Manoj Muntashir Shukla slams Anurag Kashyap over alleged casteist remark

ANI April 20, 2025 269 views

Manoj Muntashir Shukla fiercely condemned Anurag Kashyap for his alleged casteist remarks, defending Brahmin heritage. Kashyap later apologized, clarifying his words were misconstrued. Police complaints have been lodged against the filmmaker. The debate continues to spark outrage on social media.

"If you have less income, control expenses; if you have less knowledge, control words." – Manoj Muntashir Shukla
Mumbai, April 20: In a fiery response to filmmaker Anurag Kashyap's alleged casteist remarks, renowned lyricist and poet Manoj Muntashir Shukla has strongly condemned the filmmaker, accusing him of attacking the Brahmin community.

Key Points

1

Shukla accuses Kashyap of attacking Brahmin community

2

Lists historical Brahmin icons in challenge

3

Kashyap apologizes for misinterpretation

4

Police complaints filed over alleged hate speech

The issue stems from an earlier social media post by Kashyap, which criticised the ongoing controversy surrounding his upcoming film 'Phule', a biopic of social reformer Jyotirao Phule.

Taking to his official X account, Manoj Muntashir Shukla delivered a direct message to Kashyap in a video saying, "If you have less income, then you have to control your expenses, and if you have less knowledge, then you have to control your words. Anurag Kashyap, you have less income and less knowledge, so control both."

He further admonished Kashyap for his alleged remarks, adding, "You don't have enough water in your body to pollute the entire legacy of Brahmins."

In his message, Shukla challenged Kashyap to name a Brahmin figure from history whom he believed deserved to be insulted, listing prominent figures such as Acharya Chanakya, Peshwa Bajirao, and the legendary poet Tansen, among others.

"The proud tradition of Brahmins will not end. I, a Brahmin, give you an open challenge. Choose one name from the 21 I have listed and let me know," Shukla said.

https://x.com/manojmuntashir/status/1913578200287883743?s=48&t=pGU8BerQmkbmBgzLSg580g

Shukla's post went on to describe Brahmins as the "honour of India" and denounced Kashyap's comments as "heartless thoughts."

He added, "A Brahmin may forgive your heartless thoughts, but the Hindu society will never forgive you for dividing the country."

The poet further expressed his willingness to pray for Kashyap's "sick mind" and offered to take responsibility for any treatment Kashyap may need.

"#AnuragKashyap ko meri khuli chetawani," he captioned the video.

The controversy has escalated as police complaints have been filed against Kashyap. On Saturday, a complaint was lodged in Indore by Anoop Shukla, accusing Kashyap of hurting the social and religious sentiments of the Brahmin community.

Vijay Singh Sisodia, the Police Station In-Charge of MG Road PS, confirmed that an investigation is underway.

Advocate Ashish Rai has also demanded swift action from the Mumbai Police Commissioner, emphasizing that Kashyap's statements fall under the category of hate speech.

"There is a citation from the Supreme Court which mandates action in cases of hate speech on social media. These statements are highly condemnable," Rai said, following the filing of a complaint with the Mumbai Police.

Kashyap issued an apology on Friday night, clarifying that his statement had been taken out of context.

He acknowledged the threats his family and friends had received but maintained that his apology was specifically for the misinterpretation of his words, not the content of the original post.

"This is my apology, not for my post, but for that one line taken out of context and the brewing hatred... So, if it's an apology you're looking for, then this is my apology," Kashyap wrote.

He also urged the Brahmin community to refrain from targeting his family members and to direct their anger toward him alone.

"Brahmins, please spare the women even the scriptures teach this much decency," he added.

Reader Comments

R
Rahul K.
Strong words from Manoj Muntashir! While freedom of speech is important, we must be careful not to hurt sentiments of any community. Both sides need to show restraint. 🙏
P
Priya S.
Why does every debate in India turn into a caste issue? Can't we just appreciate art without bringing communities into it? Both artists should focus on their crafts instead of this drama.
A
Amit D.
Respectfully disagree with Manoj ji here. While Kashyap may have been insensitive, listing historical Brahmin figures feels like whataboutism. The focus should be on current issues, not past glory.
S
Sunita M.
As a Brahmin woman, I'm uncomfortable with how both men are talking. One shouldn't generalize communities, and the other shouldn't make it sound like we need defending. We're capable individuals, not some fragile legacy!
V
Vikram R.
The real issue here is how quickly social media amplifies conflicts. Both have valid points but the extreme language from both sides isn't helping. Hope they can have a civilized discussion offline.
N
Neha T.
I admire Manoj ji's passion but his video felt more like an attack than a constructive response. We need bridge-builders, not more division. Also, threats to Kashyap's family are completely unacceptable! 😠

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Your email won't be published


Disclaimer: Comments here reflect the author's views alone. Insulting or using offensive language against individuals, communities, religion, or the nation is illegal.

Tags: