NewKerala.com Logo

Shashi Tharoor claims Sankaran Nair would never have used words Akshay Kumar did in 'Kesari Chapter 2'

IANS April 27, 2025 249 views

Congress MP Shashi Tharoor watched Akshay Kumar's "Kesari Chapter 2" and offered a nuanced review of the historical drama. While praising the film's overall quality and powerful message about colonial resistance, Tharoor critiqued the language used by Kumar's character. The movie, set against the Jallianwala Bagh massacre, impressed Tharoor with its storytelling and historical significance. Tharoor also reiterated his long-standing call for a formal British apology for colonial atrocities.

"I thought it was an amazingly well-made, well-crafted film" - Shashi Tharoor"
Shashi Tharoor claims Sankaran Nair would never have used words Akshay Kumar did in 'Kesari Chapter 2'
Mumbai, April 27: Congress MP Shashi Tharoor recently watched Akshay Kumar's recent release, “Kesari Chapter 2,” and praised the movie for its portrayal.

Key Points

1

Tharoor admires film's portrayal of Sankaran Nair's resistance

2

Movie captures spirit of Jallianwala Bagh tragedy

3

Criticizes Akshay Kumar's dialogue choices

4

Calls for British apology for colonial massacre

However, he expressed concerns over certain dialogue choices in the film, stating that C. Sankaran Nair would never have used the words spoken by Akshay's character in the film. After watching the film, Shashi Tharoor expressed his opinions, praising the historical drama for its overall impact. The Congress MP shared, "I thought it was an amazingly well-made, well-crafted film. It took some liberties with historical fact, but it says at the very beginning it's fiction. But what it did was capture the spirit of resistance, especially using the instruments of the British court system. You can't win in the end. And we, sadly, waited 28 years after Jallianwala Bagh to become free."

"But the message of the film was brilliantly done. I must say, as usual, in a very high-quality production, the acting, the direction, the way the story unfolded, everything was just so compelling. There wasn't one dull moment. I mean, I was worried that for many people, just seeing courtroom scenes might not be so compelling."

Shashi Tharoor, who is himself from Kerala, went on to state, "But the way the story came out, I think it was impossible to turn your eye away for one second. Very riveting, very well done. I've been a fan of Sir Chettur Shankaran Nair for a long time. In fact, eight years ago, here in Tiruvannamalai, I delivered a speech memorializing him and talking about his life and achievements. But though some of this, of course, romanticizes him, if you like, in a very, very positive way, I think the fact that he was a man of courage and principle and integrity comes through. He would never have used some of the words that Akshay Kumar uses, particularly a certain four-letter word, which would never have come out of Sir Chettur Shankaran Nair."

Akshay Kumar, who portrays the role of lawyer C. Sankaran Nair in the film, used the phrase "f**k you" in one of the scenes.

Shashi added, "I can tell you that for sure. But the spirit, the message, and the very clever way in which the message was allowed to come across were extremely well done. And I will say that, you know, we need films to remind people of some of the atrocities that were inflicted. Jallianwala Bagh, in particular, was in many ways emblematic of the worst sins of the British Raj. I am proud that when I wrote my book about the empire, Inglorious Empire in England in the Era of Darkness Here, and when I then did a book tour in the UK, the point I made very strongly was the need for an apology for the massacre. And I'm glad that at the end of the film, they made the point in their screenshot that the one thing the British have never done is say sorry."

"On the 100th anniversary in 2019, the Prime Minister did speak in the House of Commons, but all she said was that they regret the events of that day. That's not the same as an apology. And I think this film is a reminder to the British and to all of us that that apology is still due. But my congratulations to the filmmakers. They've done a wonderful job, and I certainly would not hesitate to recommend this film to audiences across our country, with subtitles in English as well. Let them watch it," Tharoor further mentioned.

On a related note, "Kesari: Chapter 2," directed by Karan Singh Tyagi, also stars R. Madhavan, Ananya Panday, and Regina Cassandra. Set against the backdrop of the Jallianwala Bagh massacre, the film was released in theatres on April 18, 2025.

Reader Comments

P
Priya M.
Interesting perspective from Mr. Tharoor! While I understand his point about historical accuracy, films do take creative liberties to make stories more engaging. The important thing is they captured the spirit of resistance. Can't wait to watch it! 🎬
R
Rahul K.
Tharoor makes a valid criticism about the language used. Historical figures should be portrayed authentically - especially someone as respected as Sankaran Nair. The F-bomb might get cheers in theaters but does feel out of place for that era.
S
Sunita P.
Saw the film last weekend and it gave me goosebumps! Akshay's performance was powerful, though I agree some dialogues felt modern. The courtroom scenes were especially gripping - didn't feel long at all. More films like this please!
A
Arjun S.
Respectfully disagree with Tharoor here. Films aren't documentaries - they need dramatic moments to connect with today's audience. That "f**k you" scene got the biggest cheer in my theater! Sometimes creative choices serve the emotion over strict accuracy.
N
Neha T.
Appreciate Tharoor's balanced review - praising the film while pointing out its flaws. The British still owe us that apology 💯 More people should know about heroes like Sankaran Nair. Might read Tharoor's book after watching this!

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Your email won't be published

Disclaimer: Comments are the opinions of users and not of this website or it's staff. News stories are provided by news agencies. We do not guarantee their accuracy. Inappropriate content may be removed. By posting, you agree to our terms.

You May Like!