Key Points

Health Secretary Robert Kennedy Jr faced intense bipartisan questioning from senators over his firing of CDC Director Susan Monarez. Kennedy defended his decision while Monarez publicly accused him of weakening America's public health system. The hearing also addressed Kennedy's controversial vaccine policy changes that restricted Covid booster access. These developments come as Florida plans to become the first state to end all vaccine mandates.

Key Points: Robert Kennedy Jr Grilled in Senate Over CDC Firing and Vaccine Stance

  • Kennedy faced bipartisan Senate fury over firing CDC Director Susan Monarez
  • Defended dismissal calling Monarez untrustworthy amid WSJ accusations
  • Restricted Covid booster access saying not for healthy people
  • Replaced CDC vaccine panel with anti-vaccine movement allies
2 min read

US Health Secretary grilled in Senate on vaccine stance, CDC shake-up

US Health Secretary faces bipartisan Senate fury over firing CDC Director Susan Monarez and controversial vaccine policy changes restricting Covid booster access.

"It's not recommended for healthy people. - Robert Kennedy Jr"

Washington, Sep 5

US Health Secretary Robert Kennedy Jr. faced tough grilling from the Senate Finance Committee over his decision to fire Centres for Disease Control (CDC) Director Susan Monarez and his views on vaccines.

In the three-hour-long hearing held on Thursday, Kennedy faced bipartisan fury -- with many Republican lawmakers joining hands with Democrats to target him.

On the firing of CDC Director Monarez last week, Kennedy said that she was untrustworthy.

Monarez wrote an article in the Wall Street Journal on Thursday accusing Kennedy of making a "deliberate effort to weaken America's public-health system and vaccine protections".

Kennedy rejected those allegations.

"By the way, a month ago, you were voting against her because you thought she was either incompetent, ineligible, or unsuited to the task. Now I agree with you," the US Health Secretary told Democratic Senator Elizabeth Warren.

On Covid-19 vaccines, Warren also accused Kennedy of restricting access to the booster shot.

Kennedy shot back, saying, "It's not recommended for healthy people."

Democratic Senator Mark Warner asked Kennedy whether he agreed that "a million Americans died from Covid", Kennedy Jr. responded: "I don't know how many died."

Republican Senator Bill Cassidy also challenged Kennedy, noting that his constituents are struggling to access Covid-19 booster shots amid confusion created by the revised guidelines.

Since assuming office, Kennedy has introduced several contentious shifts in US vaccine policy -- restricting eligibility for Covid-19 shots and dismissing all 17 members of the CDC's vaccine advisory panel, replacing some with allies from the anti-vaccine movement.

The hearing comes a day after Florida announced that it plans to become the first US state to end all vaccine mandates, including for diseases like chicken pox, measles, polio and mumps.

The American Medical Association criticised the move, warning that "this unprecedented rollback would undermine decades of public health progress and place children and communities at increased risk".

Covid-19 was the third leading cause of death in the US in 2020 and 2021, fourth in 2022 and 10th in 2023, according to data from the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

Data from the World Health Organisation shows the US has reported about 1.2 million total deaths from Covid-19 through mid-August -- about one out of every six Covid deaths worldwide.

- IANS

Share this article:

Reader Comments

R
Rohit P
As someone who lost family members to COVID, I find it shocking that the Health Secretary doesn't even acknowledge the death toll. Vaccines saved countless lives here in India.
M
Michael C
While I support questioning vaccine policies, firing the entire CDC advisory panel and replacing them with anti-vaccine activists seems extreme. There should be balance in public health decisions.
A
Ananya R
We saw how polio was eradicated in India through vaccination drives. Removing mandates for diseases like measles and polio is dangerous - these diseases can make a comeback! 😟
S
Sarah B
The bipartisan anger tells you everything. When both sides agree someone is wrong, maybe they should listen. Public health shouldn't be political.
V
Vikram M
Florida ending all vaccine mandates is worrying. We've seen outbreaks happen when vaccination rates drop. Hope they reconsider for the sake of public safety.

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Minimum 50 characters 0/50