NCERT Textbook Row: Pradhan Regrets "Corruption in Judiciary" Chapter

Union Education Minister Dharmendra Pradhan has expressed regret and directed the NCERT to withdraw a Class 8 Social Science textbook containing a sub-chapter on "Corruption in the judiciary". The Supreme Court has issued show cause notices to senior Education Ministry and NCERT officials, calling the inclusion a serious matter. The court has imposed a blanket ban on the section and demanded detailed records of the committee that approved it. The CJI observed that the portrayal of the judiciary as corrupt was part of a "deep-rooted, well-planned, and orchestrated conspiracy".

Key Points: NCERT Textbook Row: Pradhan Regrets, SC Issues Notices

  • SC issues show cause notices to officials
  • Pradhan directs NCERT to withdraw books
  • Chapter titled "Corruption in the judiciary"
  • CJI calls it a "calculated move"
3 min read

"We respect judiciary, action will be taken": Education Minister over NCERT class 8 textbook row

Education Minister Dharmendra Pradhan expresses regret as Supreme Court issues notices over controversial "Corruption in judiciary" chapter in Class 8 textbook.

"We respect the judiciary. Whatever happened is unfortunate. - Dharmendra Pradhan"

Jamshedpur, February 26

Union Education Minister Dharmendra Pradhan on Thursday supported the Supreme Court of India issuing show cause notices to senior officials of the Education Ministry and the National Council of Educational Research and Training over a sub-chapter titled "Corruption in the judiciary" in a Class 8 Social Science textbook.

Expressing "regret" on behalf of the government and the Education Ministry, Pradhan said that he directed the NCERT to withdraw and cancel all books.

Speaking to ANI here, Pradhan said, "We respect the judiciary. Whatever happened is unfortunate. I express regret on behalf of the govt as well as on a personal level. As soon as I came to know 2 days back, I directed the NCERT to withdraw and cancel all books. We have no intention for contempt of our judicial system. Whatever the Supreme Court ordered will be followed. I have given responsibility to my department secretary that action be taken against whoever added such an irresponsible chapter in the NCERT book. We are taking this very seriously."

The Union Minister said the observations by the Supreme Court are very "agreeable to us."

"The mention of Supreme Court and India's judicial system in the NCERT is a matter of concern. When this came to our knowledge, we made NCERT review the books. The observations by the Supreme Court today are very agreeable to us. I express regret over this. Action will be taken against the NCERT officials concerned. Govt will see to it that this situation does not occur again," Pradhan told reporters.

The controversy erupted after the top court took exception to the inclusion of the sub-chapter in the Class 8 Social Science textbook, observing that such content may have serious implications.

Earlier today, the Supreme Court issued show cause notices to the Secretary of the Department of Education and Literacy (Ministry of Education) and NCERT Director Dinesh Prashad Saklani, asking them to explain why action should not be taken under contempt or other laws for including a sub-chapter titled "Corruption in the judiciary" in the Class 8 NCERT Social Science textbook.

A bench comprising Chief Justice of India Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi, and Justice Vipul M Pancholi refused to halt suo motu proceedings despite NCERT's apology over the controversial inclusion and imposed a blanket ban on the textbook section. The court warned that any attempt to bypass the order would be considered direct interference with the administration of justice and could attract contempt of court.

The Supreme Court has also directed NCERT to submit detailed records of the Teaching-Learning Materials Committee that approved the chapter, including the names, qualifications, and credentials of all members of the development team.

"They have fired the gun and the judiciary is bleeding today. Today, anybody can say anything. At times, there is a mounting attack on us, and we are aware of it. The material is available online, on the internet, and even in stores. This is a very calculated move -- the entire teaching will be dictated. When you look at how the Indian judiciary is portrayed as corrupt, it becomes evident what message is being sent. The entire teaching community will first be instructed that this is what they have to teach. In reality, not a single section of society has been left untouched. It is a deep-rooted, well-planned, and orchestrated conspiracy," the CJI said.

NCERT had earlier issued an apology and stated that it would review and revise the chapter following proper consultation, acknowledging that the reference to corruption was inappropriate.

- ANI

Share this article:

Reader Comments

P
Priya S
While respecting the judiciary is paramount, I'm a bit concerned. Shouldn't education also encourage critical thinking? The chapter title seems problematic, but a balanced discussion on accountability in all institutions, including judiciary, is needed for mature citizenship. 🤔
R
Rohit P
The CJI's words are very strong – "the judiciary is bleeding". This shows how serious the issue is. Who are these committee members who approved this? Their names and credentials must come out. This is about safeguarding our nation's future.
S
Sarah B
As a parent, I'm shocked. What were they thinking putting such a chapter for 13-year-olds? Education should build character and national pride. Glad the government acted fast. The apology from NCERT is not enough, accountability is a must.
V
Vikram M
The process failed at multiple levels. First the authors, then the review committee, then the publishers. How did no one raise a red flag? This calls for a complete overhaul of the textbook approval mechanism. Jai Hind!
K
Karthik V
With all due respect, the reaction seems disproportionate. The chapter was about 'corruption in the judiciary', not 'the judiciary is corrupt'. There's a difference. We teach kids about corruption in other sectors. Why is this topic untouchable? Are we not allowed to discuss improvements?

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Minimum 50 characters 0/50