Key Points

The recent rapid strengthening of US-Pakistan ties is creating a new tension point in India-US relations. A potential meeting between Pakistani PM Shehbaz Sharif and former President Donald Trump would highlight this momentum. Additionally, a new mutual defence pact between Pakistan and Saudi Arabia significantly alters regional security dynamics. India's government has stated it will closely study the implications of these developments for its national security.

Key Points: US Pakistan Ties Resurgence Tensions India Relations Kugelman

  • Kugelman notes India accepted US-Pakistan friendship but rapid resurgence creates friction
  • Potential Shehbaz Sharif meeting with Donald Trump signals major relationship momentum
  • Pakistan-Saudi Arabia defence pact is a game changer for regional security dynamics
  • The pact formally places Pakistan within the Middle East's vital security architecture
  • India's MEA states it will study the pact's implications for national security
5 min read

Resurgence in US-Pak ties a tension point in India-US relations: South Asia analyst Kugelman

Analyst Michael Kugelman says the rapid strengthening of US-Pakistan ties, including a potential Sharif-Trump meeting, creates new friction for India-US relations.

"This resurgence in US-Pakistan ties has become a tension point in US-India relations - Michael Kugelman"

New York, September 25

The recent strengthening of US-Pakistan ties has emerged as a significant "tension point" in India-US relations, according to South Asia analyst Michael Kugelman, particularly in light of recent geopolitical frictions between Washington and New Delhi.

Speaking to ANI on Wednesday on the sidelines of the 80th United Nations General Assembly in New York, Kugelman noted that while India has long accepted the US-Pakistan friendship, including military aspects, the rapid resurgence has amplified existing frictions.

"As we know, India quite some time ago accepted the fact that the US and Pakistan would have a friendly relationship, including a friendly military relationship. This resurgence in US-Pakistan ties has become a tension point in US-India relations, just because there are so many other bad things happening in US-India relations and also the US-Pakistan relationship has really strengthened very quickly in very big ways," Kugelman said.

He pointed to the expected visit of Pakistani Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif to Washington to meet US President Donald Trump as a key indicator of the relationship's momentum, while also referring to the role of Pakistan's Army Chief Asim Munir in strengthening the relationship.

"If it is true that Prime Minister of Pakistan Shehbaz Sharif goes to Washington to meet with President Trump, that would be the latest indication of just how far this relationship has come... Honestly, after the meeting between President Trump and Field Marshal Munir, anything that comes after that would not be as significant, given how powerful Munir is," Kugelman added.

Kugelman also weighed in on the recently announced mutual defence pact between Pakistan and Saudi Arabia, calling it a "game changer" for regional security dynamics and a development that India will be watching closely.

While he noted that Saudi Arabia is unlikely to let its defence pact with Pakistan undermine its growing partnership with India, the agreement formally places Pakistan within the security framework of the Middle East, a region vital to India's strategic interests.

"It's a game changer. I think that it's significant for India in the sense that India has a very close relationship with Saudi Arabia and also, given the history of relations between India and Pakistan, there certainly is a chance that sometime in the future, India will attack Pakistan. Because of these terrorism concerns and the past precedent, it's a mutual defence pact between Saudi Arabia and Pakistan," he explained.

"Saudi Arabia has a strong relationship with India. It's not going to let this pact get in the way of Saudi-India relations. But with the fact that Pakistan now has a formal institutionalised alliance with Saudi Arabia, even as it continues to pursue its very strong partnerships with China and Turkey and other Arab Gulf states, as well as this resurgence in ties with the US, Pakistan has been able to resurrect and fortify a lot of its alliances and I think that poses some new challenges for India," Kugelman added.

The analyst, however, acknowledged India's strong geopolitical position, noting its partnerships with Europe, Israel, key Middle Eastern players, and Russia.

"As this has formally enshrined Pakistan in the security architecture of the Middle East, it is important for India, given how important the Middle East is to India's own strategic interests," he concluded.

Last week, Saudi Arabia and Pakistan signed a "Strategic Mutual Defence Agreement", pledging that any aggression against either nation would be treated as an attack on both.

According to a joint statement issued following the visit, "This agreement, which reflects the shared commitment of both nations to enhance their security and to achieving security and peace in the region and the world, aims to develop aspects of defence cooperation between the two countries and strengthen joint deterrence against any aggression. The agreement states that any aggression against either country shall be considered an aggression against both."

Hours after the announcement, the Ministry of External Affairs issued a response stating that it would closely study the pact's implications for India's national security and regional and global stability.

In a statement, MEA Spokesperson Randhir Jaiswal stated that New Delhi acknowledges the formalisation of what it described as a "long-standing arrangement" between Saudi Arabia and Pakistan, while noting that it would closely examine its potential ramifications.

Jaiswal further emphasised that India's national security remains paramount in light of this development.

"We have seen reports of the signing of a strategic mutual defence pact between Saudi Arabia and Pakistan. The Government was aware that this development, which formalises a long-standing arrangement between the two countries, had been under consideration. We will study the implications of this development for our national security as well as for regional and global stability. The Government remains committed to protecting India's national interests and ensuring comprehensive national security in all domains," the statement from the MEA read.

- ANI

Share this article:

Reader Comments

P
Priya S
The Saudi-Pakistan defence pact is really worrying. Saudi Arabia has been a good partner for India, but this puts them in a difficult position. Hope our diplomacy can handle this carefully.
A
Aditya G
America's foreign policy is so inconsistent. One day they're our strategic partner, next day they're cozying up to Pakistan. We can't depend on any country completely - Make in India is the way forward! 💪
S
Sarah B
As someone who follows international relations closely, I think Kugelman makes valid points. India has strong partnerships globally, but the rapid realignment in our neighborhood requires careful strategic planning.
K
Karthik V
The mention of "India will attack Pakistan" is quite sensational. We are a peaceful nation that believes in dialogue. Our focus should be on economic growth and technological advancement, not war-mongering.
M
Michael C
Interesting analysis. The Middle East security architecture inclusion of Pakistan does change regional dynamics. India's response through MEA has been measured and professional - exactly what's needed.
S
Shreya B
Our foreign policy team is competent enough to handle this. India has come a long way in global standing. We have strong relationships with UAE, Israel, France - not just dependent on US or Saudi. Have faith! 🙏

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Minimum 50 characters 0/50