Key Points

Former Manchester City goalkeeper Joe Hart has come out in defense of Alexander Isak's controversial move from Newcastle to Liverpool. Hart argues that football clubs regularly disregard contracts when it benefits them, so players should have similar freedom. He specifically pointed to how clubs isolate players from first-team training when they want to force them out. Meanwhile, former striker Chris Sutton condemned both Isak and his replacement Yoane Wissa for what he called "disgraceful" contract behavior.

Key Points: Joe Hart Defends Isak Liverpool Move After Newcastle Contract Standoff

  • Joe Hart argues clubs frequently break contracts when convenient for them
  • Hart says players deserve same freedom to pursue moves as clubs enjoy
  • Alexander Isak refused to play for Newcastle to force Liverpool transfer
  • Chris Sutton calls Isak and Wissa's contract behavior disgraceful and disrespectful
2 min read

'When it doesn't suit the club, contracts mean nothing': Joe Hart backs Isak's forced move to Liverpool

Joe Hart defends Alexander Isak's forced Liverpool move, arguing clubs break contracts when it suits them. Former keeper says players deserve same freedom as clubs.

"When it doesn't suit the club the contract means nothing - Joe Hart"

New Delhi, Sep 2

Former Manchester City goalkeeper Joe Hart has defended Alexander Isak’s manner of leaving Newcastle United and forcing a move to Liverpool for a record Premier League fee.

Isak refused to continue playing at Newcastle and was left out of the pre-season training and the opening three Premier League fixtures while also having to train away from the first team.

Hart pointed out how clubs have not shown loyalty in the past when it comes to contracts hence why should the players respect the commitment.

‘If football was fair then he acted unacceptably. If everyone honoured their contracts, football clubs included, this is how we are going to do it, equal opportunity, play while you continue to get paid and then shake hands, great,” said Hart to BBC.

”But everyone knows it doesn't work like that. We have all been stomped on when it suited someone else. What's wrong with Alexander Isak standing up and saying, "I want to go to Liverpool"?

“You can say that you want the contract to mean something but it doesn't, because he's gone to Liverpool. I'm sure Isak doesn't care what any of us think right now.

“When it doesn't suit the club the contract means nothing. Go and sit in that dressing room, don't train when we come in, all of those things happen. So why when it's the other way around do we need to respect the contract."

On the other hand, the former Premier League striker Chris Sutton believes the actions of Isak and Yoane Wissa, who joined Newcastle as a replacement for the Swede in a similar manner, were ‘disgraceful’

“Players sign contracts, people in their everyday lives sign contracts and you adhere to those contracts. It is absolutely despicable what they [Alexander Isak and Yoane Wissa] have done. They may well be happy tonight, but it is a disgraceful way to behave.

“Eddie Howe with Isak and his career - Isak owes Howe a hell of a lot, but he has treated him with total disrespect. Saying that, Newcastle have signed Wissa who has done the same as what Isak has done,” said Sutton to BBC.

- IANS

Share this article:

Reader Comments

P
Priya S
As an Indian football fan, I see both sides. Contracts should mean something, but clubs break them too. Maybe we need better regulations to protect both players and clubs. 🤔
A
Arjun K
Hart is absolutely right! Indian clubs do the same - release players when they want. Isak just used the same tactics clubs use. Why the double standard? 🤷‍♂️
S
Sarah B
While I understand Hart's perspective, this sets a bad precedent. If every player starts forcing moves, football will become chaotic. There has to be some professionalism.
V
Vikram M
Typical elite football drama! In India, players rarely have this power. Maybe our players should learn to stand up for themselves like Isak did. 💪
M
Michael C
Respect to Joe Hart for speaking truth. Clubs bench players, freeze them out, terminate contracts when they want. Players should have the same rights. Fair is fair!

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Minimum 50 characters 0/50