Peter Jackson Compares AI to Special Effects, Defends Motion-Capture Acting

Filmmaker Peter Jackson expressed his nuanced views on AI in cinema at the Cannes Film Festival, comparing it to other special effects. He stressed the importance of protecting actors' rights against unauthorized use of their likenesses. Jackson also argued that the current debate around AI unfairly impacts awards recognition for motion-capture performances, citing Andy Serkis' portrayal of Gollum. He confirmed that Serkis will direct and star in the upcoming 'The Hunt for Gollum' film.

Key Points: Peter Jackson on AI in Cinema: No Different From Other Effects

  • Peter Jackson sees AI as just another special effect in cinema
  • He emphasizes protecting actors' likenesses from unauthorized AI use
  • Jackson believes the AI debate hurts awards chances for motion-capture performances
  • He praises Andy Serkis as the best director for the upcoming Hunt for Gollum film
3 min read

"It's no different from other special effects": Filmmaker Peter Jackson on use of AI in cinema

Lord of the Rings filmmaker Peter Jackson shares his views on AI in film, defends Andy Serkis' motion-capture performance, and discusses the upcoming Hunt for Gollum.

"I mean, to me, it's just a special effect, it's no different from other special effects. - Peter Jackson"

Cannes, May 13

The 'Lord of the Rings' filmmaker Peter Jackson expressed his opinions on the use of AI in the cinema, saying that he doesn't "dislike" AI being used in the films, but feels that the debate around it is partly the reason why Andy Serkis will never win awards for his motion-capture performance as character Gollum in 'Lord of the Rings.'

Speaking at a Cannes Film Festival masterclass the day after he was bestowed an Honorary Palme d'Or, Jackson said that though AI is "going to destroy the world," when it comes to its use in film, "I don't dislike it at all," reported Variety.

"I mean, to me, it's just a special effect, it's no different from other special effects," said Jackson as quoted in Variety.

However, he said that it's "absolutely critical" to protect actors' rights from having their likenesses stolen and used in films without their permission.

"If you're doing an AI duplicate of somebody, like Indiana Jones or anyone else, as long as you've licensed the rights off the person who you're showing, I don't see the issue, it's when people's likenesses get stolen and usurped," added Jackson as quoted by Variety.

But one downside to the current debate around AI in Hollywood is its impact on awards recognition for motion-capture performances, like Serkis' portrayal of Gollum in 'The Lord of the Rings' films.

"A lot of the current environment, everyone's so worried about AI. I don't think a Gollum-type character or a generated character has any hope for winning any awards. Which is a bit unfair, especially in the Andy Serkis case, where it's not an AI-generated performance, it's a human-generated performance 100% of the way," said Jackson.

According to the outlet, Jackson also teased the upcoming 'The Hunt for Gollum' film, which Serkis is directing and starring in. Asked why Jackson decided to let Serkis take the helm, he said: "The film is about Gollum's psychological addiction. I thought, 'Andy knows this guy better than anybody.' So I actually didn't think much of myself [directing the new movie]. I thought the most exciting version of this movie is if Andy Serkis makes it," as quoted by Variety.

Jackson was presented with his honorary Palme by 'Lord of the Rings' star Elijah Wood on Tuesday night during the festival's opening ceremony.

"You showed the world something it had never seen before, and nothing was ever the same. He helped build an entirely new filmmaking culture at the far edge of the world."

In his speech, Jackson recalled that the decision to shoot most of the three "Lord of the Rings" films was a "huge gamble," dubbed a "folly" by the media that predicted the expense might prove to be a disaster if the first movie wasn't a hit.

However, he said that the narrative changed in Cannes 25 years ago, in 2001, when he showed 20 minutes of footage from 'The Fellowship of the Ring', leading to a grand reception for the film.

The Cannes Film Festival will take place till May 23 in France.

- ANI

Share this article:

Reader Comments

K
Kavya N
🤔 Interesting to hear a big name like Jackson defend AI use. But as an Indian filmmaker, I worry about the impact on our VFX artists and animators who work so hard. We need to ensure this technology augments their work, not replaces them. The rights issue he mentioned is crucial too - our actors deserve protection.
S
Sarah B
Jackson's comparison to other special effects makes sense on the surface, but AI is fundamentally different - it can learn and create on its own. The Gollum point is spot-on though. Serkis gave a phenomenal performance and it's sad that the AI debate overshadowed that. Hope 'The Hunt for Gollum' changes this perspective.
R
Rajesh Q
I appreciate Peter Jackson's practical take on AI. In India, we've seen how technology can democratize cinema - think of how digital cameras and now AI can help regional cinema and independent filmmakers. But the copyright concerns are real. We need laws that protect artists without stifling innovation. Good that he mentioned theft of likeness.
M
Michael C
Jackson saying AI is "going to destroy the world" but then calling it "just a special effect" feels contradictory. The technology is powerful and needs regulation. But I agree wholeheartedly about motion-capture - what Serkis did as Gollum was pure artistry. The industry should create a separate category for such performances if needed.
S
Siddharth J
As someone who grew up on the LOTR films, reading about Jackson and Serkis collaborating again for 'The Hunt for Gollum' is pure nostalgia. The fact that he chose Serkis to direct because of his deep understanding of Gollum's psychology shows leadership maturity. AI or

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Minimum 50 characters 0/50