Key Points

Shashi Tharoor criticized the misuse of legal processes, calling out frivolous and politically motivated cases. He referenced a defamation case against him, which the Supreme Court suggested be withdrawn. Tharoor clarified his book merely quoted a 2011 article, not targeting any individual. He also refrained from commenting on Rahul Gandhi's controversial remarks on the US economy.

Key Points: Shashi Tharoor Slams Politically Motivated Frivolous Legal Cases

  • Tharoor highlights judicial overburden from frivolous cases
  • Supreme Court asked BJP leader to withdraw defamation case
  • Case linked to 2011 article quote in Tharoor's book
  • Tharoor avoids commenting on Rahul Gandhi's Trump remark
2 min read

Legal process itself becomes punishment: Tharoor slams political motives behind frivolous cases

Congress MP Tharoor criticizes misuse of judiciary, says legal process itself becomes punishment in politically motivated cases.

"The problem in our system is that too many frivolous cases are allowed to function, and then the process itself becomes the punishment. – Shashi Tharoor"

Mumbai, August 2

Congress MP Shashi Tharoor pm Saturday criticised the misuse of judicial processes, emphasising that the Indian legal system has become overburdened by "frivolous" and "politically motivated cases, where "the process itself becomes the punishment."

Tharoor made the remarks after the Supreme Court reportedly asked a BJP leader to consider withdrawing a defamation case filed against him.

"The problem in our system is that too many frivolous cases are allowed to function, and then the process itself becomes the punishment. Is the judiciary's time spent on worthwhile cases, or are many of our judges wasting a significant amount of time on frivolous cases often pursued for political motives?" he asked while speaking to mediapersons in Mumbai.

The defamation case in question was linked to a reference Tharoor had made in a book, which quoted a 2011 article referencing a statement by an RSS figure.

"I wasn't targeting PM Modi. I wasn't targeting anyone. I had written a book in which I had quoted an article published in 2011, which in turn quoted a statement by an individual in those days in the RSS, who subsequently rehabilitated in the BJP and served as the in-charge of the BJP in eastern UP," he told reporters in Mumbai.

He added that the case had been filed against him six years later, saying, "I was quoting a quote. So it was not surprising that the Court said to drop the case."

Tharoor today refused to comment on party leader Rahul Gandhi's endorsing US President Donald Trump's 'dead economy' remark about India and said the Leader of Opposition in Lok Sabha may have had his "own reasons" for saying so.

Speaking to the mediapersons, Tharoor said, "I don't want to comment on what my party leader has said. He has his reasons for saying so. My concern is that our relationship with the US, as a strategic and economic partnership, is important for us. We are exporting around 90 billion worth of goods to America. We can't be in a position to lose that or have it diminish significantly."

- ANI

Share this article:

Reader Comments

P
Priyanka N
As someone who has been fighting a property case for 8 years, I completely agree with Dr. Tharoor. The legal process IS the punishment in India. Our courts need urgent reforms to prevent this misuse. Justice delayed is justice denied!
A
Amit K
While I respect Tharoor's intellect, isn't it ironic that Congress leaders are talking about political cases when they filed so many during UPA era? Pot calling the kettle black? 🤔
S
Shweta Y
The real issue is our defamation laws need reform. In other democracies, public figures have thicker skin. Here every criticism becomes a court case. We need to balance free speech and reputation better 🇮🇳
N
Nikhil C
Tharoor is absolutely right! The BJP leader should have read the book properly before filing the case. This is just harassment politics. Our courts should impose heavy fines on such frivolous litigations to deter others.
M
Meera T
I appreciate that Tharoor didn't criticize Rahul Gandhi openly but maintained party discipline. That's rare in today's politics where everyone wants to give bytes. Shows his maturity as a leader. 👏

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Minimum 50 characters 0/50