US Envoy Slams Tucker Carlson's "Odious" Jewish Conspiracy Theory

US Ambassador to Israel Mike Huckabee has publicly criticized commentator Tucker Carlson for promoting what he calls an "odious conspiracy theory" about Jewish ancestry during an interview. Huckabee specifically denounced the "Khazar hypothesis," which suggests Ashkenazi Jews descend from a Turkic kingdom, calling it a weaponized narrative to delegitimize Jewish people. The interview also sparked an international crisis when Huckabee suggested Israel could rightfully expand its borders across large parts of the Middle East. Fourteen Arab and Islamic nations have issued a joint statement strongly condemning these remarks as dangerous, inflammatory, and a violation of international law.

Key Points: US Envoy Huckabee Condemns Tucker Carlson Over "Fake Jews" Theory

  • Huckabee condemns "Khazar hypothesis" as dangerous
  • Theory claims Ashkenazi Jews are not from ancient Israel
  • Remarks triggered backlash from 14 Arab/Islamic nations
  • Huckabee suggested Israel could expand its borders
  • Joint statement calls comments a threat to regional stability
4 min read

''Odious conspiracy theory'': US Envoy Mike Huckabee slams Tucker Carlson over 'Khazaria' theory and 'fake Jews' narrative

US Ambassador to Israel Mike Huckabee denounces Tucker Carlson for platforming the "Khazaria" conspiracy theory, sparking a major diplomatic backlash from Arab states.

"What I wasn't anticipating was a lengthy series of questions where he seemed to be insinuating that the Jews of today aren't really same people as the Jews of the Bible. - Mike Huckabee"

Washington, DC, February 22

United States Ambassador to Israel Mike Huckabee has launched a scathing critique against commentator Tucker Carlson, accusing him of platforming a ''dangerous conspiracy theory'' intended to delegitimise the Jewish people.

The dispute follows a sit-down interview between the two, which Huckabee claims took an unexpected turn into fringe historical theories.

Taking to the social media platform X to address the fallout, the Ambassador stated, ''When I sat down with Tucker Carlson on Wednesday, I was expecting a thoughtful conversation and that he would ask questions and give me the opportunity to actually respond--just like he did with the little Nazi sympathizer Nick Fuentes or the guy who thought Hitler was the good guy and Churchill the bad guy.''

The Ambassador expressed surprise at the line of questioning regarding Jewish ancestry, noting, ''What I wasn't anticipating was a lengthy series of questions where he seemed to be insinuating that the Jews of today aren't really same people as the Jews of the Bible.''

Huckabee specifically targeted the ''Khazar hypothesis,'' a theory suggesting that Ashkenazi Jews are descendants of a Turkic kingdom rather than ancient Israelites.

He noted that ''the discredited idea that most Ashkenazi or European Jews descended from the ancient Turkic Kingdom of Khazaria is bunk.''

The Ambassador warned that this narrative is an ''odious conspiracy theory'' that has been ''weaponised by people trying to deligitimize Jews, to strip them of their history, and to call them 'imposters' or 'fake Jews.'''

He added that this idea is ''peddled by the likes of Candace Owens and Nick Fuentes'' and by ''Islamist accounts that make up false smears about Israel non-stop and are run out of countries like Pakistan and Turkey.''

Defending the historical and genetic lineage of the Jewish people, Huckabee asserted that ''the Jews of today can trace their lineage back thousands of years to Israel and the Jewish people of the Bible.''

However, this same interview has triggered a separate international crisis, as fourteen Arab and Islamic countries, alongside the secretariats of the Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC), the League of Arab States (LAS), and the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation (OIC), have strongly condemned statements made by the Ambassador.

The joint backlash follows the televised broadcast during which Huckabee suggested that Israel possesses the right to extend its borders across significant portions of the Middle East.

The discussion centred on the geographical boundaries of Israel and historical territorial claims.

During the exchange, Carlson questioned the Ambassador regarding the concept of a land spanning from the Euphrates River in Iraq to the Nile River in Egypt and whether the modern State of Israel could claim that specific lineage.

Responding to the enquiry, Huckabee stated, ''It would be fine if they took it all.''

In a joint statement issued on Saturday night from Doha, the Ministries of Foreign Affairs of Qatar, Egypt, Jordan, the United Arab Emirates, Indonesia, Pakistan, Turkiye, Saudi Arabia, Kuwait, Oman, Bahrain, Lebanon, Syria, and the State of Palestine described these as ''dangerous and inflammatory'' remarks.

They expressed ''profound concern'' and ''strong condemnation,'' noting that the comments indicate ''it would be acceptable for Israel to exercise control over territories belonging to Arab states, including the occupied West Bank.''

The signatories categorically rejected the statements, affirming that ''Israel has no sovereignty whatsoever over the Occupied Palestinian Territory or any other occupied Arab lands.''

They stated that such remarks constitute a ''flagrant violation of the principles of international law and the Charter of the United Nations'' and ''pose a grave threat to the security and stability of the region.''

The vast territory described in the interview would encompass modern-day Lebanon, Syria, Jordan, and parts of Saudi Arabia.

The joint declaration warned that ''the continuation of Israel's expansionist policies and unlawful measures will only inflame violence and conflict in the region'' and ''undermine the prospects for peace.''

The Ministries further stressed that these remarks ''directly contradict the vision put forward by US President Donald Trump, as well as the US Comprehensive Plan to End the Gaza Conflict,'' which are based on containing escalation and creating a political horizon for an independent Palestinian state.

Amidst the growing firestorm, the Ambassador later appeared to moderate his position, characterising his earlier remark as ''somewhat of a hyperbolic statement.''

He further noted that Israel is not seeking to enlarge its current territory and emphasised that the nation has a right to security within the land it currently holds.

Despite this, the Ministries called for ''an end to these incendiary statements,'' underscoring that remarks seeking to ''legitimise control over the lands of others'' fuel tensions rather than advancing peace.

- ANI

Share this article:

Reader Comments

R
Rahul R
Huckabee is right to call out the Khazaria conspiracy theory. It's pure nonsense and has been used to attack Jewish identity for decades. But he completely undermined his own credibility with his expansionist comments. You can't fight hate speech while promoting land grabs. Very disappointing.
S
Sarah B
The whole interview is a mess. Tucker Carlson platforms extremists, and the Ambassador walks into the trap and makes things worse. The Arab and Islamic world's united condemnation shows how dangerous this is. Hope the US administration clarifies its position soon.
A
Aman W
From an Indian perspective, we understand complex histories and origins. Debating who is a "real Jew" based on some medieval kingdom is absurd. But the real issue is the Ambassador's comment on borders. That's what will have real-world consequences for millions of people.
K
Kavitha C
This is why diplomacy requires careful words. The Ambassador tried to correct one conspiracy by accidentally endorsing another dangerous idea—that of limitless expansion. The joint statement from so many nations, including Indonesia and Pakistan, is a serious diplomatic rebuke. He should apologise properly.
D
David E
Calling it "hyperbolic" after the fact isn't good enough. When you represent your country, every word is measured. The Khazar theory is hateful, but so is casually suggesting annexation of sovereign nations. Both sides of this interview promoted toxic ideas.

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Minimum 50 characters 0/50