'Sacred items should not be touched': Shivakumar on Janivara row

IANS April 21, 2025 240 views

Karnataka's Deputy Chief Minister D.K. Shivakumar has strongly condemned the removal of sacred threads during the Common Entrance Test. He emphasized that religious items are personal and should not be interfered with by examination authorities. The incident led to the suspension of college principal and staff in Bidar district after a police investigation. Shivakumar's statement highlights the sensitive nature of religious practices in educational settings.

"Sacred items such as thaali, bangles, ear rings and 'Janivara' should not be touched" - D.K. Shivakumar
Bengaluru, April 21: After the Karnataka government faced backlash over the sacred thread removal issue, Deputy Chief Minister D.K. Shivakumar slammed the authorities on Monday, saying that sacred items should not be touched.

Key Points

1

Karnataka officials suspended for blocking students with sacred threads

2

Exam authorities criticized for religious interference

3

Shivakumar supports students' religious sentiments

"It was wrong to remove the 'Janivara'. People wear items like the 'linga' (Shiva lingam) or 'udu-dara' (a string of cotton tied around the waist). Sacred items such as thaali, bangles, ear rings and 'Janivara' should not be touched," said the Deputy Chief Minister when asked about the incident where sacred threads (Janivara/ Janeu) were removed during the CET examination.

The Deputy Chief Minister said that these are personal religious matters, adding that the government does not support interference in such matters.

"There is a practice of removing such items during police recruitment tests, but they should not be removed in schools or colleges. What was done here is wrong. In the past, there have been incidents where students used hidden Bluetooth devices and other gadgets to cheat. Measures have now been taken to prevent such malpractices," he said.

Principal and staff of Sai Spoorthi Pre-University College in Karnataka's Bidar district were suspended after a probe by the police confirmed that students were not allowed to take the Common Entrance Test (CET) for wearing the sacred thread (Janivara/Janeu), in violation of rules and guidelines.

Chandrashekhar Biradar, the Principal of Sai Spoorthi Pre-University College in Bidar, and the college's invigilator Satish Pawar have been suspended on the order of the Higher Education Department Secretary, K. G. Jagadeesha.

The action was taken immediately after Bidar Deputy Commissioner Shilpa Sharma submitted the report.

The Karnataka State Commission for Protection of Child Rights has also registered a suo motu complaint.

Besides, a police complaint has been filed against an officer attached to the Education Department on Saturday for allegedly denying entry to students wearing the sacred thread into the examination hall during the Common Entrance Test (CET) in Karnataka's Shivamogga district.

Suchivrat Kulkarni, the student who was denied the opportunity to write the CET exam, told the media that he was stopped. He said a staff member made a reckless comment, asking what would happen if someone committed suicide using the sacred thread inside the examination hall.

Shivakumar also criticised the Karnataka Leader of the Opposition R. Ashoka, on the caste census, saying that a person who holds a responsible position should not lie.

"If he wants to know whether the caste census report is genuine or fake, he should ask Jayaprakash Hegde, who was the chairman of the commission, or the officer Dayanand. He will get the answer," said the Deputy Chief Minister.

On Minister Satish Jarkiholi's comment that it would take another year to implement the caste census, he said, "This is an internal matter to be discussed within the Cabinet."

Earlier, LoP Ashoka had claimed that what exists now is a fake report of the caste census report.

Reader Comments

P
Priya M.
Finally someone spoke sense! Religious sentiments should always be respected. The way these students were treated was completely unacceptable. 🙏
R
Rahul K.
While I agree religious items should be respected, we also need to ensure exam integrity. Maybe there's a middle ground - like allowing transparent inspection instead of removal?
S
Sunita P.
The comment about suicide was completely insensitive! These are sacred threads, not some random objects. The suspension was absolutely warranted.
A
Arjun T.
I appreciate Shivakumar speaking up, but this feels like selective outrage. Why wasn't action taken sooner? And what about similar issues faced by students from other religions?
M
Meena S.
As a teacher, I understand both sides. But there has to be a better way to handle this. Maybe special guidelines for religious items during exams? This could prevent future conflicts.
V
Vikram R.
The sacred thread is part of our identity. Would they ask someone to remove their cross necklace or hijab? Religious freedom must be protected in all cases. Good that action was taken!

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Your email won't be published


Disclaimer: Comments here reflect the author's views alone. Insulting or using offensive language against individuals, communities, religion, or the nation is illegal.

Tags:
You May Like!