NewKerala.com

India's Pragmatic Taliban Engagement: Consular Access Over Recognition

India has quietly accepted a Taliban-appointed representative in New Delhi to manage the Afghan Embassy, emphasizing this is for functional consular services rather than diplomatic recognition of the regime. This move provides essential passport and document validation for thousands of Afghan refugees in India while allowing New Delhi to maintain a pragmatic channel. It complicates efforts by China and Pakistan to fully draw Afghanistan into the CPEC and creates a strategic counterbalance in the region. The arrangement reflects a global pattern of "engagement without endorsement" as the Taliban seeks legitimacy beyond its traditional allies in Islamabad and Beijing.

Key Points: India's Pragmatic Engagement with Taliban Representative

  • Pragmatic engagement vs. formal recognition
  • Facilitates consular services for Afghan refugees
  • Counters China-Pakistan influence in Afghanistan
  • Part of global trend of hosting Taliban representatives
3 min read

India's quiet acceptance of Taliban representative signals pragmatic engagement, not recognition

India accepts a Taliban-appointed diplomat in Delhi for consular services, signaling pragmatic engagement without formal recognition of the Kabul regime.

"Allowing Mufti Noor Ahmad to take charge... is a functional arrangement, where India maintains that it does not diplomatically recognise the Taliban regime. - Analysis"

New Delhi, Jan 10

Taliban leader Mufti Noor Ahmad Noor's reported arrival in New Delhi to take over as Charge d'Affaires at the Afghan Embassy has been drawing few criticisms, while some coverage terming it a diplomatic move.

However, India's quiet acceptance of a Taliban representative in Delhi signals pragmatic engagement, not recognition of the government in Kabul.

This complicates Beijing and Islamabad's joint efforts to draw Afghanistan fully into the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC), a part of the China's ambitious Belt and Road Initiative (BRI).

In India, Kabul's representative is necessary for the thousands of Afghan refugees in India who need consular access for passport validation, in turn facilitating visa processing and their stay.

They also need clearance from the Embassy and the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) to validate refugee status and initiate bank operations.

According to Faisal Payenda, Chairman of Afghan Refugee Community in India, Delhi alone hosts an estimated 15,000 Afghan refugees.

Meanwhile, there is global precedence of several countries hosting Taliban-appointed diplomats, classifying them as "Charge d'Affaires" or "representatives", instead of granting recognition as Ambassador.

China intends using economic incentives to keep Kabul aligned with it.

New Delhi has offset the outreach, with Beijing having similar diplomatic arrangement, stopping short of recognition.

Till now, only Russia has formally recognised the Taliban government.

Beijing insists on Taliban guarantees against Uyghur militants and broader anti-terrorism cooperation.

Yet, through deepening its ties, China has still not formally recognised the Taliban government, preferring a cautious "engagement without endorsement" approach.

Allowing Mufti Noor Ahmad to take charge at the Afghan Embassy in New Delhi is a functional arrangement, where India maintains that it does not diplomatically recognise the Taliban regime.

New Delhi permits representation for consular and community services and has been for long among the suppliers of aid and humanitarian relief.

The Taliban's presence in Delhi shows they are seeking legitimacy beyond Islamabad and Beijing, where rising tensions with Pakistan has led to the closure of the Afghan border, hampering trade and human traffic.

The present cautious engagement creates a counterbalance, where the representative provides consular services without forcing India to take a political stand on recognition.

In the Taliban's search for legitimacy, they will likely continue to balance their relation between regional powers like India, China, and Russia before committing fully to any bloc.

Despite the related roadblocks and stops, India needs to continue maintain a relation, continue investing in humanitarian and reconstruction projects in Afghanistan, in order to build goodwill, countering the "Great Game" being played by other countries.

- IANS

Share this article:

Reader Comments

P
Priya S
I understand the practical reasons, especially for the refugees. But it feels uncomfortable. We are essentially doing business with a regime whose values are the opposite of ours on women's rights and democracy. I hope this engagement comes with strong, quiet pressure for reform.
R
Rohit P
Good strategic thinking! 🇮🇳 This complicates CPEC and shows the Taliban they can't rely only on Pakistan. It's all part of the great game. We need to be present in Afghanistan to protect our interests and counter Chinese influence. Humanitarian work builds long-term goodwill.
S
Sarah B
As someone who has worked with Afghan students here, this is a relief. The bureaucratic hurdles for refugees are immense without a functioning embassy. This is a humane step first and foremost. The geopolitical angle is secondary to helping 15,000 people get their documents in order.
V
Vikram M
The article says only Russia has formally recognized them. If China, with all its investments, is also holding back on recognition, then India's "cautious engagement" is the global norm, not an exception. We're playing it safe and smart, not rushing in like before.
K
Karthik V
It's a delicate balance. We cannot abandon the Afghan people, who have always had goodwill for India. At the same time, we cannot legitimize the Taliban's rule. This "Charge d'Affaires" arrangement seems to be the middle path. Let's hope it works and doesn't backfire.

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Minimum 50 characters 0/50