Karnataka Minister's Sharp Rebuke: Why Sudha Murty Refused State Survey

Karnataka Minister HK Patil expressed disappointment over Sudha Murty and Narayana Murthy refusing to participate in the state's socio-economic survey. He clarified that the survey aims to identify backwardness through comprehensive data collection. Chief Minister Siddaramaiah also criticized the couple, calling their understanding of the exercise "wrong" and questioning their potential cooperation with central government surveys. The controversy has sparked broader discussions about public figures' participation in government initiatives.

Key Points: HK Patil on Sudha Murty Narayana Murthy Karnataka Survey Boycott

  • Minister HK Patil terms Murthys' survey refusal as unfortunate misunderstanding
  • Survey aims to identify backwardness through socio-economic conditions analysis
  • CM Siddaramaiah questions if they'd boycott central caste census too
  • Minister Priyank Kharge suggests BJP influence behind Murthys' decision
3 min read

Unfortunate that Sudha Murty misunderstood socio-economic survey: Karnataka Minister HK Patil

Karnataka Minister HK Patil calls Sudha Murty's refusal to participate in socio-economic survey "unfortunate misunderstanding" amid growing political criticism.

"It is unfortunate she misunderstood this socio-economic survey being conducted - HK Patil"

Bengaluru, October 17

Karnataka Minister HK Patil on Friday said that Rajya Sabha MP Sudha Murthy and her husband, Infosys founder Narayana Murthy, misunderstood the ongoing Social and Educational Survey in the state, and termed it unfortunate that they refused to participate in the survey.

"It is unfortunate she (Sudha Murty) misunderstood this socio-economic survey being conducted. This is to identify the backwardness considering the socio-economic conditions. There is no reason why any sane thinking person should refuse to give this information," Patil told ANI.

Infosys founder Narayana Murthy and his wife Sudha Murty have declined to take part in the ongoing Social and Educational Survey in Karnataka, saying they do not belong to any backward caste.

Earlier, Karnataka Chief Minister Siddaramaiah also criticised Sudha Murty and Narayana Murthy.

Calling Sudha Murty's understanding of the exercise "wrong," Siddaramiah said that the couple's decision stemmed from misinformation. He questioned whether they would also decline to cooperate if the Centre undertook a similar caste survey.

"It is wrong to think of the survey as a survey of the backward classes," Siddaramaiah told reporters. "The central government will also conduct a caste census in the coming days. Will they still not cooperate? They may be showing such disobedience due to the misinformation they have. The state has a population of about seven crore, and this is an economic, educational and social survey of these people."

He further stated that the initiative involved people from all sections. "This is a survey that is being done, including the entire population. Under the Shakti Yojana, the poor and the upper castes will all be included. There is misinformation about this. The government has conveyed the messages of the ministers and the chief minister to the people through advertisements. It's a survey of seven crore people of the state," he said.

Earlier on Thursday, Karnataka Minister Priyank Kharge also expressed his disappointment over Sudha Murty opting out of Karnataka's socio-economic survey. He said it was surprising that a member of parliament would make such statements. He questioned whether Murty's decision was influenced by BJP leaders, given her association with the party.

Speaking to reporters, Priyank Kharge said, "The Caste Census is a government initiative. First of all, it is a survey that includes a wealth of additional information. It is surprising that a member of parliament makes such statements. Clearly, I think it is inspired by other BJP leaders or the co-direction, saying it is voluntary, but more is expected from people like them because they inspire many generations and continue to do so. However, saying that I will not participate in a government survey is not right. You could have refused to answer a few questions at most."

- ANI

Share this article:

Reader Comments

P
Priya S
Actually, I understand why Sudha Murty refused. Many upper-caste families feel uncomfortable with caste-based surveys. The government should ensure data privacy and explain the purpose better.
S
Sarah B
As someone living in Bengaluru, I participated in this survey last week. It took only 15 minutes and the questions were quite comprehensive about education, income, and social status. Nothing to fear!
A
Arjun K
This is disappointing from the Murthys. They are role models for millions of Indians. When government asks for data for policy making, we should cooperate. Jai Karnataka! 🙏
K
Kavya N
Both sides have valid points. The government needs to build more trust around data protection, while public figures should lead by example. Hope this misunderstanding gets resolved soon.
M
Michael C
Interesting debate. In democratic countries, citizens have the right to participate or not in surveys. The ministers' criticism seems a bit harsh for what should be voluntary participation.

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Minimum 50 characters 0/50