Key Points

The CEO of Sona Comstar is calling for direct government intervention with China over rare earth export restrictions. His company has already suffered significant production losses and is using less efficient alternatives. China's dominance in global magnet production creates major supply chain vulnerabilities for industries worldwide. Meanwhile, India is pursuing domestic production incentives and international partnerships to diversify its supply sources.

Key Points: Sona Comstar CEO Urges India China Talks on Rare Earth Magnet Exports

  • Sona Comstar suffered three weeks of production loss due to rare earth shortage
  • Company using less efficient rare-earth-free magnets as interim solution
  • China controls over 90% of global magnet production creating vulnerabilities
  • India investing Rs 1,345 crore to incentivise domestic magnet production
3 min read

Sona Comstar CEO urges government to engage China on rare earth magnet export controls

Sona Comstar CEO Vivek Vikram Singh urges government talks with China to lift rare earth magnet export controls, citing production losses and industry-wide supply constraints.

"We need solutions. The government should talk to the Chinese side and get rid of these rare earth export controls. - Vivek Vikram Singh"

New Delhi, September 12

Vivek Vikram Singh, Managing Director and Group CEO of Sona Comstar, has urged the government to hold discussions with China to address the supply constraints around rare earth metals that are vital for the auto component industry.

"We need solutions. The government should talk to the Chinese side and get rid of these rare earth export controls. The interim solution (using rare-earth-free magnets) is not the best solution. This affects us and our customers. It would be good if the problem is resolved. We are operating with constraints now, and our hope is that we will run smoothly going ahead," Singh said, talking to ANI on the sidelines of the Automotive Component Manufacturers Association's annual event here in the national capital.

He noted that the company suffered about three weeks of production loss in the past quarter due to a rare earth shortage.

While Sona Comstar has started using alternatives, he admitted these come with limitations.

"In August, we have reached 95% production level. We have started using heavy, rare-earth-free magnets. However, it is not fully efficient on the cost and performance side, particularly for the heavy-duty motors. For two and three-wheelers, they are okay. For cars and buses, they are next to impossible," he said.

Early this April, China announced a decision to implement export controls on certain rare earth-related items, pushing a supply shortage across the world, including India. Export controls imposed by China have raised concerns about supply chain vulnerabilities, particularly in critical sectors.

India aims to diversify its rare earth supply through a combination of imports, domestic mining and international partnerships. The government is investing in research and development to improve domestic refining and processing capabilities. India is also engaging in diplomatic efforts to secure stable and affordable access to rare earth materials, while also promoting cooperation with like-minded countries.

The central government has recently earmarked Rs 1,345 crore to incentivise rare earth magnets production in India.

China's overwhelming control of global rare earth processing - commanding over 90 per cent of the world's magnet production capacity - has created significant vulnerabilities for industries worldwide. Beyond China, there are only a few alternative suppliers of critical minerals.

Meanwhile, Singh also welcomed the recent GST rate rationalisation, describing it as a timely boost for the industry.

"The GST rate cuts are a Bardaan (boon) for the industry, and Modi ji has got Diwali early this year. If the GST rate cut is completely transmitted to consumers, then the demand can rise upwards of 10-15 per cent. Growth is definite. It is a positive and a bold step," he said.

Asked about the impact of U.S. tariffs, Singh said the sector is relatively unaffected.

"Our sector is less affected...The expected loss in overall exports to the US because of the tariffs can largely be negated by the GST reforms," he explained.

Singh also underlined the importance of trade negotiations with Europe. An India-EU FTA is expected to be finalised later this year, and talks for the deal are currently underway.

"From India's point of view, the European FTA is very important. The size of the EU market in terms of auto is lower than that of the US, but it is quite crucial. In terms of value, too, it is quite sizable. For India, it is a big opportunity and we should not miss this opportunity," he said.

- ANI

Share this article:

Reader Comments

P
Priya S
This is why we need to invest more in domestic mining and processing. Relying on China for critical materials is risky business. Good that government has allocated funds, but implementation needs to be faster.
M
Michael C
As someone in the auto industry, I can confirm the supply chain disruptions are real. The alternatives just don't perform as well for larger vehicles. Hope the government takes this seriously.
A
Ananya R
While I understand the need for dialogue with China, we should also focus on partnerships with other countries like Australia and Japan who have rare earth resources. Diversification is key! 🤝
S
Sarah B
The GST cuts are indeed a positive step, but the rare earth issue shows we need to think long-term about supply chain security. Can't keep depending on one country for critical materials.
V
Vikram M
Three weeks production loss is huge for any company! This affects not just Sona Comstar but the entire automotive ecosystem. Hope the government acts quickly on this.
K
Karthik V
Good to see industry leaders speaking up about real issues. The EU FTA mentioned is crucial - we need more trade partnerships to reduce dependency on any single market.

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Minimum 50 characters 0/50