Vance Praises Pope's Peace Role, Questions Stance on Military Action

US Vice President JD Vance expressed appreciation for Pope Leo XIV's willingness to speak on global issues like war and peace, while also noting specific disagreements with the pontiff's recent remarks. Vance specifically questioned the Pope's statement that God is never on the side of those who wield the sword, using the Allied liberation in WWII as a counterpoint. Meanwhile, President Donald Trump refused to apologize to the Pope, describing his positions as weak and wrong. Pope Leo XIV reiterated that his mission is spiritual, not political, and that he will continue to advocate loudly for peace and dialogue.

Key Points: Vance on Pope: Advocate for Peace, But Disagrees on Military

  • Vance praises Pope's global voice
  • Questions theological framing of peace statement
  • Trump refuses to apologize to Pope
  • Pope asserts he is not a politician
  • Focus remains on Gospel and peacemaking
5 min read

JD Vance praises Pope Leo XIV's peace advocacy amid policy differences

US VP JD Vance respects Pope Leo XIV's peace advocacy but challenges his remarks on Western military actions and the Iran conflict.

"I like that the Pope is an advocate for peace. That's certainly one of his roles. - JD Vance"

Washington, April 15

US Vice President JD Vance praised Pope Leo XIV as a strong advocate for peace, while also pushing back against some recent remarks made by the pontiff on Western military actions, including commentary linked to the Iran conflict.

Speaking during an interview, Vance said he appreciated the Pope's willingness to speak on global issues, even when there is disagreement.

"I kind of like even when there's disagreement. I like it when the pope comments on questions of immigration, I like it when the pope talks about abortion, I like it when the pope talks about matters of war and peace, because I think that, at the very least, it invites a conversation," Vance said during an interview with Turning Point USA in Georgia, quoted by CNN.

He added, "There are certainly things that the pope has said in the last few months that I disagree with."

Vance further referred to Pope Leo XIV's social media post last week that alluded to the Iran conflict, in which the pontiff said, "Anyone who is a disciple of Christ, the Prince of Peace, is never on the side of those who once wielded the sword and today drop bombs."

While Vance said he respects the Pope's role as a global voice for peace, he questioned the theological framing of the statement.

"On the one hand, I like that the Pope is an advocate for peace. That's certainly one of his roles," he said.

"On the other hand, how can you say God is never on the side of those who wield the sword? Was God on the side of the Americans who liberated the Holocaust camps and liberated those innocent people from those who had survived the Holocaust? I think the answer is yes," Vance said, quoted by CNN.

During the interaction, a member of the audience interrupted, shouting that Jesus would not have supported genocide. Responding to the broader discussion, Vance said the humanitarian situation in Gaza had been "an absolute catastrophe" when the administration came into office.

"You know, who's the person who got a peace agreement in Gaza? Donald J. Trump," Vance added.

Meanwhile, US President Donald Trump on Monday refused to apologise to Pope Leo XIV, the first American-born pontiff, following criticism over the Pope's stance on Iran and other global issues.

Trump described Pope Leo's positions as "wrong" and suggested that the pontiff would be "unhappy with the result" of his administration's policies, further intensifying political and diplomatic tensions.

"I won't apologise to Pope Leo. I think he's very weak on crime and other things," Trump told reporters at the White House.

The comments came after Pope Leo XIV reiterated his commitment to peace and spiritual advocacy, stating that he has no intention of engaging in a political confrontation with the United States administration.

When questioned by reporters during his flight to Algeria, the Pontiff said, "I think that the people who read will be able to draw their own conclusions: I am not a politician, I have no intention of entering into a debate with Donald Trump."

He further asserted his focus on peace and reconciliation, adding, "Rather, let us always seek peace and put an end to wars. I am not afraid of the Trump administration."

The Pope maintained that his mission is rooted in faith rather than political engagement, emphasising that the message of the Gospel should not be used for political purposes. "I speak about the Gospel; I am not a politician. I do not think the message of the Gospel should be abused in the way some people are doing," he said.

Emphasising his role as a global advocate, he stated, "I will continue to speak out loudly against war, to try to promote peace and multilateral dialogue between states in order to seek the right solution to problems."

Reiterating the Church's stance, he noted, "The message of the Church is the message of the Gospel: blessed are the peacemakers. I do not see my role as that of a politician; I do not want to enter into a debate with him. Too many people are suffering in the world."

The Pope described his journey to Africa as "truly a blessing for me personally, but I believe also for the Church and for the world." He noted the necessity of the mission, stating, "because we must always seek bridges to build peace and reconciliation."

Highlighting the historical significance of the visit, Leo XIV spoke of St. Augustine, a native of modern-day Algeria, who he believes "serves as a vital bridge in interreligious dialogue and is deeply loved in his homeland, as we shall see." The Pope, who famously identified himself as "a son of St. Augustine" upon his election last May, is the first Pontiff to visit the saint's homeland.

Characterising the 10-day African tour as "a precious opportunity to continue with the same voice and the same message," the Pope reaffirmed his objective to "promote peace, reconciliation, and respect and consideration for all peoples."

The visit to Algeria marks the initial phase of his third international apostolic journey. In a nation where the Catholic community comprises only a few thousand individuals within a population of 48 million Muslims, the mission is expected to focus on the themes of fraternity and interfaith encounter.

These calls for peace from the papal plane stand in sharp contrast to the domestic political climate in the United States. On Sunday (local time), the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops (USCCB) criticised President Donald Trump for his recent social media remarks targeting the Pope, asserting that the Pontiff is "not his rival" and should not be viewed through a political lens.

- ANI

Share this article:

Reader Comments

S
Sarah B
Vance makes a fair point about the complexity of "peace." Sometimes defending the innocent requires force, as history shows. But the Pope's role is to hold up an ideal. It's a necessary tension in global discourse.
P
Priya S
As an Indian, I appreciate the Pope's visit to Algeria for interfaith dialogue. We understand the importance of such bridges in a multi-religious society. Trump's comments seem unnecessarily confrontational. Why pick a fight with a spiritual leader?
R
Rohit P
The whole debate feels very distant from our concerns in India. We have real border issues and security threats. While peace is noble, the world isn't that simple. Vance's pushback is understandable from a governance perspective.
M
Michael C
Respectfully, I think Vance is missing the Pope's point. The statement "never on the side of those who wield the sword" is a theological ideal about the heart of a disciple, not a historical commentary on every Allied soldier in WWII. It's about intention and spirit.
K
Kavya N
The Pope's message is timeless. In a country like ours with so much diversity, the call for peace and dialogue is always relevant. Hope our own leaders take note. 🙏

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Minimum 50 characters 0/50