Maha govt orders probe into Kandivali Mathadi land deal, to reclaim 26,900 sq m surplus plot
Mumbai, July 2
The Maharashtra government on Thursday admitted that conditions governing the transfer and redevelopment of a 27-acre land parcel in Kandivali, originally earmarked for Mathadi workers, had been violated and announced a comprehensive probe into the matter.
Replying to a starred question raised by MLA Haroon Khan in the Legislative Assembly, Revenue Minister Chandrashekhar Bawankule said directions would be issued to the District Collector to reclaim 26,900 square metres of unconstructed surplus government land that was included in the redevelopment arrangement without prior permission.
Originally, 27 acres of land under Survey No 149 in Kandivali (Borivali taluka) was allotted to the Cloth Market and Shops Board. It was subsequently transferred to the 'Vishal Sahyadri Co-operative Housing Society.'
Under this arrangement, 11,254 sq meters of land went to the Vishal Society, 334 sq meters to a Ganesh Temple, 2,000 sq meters to the Rayat Shikshan Sanstha, and the remaining 99,116 sq meters were leased to the Vishal Sahyadri Society.
During the conversion of this Class-II land to Class-I status, the government had collected Rs 42.07 crore as premium and Rs 74.09 crore as stamp duty, said the Minister.
Bawankule said violations were detected in relation to extensions granted for construction deadlines, commercial use of the land and subsequent transfers. While Rs 21.67 crore had earlier been recovered to regularise some of these breaches, legal and procedural irregularities remained.
"The Inspector General of Registration (IGR), Pune, will conduct an inquiry into the stamp duty irregularities and loopholes within the next 15 days. The entire data determining whether there was any manipulation at the lower administrative levels will reach the government in 7 to 15 days," Minister Bawankule stated.
Furthermore, because a 26,900 sq meter area was included in the agreement with the developer without obtaining prior permission from the District Collector, this has been ruled a major breach of terms. Orders will be issued to take immediate possession of this land, he said.
Minister Bawankule assured that common citizens and Mathadi workers residing in existing houses and built-up housing societies on the land will receive full protection. The government plans to convert these lands into 'Freehold' status to grant occupants complete ownership rights.
Participating in the discussion, local MLA Yogesh Sagar raised the pending housing issue of the Mathadi workers. "Around 1,250 to 1,300 families of Mathadi workers, who used to carry cloth bales on their heads back in 1969-70, reside here. Even today, applications from many workers' children remain pending. Therefore, instead of a blanket reclamation of the 26,900 sq meter surplus land, houses should be built for the Mathadi workers on that site," he demanded.
Responding to the demand, the Revenue Minister stated, "Although directions have been given to reclaim the land for now due to the breach of terms, the government remains committed to delivering justice to Mathadi workers. We will hold a meeting with the concerned society and MLA Yogesh Sagar. If 1,600 to 2,000 houses are genuinely going to be built for the workers, the government is fully prepared to allot that land for the workers' housing after charging the required premium. We do not object to the developer receiving a 'sale component,' but the government will not compromise on the rightful homes of the original Mathadi workers."
— IANS
Reader Comments
The math here is shocking: Rs 42 crore premium + Rs 74 crore stamp duty collected, and still the terms were violated? That's over Rs 116 crore for this land, and yet the original Mathadi workers who literally carried bales on their heads for decades are living in uncertainty. The minister's assurance to protect existing residents is welcome, but I hope the 'freehold' conversion doesn't become another bureaucratic nightmare. Also, MLA Yogesh Sagar makes a solid point—why not use that surplus land for worker housing directly?
Interesting to see how this plays out. In Mumbai, redevelopment deals are notoriously complex. The fact that 26,900 sq m was included without Collector's permission is a serious red flag—who approved that? The IGR Pune inquiry should be thorough. But I hope they don't drag this out for years. The Mathadi workers' plight is real; they've been waiting since 1969 for proper housing. Let's hope this probe leads to actual houses, not just headlines.
Why is the government only acting now? This land was allotted years ago, and violations were happening right under their noses. The Rs 21.67 crore collected earlier to 'regularize' breaches feels like a slap on the wrist—basically a fine for playing with people's homes. The minister says 'full protection' for existing residents, but what about the Mathadi workers not yet housed? 1,600-2,000 homes sounds great, but we've heard such numbers before. Action needed, not meetings. 😤
A classic case of development vs. displacement. On one hand, converting land to Class-I status and collecting stamp duty is standard procedure. But including unapproved surplus land in a private developer's deal is outright unfair to the Mathadi workers who this land was originally meant for. The minister's willingness to reconsider if 1,600-2,000 houses are built for workers is a reasonable middle ground—but only if it's binding. Let's
We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.