'E20 is fuel for future', says oil experts while bursting pervasive myths
Mumbai, July 4
With the public debate over dropping fuel economy and potential engine damage gaining momentum, prominent energy industry veterans on Saturday stepped forward to clear up public confusion and address consumer anxieties regarding India's rapidly expanding E20 petrol mandate.
Speaking to ANI on the sidelines of a high-level media briefing in Mumbai, R Ramachandran, retired Director (Refineries) of BPCL, and Raj Kumar Dubey, retired Chairman of IGL and Director of BPCL, systematically dismantled pervasive myths surrounding the fuel by comparing empirical laboratory data against subjective roadside experiences.
Addressing widespread driver complaints of a 10 per cent drop in fuel economy, Ramachandran stated that extensive institutional testing shows only a marginal impact on mileage.
"These are unique cases which may require fixes of a different type," he explained, pointing out that older vehicles, general wear and tear, or aggressive city driving distort real-world perceptions.
Dubey further added that motorists have already been buying blended fuel like E20 for over a year without realising it.
"Suddenly, you know, if you raise this question that, 'No, the mileage is dramatically dropping'--now, those things, you know, are not subject to reason," Dubey stated, urging consumers to trust testing agencies over individual opinions.
The experts also tackled mechanical fears for millions of older vehicles built before 2023 that lack explicit E20 factory compliance.
Dubey explained that accelerated testing revealed only minor long-term adjustments for older engines. "In very old vehicles, there will be some issues on the rubber parts," Dubey noted.
"Normally, suppose you want to change the rubber parts within 10 years; here, you need to look into changing the rubber parts maybe in eight years. It's a very small price to pay for such a big initiative," he said.
Furthermore, Ramachandran dismissed rumours regarding insurance, clarifying that clear notifications confirm insurance policies remain fully valid.
On environmental concerns, the veterans dismissed reports claiming that ethanol production wastes up to 10,000 litres of water per litre of fuel.
"Agricultural production water consumption should not be foisted on ethanol," Ramachandran stated, highlighting that most new-age distilleries operate with 100% water recycling and zero-effluent discharge.
Finally, the experts emphasised the massive macroeconomic benefits of the policy against the government's expected Rs 1.8 lakh crore to Rs 1.9 lakh crore in foreign exchange savings. Dubey focused on the buffer the policy provides against volatile global crude prices.
"If E20 was not there and 20 per cent of these additional things we had to import from abroad, what would the cost of petrol have been in this country? The prices would have gone up by more than 5 to 7 rupees more," Dubey argued, concluding that keeping capital within the domestic economy directly enriches local sugarcane farmers.
— ANI
Reader Comments
I appreciate the macroeconomic argument but there's genuine panic among middle-class car owners. My father's 2019 Hyundai i20 gave noticeably lower mileage on E20 - we tried it for a month. If the government wants trust, they should first do better public awareness campaigns and offer affordable retrofitting for older vehicles. The rubber part change argument sounds too simplistic for real-world conditions in Indian traffic.
The environmental argument is weak - even if distilleries recycle water, growing sugarcane for ethanol still requires huge amounts of water and fertilizers in drought-prone regions like Maharashtra and Karnataka. Let's not pretend this is all green. But yes, energy independence is important. Mixed feelings on this one.
As someone from the US, I've seen how ethanol mandates created problems with food prices and small engine reliability. India should learn from our mistakes. The Japanese car manufacturers have already warned about warranty issues. The government's push seems politically motivated to appease sugarcane lobby rather than genuine energy policy. Be careful what you wish for.
I trust the testing agencies more than random WhatsApp forwards. My Scooty has been running on E10 for years without issues. The 5-7 rupee petrol price saving argument is powerful - imagine what that means for auto drivers and daily commuters. Sacrifice the rubber parts every 8 years instead of 10? Done deal! 🇮🇳
The experts say 'trust testing agencies' but most Indians don't even know how their fuel is tested. Also, the ethanol blending is already a done deal - we've been
We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.