Ex-Diplomat Slams US "Arrogance" on Iran, Warns of Trump's "Lost Judgment"

Former diplomat KP Fabian criticized the United States' language and posture regarding Iran as "most unfortunate" and arrogant. He acknowledged Iran's military feat in downing American transport aircraft while noting its limited air defense capabilities. Fabian expressed concern over President Trump's "lost judgment" and unpredictable reactions, which heighten escalation risks. He also highlighted Iran's efforts to engage India diplomatically, as a ceasefire plan for the Strait of Hormuz is reportedly being discussed.

Key Points: Former Diplomat Criticizes US Posture on Iran Conflict

  • US comments show arrogance
  • Iran downed US aircraft
  • Trump has lost judgment
  • Iran values India relations
  • Ceasefire plan proposed
3 min read

Former Diplomat KP Fabian says US comment on Hormuz "most unfortunate"

KP Fabian calls US comments "most unfortunate," analyzes Iran's air defense feat, and warns of Trump's unpredictable reactions in the Hormuz crisis.

"The US posture is most unfortunate... it shows ignorance, but it certainly shows arrogance. - KP Fabian"

New Delhi, April 6

Former Diplomat KP Fabian on Monday said that the US' posture is unfortunate, and shows arrogance.

Fabian, while talking to ANI, said that Iran's capabilities to bring down American aircraft must be recognized.

"Essentially, it was a feat. It was extremely difficult to go deep into Iranian territory near Isfahan, but at the same time, we have to realize that Iran does not have much by way of air defence or an air force. We should also recognize that in the process, Iran seems to have brought down one or two American transport aircraft," he said.

Fabian said that Trump has already lost judgement, as one can see from the way he used expletives.

"It is a mixed success, but on the whole, it is good that it happened because, given President Trump's temper and tantrums, if Iranians had captured him first, they would have used him for publicity purposes. That would anger Trump to an extent that he would lose judgment even more. He has already lost judgment, as we can see from the way he used expletives," he said.

"The US posture is most unfortunate because it is not only using foul language; in fact, the Secretary for War is also resorting to quoting the Bible during Holy Week. The US is openly saying--both the President and the Secretary for War--that they do not care for international humanitarian law. By repeatedly saying they would hit civilian targets, they are saying they couldn't care less. Pete Hegseth said he didn't care "two hoots" for these "stupid rules of engagement." That shows ignorance, but it certainly shows arrogance," he said.

Fabian also said that the fact that the Iranian foreign minister called shows that Iran attaches high importance to keeping good relations with India.

"Regarding the talks between the ministers, I wouldn't say they are very crucial because India is not part of the conflict resolution process. At the same time, the fact that the Iranian foreign minister called shows that Iran attaches high importance to keeping good relations with India. Iran is pressing India, as the chair of BRICS and the leader of the Global South, to speak up, though India has so far declined," he said.

"Regarding whether the US blew up the aircraft to prevent Iran from getting hold of them, sitting here, we cannot say for certain. However, we may recognize that this is a statement coming from US officers now. Initially, Iran put out the fragments of the shattered aircraft, and at that point, there was no comment. I take it that the US claim is an afterthought," he said further.

Fabian said that the fact that Trump is shifting his deadlines, and it's not certain how he would react.

"As for whether this war will escalate, Trump has been extending his deadlines and shifting his ultimatums. That shows he has boxed himself in and painted himself into a corner. The problem is how a man like President Trump, who holds the most powerful office under the moon, will react. It may not be entirely rational, so there is a risk," he said.

Meanwhile, the United States and Iran have received a plan to end hostilities, which could come in effect on Monday and result in the opening of the Strait of Hormuz, sources familiar with the proposals told Reuters.

As per the report by Reuters, the framework has been put together by Pakistan and exchanged with Iran and US overnight, the source said, noting of a two-tier approach with an immediate ceasefire followed by a comprehensive agreement.

- ANI

Share this article:

Reader Comments

S
Sarah B
Interesting analysis. The point about Iran valuing relations with India is crucial. It shows our diplomatic weight. But I respectfully disagree on downplaying the talks between ministers. Every channel for de-escalation is crucial right now, and India can be a quiet, trusted intermediary.
V
Vikram M
Trump's shifting deadlines are the most dangerous part. A leader who acts on impulse with the world's most powerful military? Scary thought. Hope the Pakistan-brokered plan works 🤞. Stability in Hormuz is vital for global oil prices and our economy.
P
Priya S
The Bible quote during Holy Week comment hit home. It shows a complete lack of respect. Fabian sir has articulated what many of us feel. The world doesn't run on might alone. India's stance of strategic autonomy is the right one. Jai Hind!
R
Rohit P
Good to see a seasoned diplomat calling out the US posture clearly. But let's not romanticize Iran either. They are no saints in the region. India's challenge is to balance this perfectly without getting sucked into their conflict. Tough job for MEA.
D
David E
The analysis about Iran bringing down US aircraft is a key military detail often missed. Shows the conflict is more complex than "David vs Goliath". Hope the ceasefire holds. The last thing the world needs is another full-blown war.

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Minimum 50 characters 0/50