Children must be taught discipline of using communication technology
So who is right? I think both the parents and the children are partially right.
Communication technology, which includes smartphones, internet, etc., has a powerful hold on children's brains. Their brains, at a young age, have the maximum power -- which means that they require tremendous amounts of inputs and information to wire different neural pathways. The formation of various neural pathways helps in satisfying desires and needs. Interactive technology like smartphones, iPads, internet, etc., allows instant gratification and hence is very addictive. This fritters away their time and energy -- they are unable to focus on the work at hand, resulting in their attention-deficit behaviour.
Instant gratification also fuels the greed-impulse and with no discipline to control this, it is the genesis of the greed exhibited in adulthood. This greed-impulse has unfortunately resulted in young children exhibiting unsavoury behavior -- such as making more money by stealing cellphones, cameras, etc., and becoming prey of pedophiles and prostitution gangs.
Meenakshi Satpute (name changed) is a school teacher in a small rural town in Maharashtra. Her house was burgled recently and her smartphone, camera and iPad were stolen. The needle of suspicion pointed to a young boy living close to her house. When he was taken to the local police station and questioned, he informed them that the majority of students his 8th standard class steal these gadgets as a part of play and to show off who has stolen the best gadget. It is a game for them and they also sell these stolen goods to get money.
This is not an isolated incident. Quite a number of school children all over the country indulge in such behaviour. How to curb this greed tendency in children is a great challenge for both parents and teachers.
Too often, parents give their children smartphones and iPads or deposit them in front of a TV when they are toddlers. Part of the reason is that by giving such "toys", parents feel that the child will not bother them since he/she will be entertained and immersed in playing with the device. But, by exposing the children to such tools at a very early age the parents are playing with fire since there is no mechanism to provide discipline in their use.
This does not mean that we should not expose children to modern technology. Technology begets technology. Without being exposed to technology, children's imagination will not be fired and they will not be able to contribute later to its development.
I became an engineer because I was exposed as a child to steam engines and the power of steam instilled in me the desire to be involved with the technology and getting an engineering education was the first step. All great feats of science and technology have resulted from people who, as children, were inspired by some aspect of gadgets and technology. For example, Einstein as a child was inspired by the magnetic compass. There are innumerable examples of inventors the world over who were inspired by technology when they were children.
However, the old technologies were not very interactive and so the child had to use tremendous imagination thinking about it and what could or would be. That required quite a lot of effort and fired his/her curiosity.
With today's "toys" like the internet and smartphones which provide instant information and feedback, the result is that curiosity and the desire to think deeply about a problem is lost. This is the reason why children today do not apply themselves too much to solving problems or creating new inventions but have a tremendous amount of information at hand. Also, with such interactive technologies children seem to be losing the ability to daydream. Daydreaming is a very powerful mechanism for the development of imagination and helps in sharpening the brain.
The biggest challenge for parents and teachers is how to teach children the discipline of using communication technology. It should be used for both fun and learning so that the tremendous energies which children have can be channeled for the betterment of society.
There are already some interesting experiments being done in the US, where children use smartphones and the internet to design projects which they can fabricate using 3-D printing technology. If hands-on projects can be planned and made using communication technology, then children can be weaned away from only chatting, SMSing and other less-productive use of this technology. For this the teachers have to work hard to develop an appropriate curriculum.
Communication technology for children is not all bad if used with discipline and if children are guided and inspired in the right direction.
(Anil Rajvanshi is the Director, Nimbkar Agricultural Research Institute at Phaltan, Maharashtra. The views expressed are personal. He can be contacted at firstname.lastname@example.org)