Ceasefire Offers "Breathing Space" for Iran-US to Reassess, Says Ex-Diplomat

Former diplomat Vidya Bhushan Soni states a temporary ceasefire between Iran and the US is a sensible move, providing crucial "breathing space" for both sides to reassess the situation on the ground and politically. He criticizes former President Donald Trump's aggressive rhetoric, arguing such threats are ineffective against a civilization with Iran's deep historical roots. Soni suggests the agreement is a positive sign, indicating a potential opening for diplomatic "give and take." He further posits that the US may attempt to open other fronts by targeting Iran's regional supporters.

Key Points: Ex-Diplomat on Iran-US Ceasefire: A Vital "Breathing Space"

  • Ceasefire allows mental and physical reassessment
  • Iran initially rejected proposal
  • Trump's "obliterate" statement criticized
  • War cannot be fought "day in and day out"
  • US may shift focus to Iran's allies
4 min read

"Ceasefire is sensible for both parties to reassess situation," says Former Diplomat

Former diplomat Vidya Bhushan Soni calls the two-week ceasefire sensible, allowing warring nations time to reassess and potentially find common ground.

"It makes sense for the two warring nations to find at least a breathing period - Vidya Bhushan Soni"

New Delhi, April 9

Former Diplomat Vidya Bhushan Soni said on Thursday that it makes sense for the two warring nations to find a breathing period to reassess their situation.

Soni, in a conversation with ANI, said that Iran initially rejected the proposal that came through, but now they feel they can see what developments might come up, which is a positive sign.

"I think it makes sense for the two warring nations to find at least a breathing period when you can reassess your situations, both on the ground and from a political discussion angle. If they are threatened by everyday action, fire, and destruction, then nothing gets done. Your mind doesn't think clearly. By agreeing to this ceasefire for two weeks, it will give them time to reassess the situation on the ground physically and mentally," Soni said.

He then said that the parties will now re-evaluate what has been passing between them.

"Whatever has been passing between the two sides and whatever feedback both countries are getting from their respective camps, they will be able to reevaluate, re-examine, and see if they can find a meeting ground," he said.

Soni said that the ceasefire would allow for "time to reassess", as "no war can be fought day in and day out".

"It is a breathing space, which is very important because no war can be fought day in and day out. If you remember, even in the good old days, war stopped when the sun went down. Until the next day, no hostilities were exchanged between the two sides. In fact, they would even go to each other's camps and ask about their welfare. In the present-day system, that obviously cannot be done, but at least a ceasefire provides time to reassess," he said.

"That is my reaction, and I think it is a positive one. Iran initially rejected the proposal that came through, but now they feel they can see what developments might come up. If there is something positive--something where they can give and take--that is the reason why they have agreed," he added.

Soni said that Trump issued a very strong statement on Iran.

"The important thing is the so-called deadline set yesterday by Trump. Before such deadlines, people often take very tough positions. That is why he was saying he would obliterate the civilization. I think it was a very stupid statement by President Trump. Iran would not have bowed down or buckled because of that threat," he said.

"You must remember, you cannot destroy a civilisation that is 5,000 years old. You can destroy their government or individuals; Alexander tried it, and after that, Genghis Khan also tried it. It doesn't work. Who is Mr. Trump to obliterate a civilisation and a people? You can talk about regime change, but not that," he added.

Soni said that people who have depth, are not shaken or moved by this kind of rhetoric being bombarded at them.

"Now I feel Iran will bounce back because it is in their blood and their genes. Mr. Trump should also realize that they don't have a comparable civilization to talk about, so they don't know the value of it. Their country is only 250 years old. Can you really call them a civilization in the same manner? That is why the way they talk has no reality on the ground. People who have depth, whose roots are deeply embedded, are not shaken or moved by this kind of rhetoric being bombarded at them," he said.

"You can open the Strait of Hormuz, but at what cost? You would have your own battleships escorting. You can do it for a day or two, or for five ships, but it cannot be done for days on end. However, opening other fronts is something they will probably try to do, much like Israel has done in Lebanon. They are trying to target Iran's supporters, whether it is Hezbollah or even the Houthis," he added.

Soni further said that the US will now focus more on Iran's supporters.

"Attention will probably be deflected there so that there is less attention on Iran. What they are trying to do is fight on two fronts. On the first front, there is no clear victory. But on the second front, which is more vulnerable, there is a chance for them. Firstly, they are closer to the ground, and secondly, those groups don't have the same kind of civilizational support that Iran has. That is why they can easily browbeat them and put them into submission without a great cost," he said.

Meanwhile, President Donald Trump on Wednesday (local time) said that the US military deployments will remain in place around Iran until the "real agreement" reached is fully complied with.

- ANI

Share this article:

Reader Comments

S
Sarah B
Soni makes a very valid point about the need for a "breathing period." In any high-stakes conflict, decisions made under constant fire are rarely the best ones. This gives diplomats a chance to actually think.
V
Vikram M
While I agree with the need for peace, the former diplomat's comments about comparing civilizations feel a bit unnecessary and could be seen as inflammatory. The focus should remain solely on the strategic benefits of the ceasefire for de-escalation.
P
Priya S
This is a welcome development. As a major importer of oil, stability in the Gulf is crucial for India's energy security. Any escalation there directly impacts fuel prices here. Hope the ceasefire holds.
R
Rohit P
The part about war stopping when the sun went down in the old days is so true. There was some humanity left. Now with drones and satellites, conflict is 24/7. A ceasefire, even a short one, is a return to some basic sense.
M
Michael C
The analysis about the US shifting focus to Iran's supporters like Hezbollah is sharp. It's a classic strategy - when you can't defeat the main force, pressure the allies. The next two weeks will be critical to see if this pause is genuine or just a regrouping.

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Minimum 50 characters 0/50