Kerala LoP Warns Meta: Don't Block Viral Sabarimala Gold Theft Parody Song

Kerala's Leader of Opposition has taken a firm stand on a viral online issue. V.D. Satheesan has written to Meta, the parent company of Facebook and Instagram, asking them not to remove links to a satirical song about the Sabarimala gold theft case. He argues that doing so without a direct court order would be an unconstitutional restraint on free speech and expression. This move highlights the growing tension between online satire and police powers in the state.

Key Points: VD Satheesan Urges Meta Not to Remove Sabarimala Parody Song

  • Satheesan cites Supreme Court rulings protecting free speech from arbitrary curbs
  • He argues parody is protected artistic expression under the Constitution
  • The letter warns police requests without court orders set a censorship precedent
  • Satheesan says takedowns must follow judicial scrutiny or Meta's own standards
2 min read

Kerala LoP Satheesan writes to Meta, requesting not to block viral Sabarimala gold theft parody song

Kerala's Leader of Opposition writes to Meta, arguing that removing the viral 'Pottiye Kettiye' song without a court order violates free speech.

"In a democracy governed by the rule of law, any restriction on speech must strictly adhere to due process. - V.D. Satheesan"

Thiruvananthapuram, Dec 19

Leader of Opposition in the Kerala Assembly V.D. Satheesan has written to Meta Platforms Inc., urging the social media major not to remove links to a satirical song linked to the alleged gold theft parody at the Sabarimala temple, warning that any takedown without a court order would amount to unconstitutional restraint on free speech.

In his letter, Satheesan referred to reports suggesting that the Kerala Police had approached social media platforms, including those operated by Meta, seeking the removal of links to the song titled “Pottiye Kettiye”, which has been circulating online in connection with the alleged disappearance of gold from the Sabarimala temple premises.

The Opposition leader noted that the Thiruvananthapuram Cyber Police have registered a case in connection with the creation and circulation of the song.

However, he underlined that there is, as of now, no judicial verdict, court order or statutory direction mandating the removal of the content.

Citing consistent rulings of the Supreme Court, Satheesan said the right to freedom of speech and expression could not be curtailed unless a clear and legally established violation of law was demonstrated.

In a democracy governed by the rule of law, he argued, any restriction on speech must strictly adhere to due process.

Satheesan emphasised that parody and satire are well-recognised forms of artistic expression protected under the Constitution, subject only to reasonable restrictions imposed through lawful and judicially sanctioned means.

He cautioned that administrative or police requests, in the absence of a competent court order, should not form the basis for content removal.

Such actions, he warned, could amount to prior restraint, set an unhealthy precedent for censorship and cause irreparable harm to content creators.

Allowing law-enforcement agencies to secure takedowns without judicial scrutiny would erode constitutional safeguards and chill legitimate expression, the letter said.

In this context, Satheesan urged Meta to refrain from removing or disabling access to links related to the song unless a competent court of law issues a clear and specific directive to that effect.

Alternatively, he said, Meta could act only if, upon an independent assessment, the content is found to be in clear violation of its own Community Standards.

The letter comes amid heightened political controversy surrounding the alleged Sabarimala gold theft and growing concerns over the use of police powers to curb online criticism and satire in Kerala.

- IANS

Share this article:

Reader Comments

R
Rohit P
While I support free speech, we must be careful when it comes to religious sentiments. Sabarimala is a very sacred place for millions. The song might be funny to some, but it could hurt devotees. The authorities should find a balanced way.
A
Aman W
The real issue is the alleged gold theft! Instead of chasing a song, the police should focus on finding out what happened to the temple's gold. This feels like a distraction from the main issue. #SabarimalaGoldTheft
S
Sarah B
As someone who follows Indian politics, this is a classic move. The ruling party tries to suppress criticism, the opposition defends free speech. The cycle continues. Meta should stick to its own global standards and not bow to local pressure without a court order.
K
Karthik V
I heard the song. It's actually quite clever and highlights the administration's failure. Art has always been a tool for social commentary in India. If there's no court order, it should stay up. Freedom of expression is non-negotiable.
N
Nikhil C
Respectfully, I think the LoP is politicizing this. The police have registered a case, which means they see a potential violation. Let the investigation proceed. If the content is illegal, it should be removed. We can't have absolute free speech if it breaks laws.

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Minimum 50 characters 0/50