Key Points

The opposition staged a walkout during Amit Shah's Rajya Sabha speech, sparking a heated debate. Pralhad Joshi accused them of fleeing due to fear of exposure on terrorism links. Shah countered Chidambaram's claims on decisive wars, questioning Congress' anti-terror record. Kharge demanded PM Modi's presence, calling his absence an insult to the House. The debate highlighted deep political divisions over national security.

Key Points: Amit Shah Exposes Opposition Walkout in Rajya Sabha Debate

  • Opposition MPs staged walkout during Amit Shah's Rajya Sabha speech
  • Joshi links walkout to Congress' alleged terror support history
  • Shah challenges Chidambaram on decisive war claims
  • Kharge demands PM Modi's presence, calls absence an insult
4 min read

They know they stand exposed every time Amit Shah speaks: Pralhad Joshi on opposition's walkout from Rajya Sabha

Pralhad Joshi slams opposition walkout during Amit Shah's speech, calling it fear of exposure on terrorism and naxalism links.

"They know they stand exposed every time Amit Shah speaks up, and that is why they get scared and run away. – Pralhad Joshi"

New Delhi, July 30

Reacting to the opposition staging a walkout from the Rajya Sabha during Union Home Minister Amit Shah's speech, Union Minister Pralhad Joshi said that they knew they would be exposed every time Amit Shah spoke, and they get scared and run away.

Opposition MPs staged a walkout on Wednesday from the Rajya Sabha after a heated altercation between Union Home Minister Amit Shah and Leader of Opposition in the House Mallikarjun Kharge over Prime Minister Narendra Modi's absence during the proceedings.

Speaking to ANI, Pralhad Joshi said, "What I think is, they had already decided because of the mistakes they made, especially the statement made by P Chidambaram, Rahul Gandhi's speech, and Akhilesh Yadav's statement. They have a history of supporting terrorism and naxalism. They know they stand exposed every time Amit Shah speaks up, and that is why they get scared and run away. They don't have the patience and the courage to listen to a reply."

Union Home Minister Amit Shah on Wednesday said the senior Congress leader P Chidambaram should tell whether the wars between India and Pakistan in 1965 and 1971 were "decisive" enough, as terrorism still continued over the decades post-conflict.

Amit Shah responded to Chidambaram's remark after the former Home Minister in Rajya Sabha stated that only time will tell whether Operation Sindoor was "decisive" or not.

Speaking during the debate on Operation Sindoor in the Rajya Sabha, Amit Shah said, "Chidambaram sahib yesterday stated that it cannot be said that Operation Sindoor was decisive. I want to ask him whether the 1965 and 1971 wars were decisive. If they were decisive, then why did terrorism continue to spread? For all these years, no action was taken to intimidate them (terrorists), so why would they have been afraid?"

Opposition MPs led by Kharge demanded that the Prime Minister come to the Upper House and brief them on Operation Sindoor as he did on Tuesday in the Lok Sabha.

Kharge said that PM Modi should have come to the House, as many of the Opposition's questions were directly related to him."It was already the demand of the members of this House that, after a 16-hour-long discussion, the Prime Minister should come here and present his views, especially since many of our questions are directly related to him. I am not saying that you (Amit Shah) are not capable of responding, but if the Prime Minister is present and still doesn't come to this House, then it is an insult to the House. It is not right to insult the House," the Rajya Sabha LoP said.

Replying to this, Deputy Chairman of the House, Harivansh said, "Mr. Kharge, I would like to inform you that I have already explained that any minister from the government side can respond, this is the ruling. You cannot force anyone."Reacting to this, Amit Shah said that Mallikarjun Kharge is raising this point, who is not allowed by his own party to speak on important matters."Mr. Kharge is raising this issue, even though his own party (Congress) doesn't allow him to speak on important matters," Shah said.

The Rajya Sabha LoP again stood up and said to the Deputy Chairman, "You interrupt on every point."The Opposition MPs then staged a walkout from the House.

Targeting them, Amit Shah said that the opposition members simply cannot stand to listen to this debate, as they were unable to stop terrorism for so many years.

"The opposition's demand is not justified because in the Business Advisory Committee meeting, it was decided that the discussion can go on as long as you want, but it is up to the government to decide who will respond," Shah said.

"I know why they are leaving -- because for so many years, in the name of protecting their vote bank, they did nothing to stop terrorism. They simply cannot stand to listen to this debate," he added.

- ANI

Share this article:

Reader Comments

S
Shreya M
The opposition's behavior is childish. If you disagree, counter with facts, don't run away! This is not how democracy works.
A
Arjun K
While I support the government, I feel both sides should maintain decorum. Walkouts and personal remarks don't help anyone.
P
Priya S
The PM should have addressed Rajya Sabha too. Equal respect should be shown to both houses of Parliament. 🤔
V
Vikram J
Shah's arguments about past wars and terrorism were brilliant! Congress has no answers for their weak policies during UPA era.
N
Neha R
As a neutral voter, I'm tired of this constant bickering. Can't our leaders focus on real issues like inflation and jobs?
K
Karan T
The way Amit Shah dismantles opposition arguments is masterclass! No wonder they prefer to walk out than face him.
D
Divya L
Both

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Minimum 50 characters 0/50