Amit Shah Debunks Southern States' Power Loss Myth in Lok Sabha Bills Debate

Union Home Minister Amit Shah refuted opposition claims that new bills for implementing women's reservation would diminish the political influence of southern states. He presented detailed statistics showing that southern states would see an increase in both absolute seat numbers and their percentage share in an expanded Lok Sabha. Prime Minister Narendra Modi also participated in the debate, offering a guarantee that the delimitation process would not discriminate against any region. The government introduced three bills for early implementation of the Women's Reservation Act during a special parliamentary session.

Key Points: Amit Shah Rejects Claims of Southern States Losing Influence

  • Shah counters narrative of southern power loss
  • Cites figures showing seat share increase
  • PM Modi guarantees no injustice in delimitation
  • Bills aim for early women's reservation
5 min read

Amit Shah says opposition creating false narrative on new Lok Sabha bills, cites figures to reject claims of decline in influence of southern states

Union Home Minister Amit Shah uses data to counter opposition narrative that new Lok Sabha bills will reduce southern states' political power.

"Karnataka will not suffer any loss at all. - Amit Shah"

New Delhi, April 16

Union Home Minister Amit Shah on Thursday sought to allay apprehensions of opposition members about the Southern states losing their influence as a result of increase in seats in the Lok Sabha to implement the women's reservation Act and said while there will be about 50 per cent increase in their seats, the relative proportion in total seats will also move up.

Shah, who made his remarks during the debate in Lok Sabha on three bills, including the Constitutional Amendment Bill for early implementation of women's reservation, said he will reply to the debate tomorrow but was clearing some misconceptions.

"The biggest narrative being created is that these three bills, the Constitution Amendment Bill, bill on delimitation, and changes to the constituency election law, will harm the power of the South," he said.

"If we listen to the entire narrative created for the South, then out of the 543 seats created by you, 129 MPs currently sit in this House, which is approximately 23.76%. In the new House, 195 MPs will be sitting here, and their power will be 23.97%," he added.

Shah said Karnataka has 28 seats, and 5.15 per cent of the 543 seats in the House and after the passage of the bill, the number of Karnataka MPs will increase from 28 to 42, and the percentage in the Lok Sabha will increase to 5.44.

"Karnataka will not suffer any loss at all. Andhra Pradesh has 25 seats, which is 4.60 per cent. After the passage of the bill, the number of MPs will increase from 25 to 38. which will be 4.65 per cent," he said.

Shah said Telangana has 17 seats, which is 3.13 per cent and after the passage of the bill, the number of MPs will increase from 17 to 26, which will be 3.18 per cent.

"Tamil Nadu has 49 seats, which is 7.18 per cent. After the passage of the bill, the number of MPs will be 59, and their percentage in the new House of 816 will be 7.23 per cent. Tamil Nadu will also suffer no loss. Keralam has 20 seats, which is 3.68 per cent. After the passage of the bill, the number of MPs will be 30, and their percentage in the new House will be 3.67 per cent," he added.

Prime Minister Narendra Modi earlier sought to allay apprehension of opposition parties over the delimitation of constituencies and the "proportionate increase" in the strength of Lok Sabha to implement the Women's Reservation Act from the 2029 polls.

Participating in the debate on the Constitution Amendment Bill for early implementation of the Women's Reservation Act in the Lok Sabha, PM Modi said he can give a guarantee or a promise about his remarks if the opposition wants, as the government's intention is clear.

"I want to say from this House today with a great sense of responsibility that whether it is the South, the North, the East, the West, small states or large states... this decision-making process will not discriminate against or do injustice to anyone. In the past government that was in power, in whose time the delimitation took place, there will be no change in that proportion either, and the increase will also be in the same proportion," he said.

"If you need a guarantee, I give you a guarantee; if you need a promise, I make a promise... because if the intention is clear, there is no need to play games with words," he added.

Lok Sabha on Thursday took up simultaneous discussion on three bills for early implementation of Women's Reservation Act. The government had extended the budget session and called a three-day special sitting of Parliament for the purpose.

The Constitution (One Hundred and Thirty-First Amendment) Bill, 2026, The Union Territories Laws (Amendment) Bill, 2026 and The Delimitation Bill, 2026 were introduced and taken up for consideration and passing in the Lok Sabha earlier in the day.

PM Modi urged the House to pass the bills with consensus.

"This should not be weighed from a political angle. Those who are carrying half the responsibility of the nation also have the right to be here; we should not stop them," he said.

He said ever since the discussion on women's reservation took place in the country, and every time elections have come around thereafter, whoever has opposed this right being given, "women have not forgiven them".

"In the 2024 elections, this did not happen, and it did not happen because everyone passed it unanimously then, so the issue itself did not remain," he said.

"Those who opposed giving this right to women have not been forgiven by the women of this country. They have faced the consequences. If we all move forward together, this decision will not go in favour of any one political party, but in favour of the country's democracy," he added.

PM Modi said if there is unanimous support for the bills, it won't go in favour of any party.

"It will go in favour of the country's democracy, in favour

of the country's collective decision-making power, and we all will be deserving of that glory. Neither the Treasury Bench will be deserving of it, nor will Modi be deserving of it. Therefore, anyone who smells politics in this should take a look at their own outcomes from the past 30 years. Their benefit lies in this. They will be saved from whatever damage is happening. Therefore, there is no need to give it a political colour," he said.

He said anyone who wants to move forward in political life will have to accept that over the past 25 years, lakhs of women have emerged as grassroots leaders.

"The leadership that has developed at the grassroots level among women must be recognised and taken into account. Therefore, those who oppose this today will have to pay the price for a long time," he said.

- ANI

Share this article:

Reader Comments

R
Rohit P
As someone from Karnataka, I appreciate the detailed figures. Going from 28 to 42 MPs is a significant increase. The opposition should stop creating a North vs South divide. The focus should be on implementing women's reservation, which is long overdue.
S
Sarah B
While the numbers look good on paper, the real test will be in the execution. Delimitation is always a sensitive issue. I hope the process is transparent and fair, and the increased representation truly empowers women from all communities.
V
Vikram M
PM Modi's guarantee on no injustice to any region is reassuring. The women's reservation bill was passed unanimously, so why create hurdles now? This is about nation-building, not politics. Let's get it done.
A
Ananya R
The concern isn't just about seat numbers, it's about the principle. Southern states have controlled population growth effectively. Will they be penalized for that in future delimitation exercises? The government must address this core worry, not just current arithmetic.
K
Karthik V
Good to see concrete data. Tamil Nadu's share going from 7.18% to 7.23% is a small but positive move. The opposition's narrative seems baseless. We need more women in Parliament, period. This is a historic step.
M
Michael C

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Minimum 50 characters 0/50