reductions in Central allocations, Aadhaar-based verification challenges in tribal and remote areas, restrictions on work during agricultural seasons, and provisions allowing the Centre to block funds on preliminary complaints.

He criticised the removal of Mahatma Gandhi’s name from the scheme, saying it symbolised the Centre’s intent to erase the programme’s original spirit.

"The employment guarantee scheme prevented starvation during the Covid-19 crisis and protected millions of rural families. The Centre must withdraw this Bill," Rajesh said, warning that its implementation would dismantle one of India’s most critical social security programmes.

- IANS

Share this article:

Reader Comments

P
Priya S
As someone who has studied rural development, this is a classic case of weakening a rights-based program. Changing it from a legal guarantee to a target-based scheme removes accountability. The minister is right - it dismantles the core idea.
R
Robert G
While I understand the concerns about state finances, maybe there is a need for reform? The article mentions Kerala exceeded its labour budget. If every state does that, the central kitty will be empty. Some fiscal responsibility is needed, but the 60:40 split seems harsh.
A
Anjali F
Removing Gandhiji's name says everything. This scheme was about dignity of labour and right to work. Now it will become another bureaucratic program where help reaches only "notified areas". What about the poor in other panchayats? Heartbreaking.
K
Karthik V
Kerala always performs well in social schemes, and this feels like a punishment for that efficiency. Rs 1600 crore is a massive hole in the state budget. Will have to cut other welfare programs. The ones who will suffer are the daily wage workers. Very short-sighted policy.
M
Meera T
The Aadhaar-based verification point is crucial. In tribal areas, connectivity is poor and many don't have updated documents. They will be excluded. This isn't reform, it's exclusion. The Centre must listen to the states on the ground reality.

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Minimum 50 characters 0/50