New Delhi, Aug 19
Nearly one-third of India’s prison undertrial population comprises Scheduled Caste (SC) and Scheduled Tribe (ST) inmates, according to data tabled in the Lok Sabha on Tuesday.
As of December 31, 2022, out of 4.34 lakh undertrials across the country, 90,951 (20.94 per cent) were SCs and 40,221 (9.26 per cent) were STs, Minister of Home for State Affairs Bandi Sanjay Kumar said in Lok Sabha in a written response.
Uttar Pradesh reported the highest number of SC undertrials at 24,693 (26.23 per cent), followed by Bihar with 11,826 (20.55 per cent) and Punjab with 8,306 (34.33per cent) and others.
Among ST undertrials, Madhya Pradesh led with 5,706 (21.23 per cent), Uttar Pradesh with 5,209 (5,53 per cent), Chhattisgarh with 4,044 (31.54 per cent), and Jharkhand with 4,056 (27.43 per cent).
Disproportionate representation was stark in the North-East. In Mizoram, 96.19 per cent of undertrials were STs, Nagaland 70.86 per cent, Meghalaya 76.12 per cent, and Lakshadweep recorded 100 per cent.
Arunachal Pradesh also reported 66.30 per cent ST undertrials. Among SCs, Tamil Nadu (30.72 per cent), Odisha (30.56 per cent), Chandigarh (30.17 per cent), and Himachal Pradesh (29.18 per cent) reflected a heavy presence in the prison population, far higher than their share in the general population.
Of the 44,862 SC/ST convicts nationwide, SCs accounted for 26,952 and STs 17,910. Uttar Pradesh again topped with 5,943 SC convicts, while Madhya Pradesh reported the highest ST convicts at 4,910.
Chhattisgarh (2,542), Jharkhand (1,633), and Odisha (1,011) also recorded large ST convict populations.
The Ministry of Home Affairs noted that while prisons are a state subject, several steps are being taken to address prolonged pre-trial detention. State Legal Services Authorities have set up legal service clinics inside jails, and the National Legal Services Authority (NALSA) conducts awareness drives on bail, plea bargaining, and Lok Adalats.
Videoconferencing between courts and jails is also being used to speed up trials. However, Maharashtra did not provide a caste-wise breakup of prisoners.
The data highlights the over-representation of SCs and STs in the prison system, particularly as undertrials, reflecting deep structural issues in policing, investigation, and access to legal remedies.
— IANS
Reader Comments
The numbers from Northeast states are particularly alarming. 100% ST undertrials in Lakshadweep? This shows systematic targeting of tribal communities. Need urgent judicial reforms.
While the data is concerning, we must also consider that crime rates might be higher in economically disadvantaged communities. The solution isn't just legal reform but also economic empowerment and education.
As someone working in legal aid, I've seen firsthand how SC/ST communities struggle to access proper legal representation. Many can't afford bail or lawyers. The system is stacked against them from day one.
Uttar Pradesh and Bihar numbers are shocking but expected. Police often target marginalized communities for easy convictions. This data should be a wake-up call for our law enforcement agencies.
The fact that Maharashtra didn't provide caste-wise data speaks volumes. Transparency is the first step toward addressing this injustice. All states must be compelled to share complete data.
Legal aid clinics and video conferencing are good steps, but they're not enough. We need community-based policing, sensitivity training for police, and faster trial systems specifically for marginalized groups.
We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.