"If you had no nuclear weapons, nobody would care": Former Singaporean diplomat says "Pakistan teetering on brink of failure"
Singapore, July 3
During a wide-ranging discussion with journalists at the National Press Foundation's International Reporting Fellowship, a scathing assessment of Pakistan was delivered, characterising the nation as a state "teetering on the brink of failure".
The critique was offered by Bilahari Kausikan, the Chairman of the Middle East Institute, an autonomous institute of the National University of Singapore, who served as Permanent Secretary of Singapore's Ministry of Foreign Affairs from 2010 to 2013.
Speaking on the topic, "On Keeping Perspective in Volatile Geopolitical Times", the longtime diplomat dismantled the image of Pakistan as a stable international actor, exposing the profound internal instability, radicalisation, and severe systemic economic vulnerabilities plaguing the country.
The severe reality of the South Asian nation's domestic decay was brought to the forefront when a Pakistani journalist questioned the diplomat regarding the impact of the US-Iran conflict on Pakistan and where the country stands over the next five years. The journalist outlined a grim account of internal turmoil, detailing how the domestic fallout has triggered massive inflation, doubled fuel prices, and caused Qatar to suspend its visa-on-arrival facility for Pakistani passport holders.
Highlighting the breakdown of internal security and law and order, the journalist also pointed to violent public attacks on the US Consulate in Karachi that forced the facility to shut down, alongside partial lockdowns that have plunged the public into a massive crisis.
In a blunt reality check, Kausikan firmly rejected the idea that Islamabad's tactical diplomatic manoeuvres could compensate for its structural vulnerabilities, noting that temporary external optics fail to address the core miseries of its population.
"I'll be very blunt. Pakistan was very agile and very successful in taking advantage of a diplomatic opportunity, and that has gone some way to rehabilitate Pakistan diplomatically in the eyes of the U.S. anyway. But, you know, that doesn't feed the Pakistani people," Kausikan stated.
Tearing down the illusion of international rehabilitation, the veteran diplomat explicitly labelled the Pakistani state a chronically unstable entity, pointing out its continued tolerance of extremist elements that threaten global security.
"Pakistan is a state that is teetering on the brink of failure, and has been for some time. It hasn't quite fallen over, for which we should all be grateful, but that diplomatic success doesn't change that fundamental reality. And I don't think the U.S. is going to lift whatever restrictions in totality it has on Pakistan, because the fact is Pakistan is a hotbed of all kinds of strange groups that are not necessarily working for U.S. interests," Kausikan explained.
The former top diplomat also targeted the country's powerful military establishment, noting that tactical foreign policy moves are completely overshadowed by a profound internal rot driven by severe economic mismanagement and a failure to contain radical movements.
"Pakistani military was very agile and very successful, that you have to give them credit, but diplomatic success doesn't feed people--that's the hard reality. Pakistan's problems are not diplomatic; Pakistan's problems are much more fundamental within Pakistan. Mismanagement of the economy, letting various jihadist movements get out of hand--if you don't fix those problems, you're always going to be teetering on the brink of state failure," he warned.
Concluding his sharp analysis, the Singaporean academic observed that global attention towards the faltering state is driven solely by international anxiety over its strategic weapons arsenal, rather than any genuine respect for its geopolitical standing.
"And everybody is worried about it because you happen to have nuclear weapons. If you had no nuclear weapons, nobody would care," Kausikan remarked.
— ANI
Reader Comments
Sad but true. Look at the condition of common people in Pakistan—inflation, fuel prices doubled, lawlessness. And yet their leaders keep pretending everything is fine. The genocide against minorities and poor governance is why they're in this mess. Nuclear weapons don't put food on the table. 😔
Harsh words but needed. As an Indian, I feel for the common Pakistani citizen—they're caught between military adventurism and extremist groups. But their establishment keeps playing the same game. The fact that Qatar suspended visa-on-arrival should be a huge wake-up call. Diplomacy without domestic stability is just smoke and mirrors.
I have to disagree with the tone here. While Pakistan has serious issues, calling it a "failed state" is too harsh. Every country has problems. The real failure is the international community's selective attention—only caring because of nukes. What about other failing states without nuclear weapons? Nobody seems to care about them either.
Finally someone saying it out loud! For decades, Pakistan has used the nuclear card to get foreign aid and diplomatic leverage. But you can't build a nation on insecurity. India's strength comes from our democracy, economy, and diversity. Pakistan needs to fix its fundamentals—stop sponsoring terror, clean up the economy, and get the military out of politics. 🎯
As someone who has Pakistani friends online, I can say they are lovely people. But their government has failed them spectacularly. The economy is in shambles, education is lacking, and the military runs the show. Kausikan's criticism is valid—you can't
We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.