Key Points

Political leaders in Bihar are switching parties as assembly elections approach in November. Several MLAs including RJD's Bharat Bind and Congress's Murari Prasad Gautam have recently resigned from their positions. This continues a long tradition in Indian politics where leaders change allegiance for better prospects. The phenomenon dates back decades, with anti-defection laws introduced in 1985 to curb such practices.

Key Points: Bihar Election Season Sparks Political Defections and Party Hopping

  • RJD MLA Bharat Bind resigns after joining BJP earlier this year
  • Congress MLA Murari Prasad Gautam also resigns from Assembly seat
  • Nitish Kumar called "paltu ram" for changing alliance partners
  • Anti-defection law introduced in 1985 to check party-hopping
  • Historical data shows 540 defections between 1951-1967
  • Former Union Minister Nagmani changed nearly dozen parties in 23 years
  • Deputy CM Samrat Choudhary led multiple parties before BJP
  • Haryana's Bhajan Lal termed "master of horse-trading"
4 min read

As poll process heats up in Bihar, it's time to party-hop for some

As Bihar gears up for November elections, political leaders switch parties seeking comfortable victories and higher positions, continuing India's long tradition of defections.

"Aya Ram, Gaya Ram (he comes, he goes) - Common political phrase describing party-hoppers"

New Delhi, Oct 9

Even as Bihar gears up for upcoming Assembly elections scheduled for November 6 and 11, reports are coming on political leaders switching allegiance, possibly looking for a comparatively comfortable victory or elevation in the party hierarchy.

Rashtriya Janata Dal (RJD) MLA Bharat Bind, who was reported to have joined the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) earlier this year, recently resigned from the state Assembly.

In 2020, Bind won from Bihar's Bhabua Assembly constituency defeating his nearest rival Rinki Rani Pandey of the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) by more than 10,000 votes.

In the 2015 Assembly polls, contesting from the same seat, but on a Bahujan Samaj Party (BSP) ticket, Bind came a distant third behind the BJP and Janata Dal-United (JD-U) candidates.

Incidentally, in 2015, JD-U was not in alliance with the BJP.

Similarly, Congress MLA Murari Prasad Gautam, who defeated JD-U's Lalan Paswan by 18,000 votes at the Chenari Assembly seat in 2020 state polls, has also resigned.

Incidentally, Paswan won the seat in 2015, but then as an Rashtriya Lok Samata Party (RLSP) candidate.

Former Union Minister Nagmani Kushwaha has changed, or launched, close to a dozen parties in the last 23 years.

The septuagenarian Dalit leader is followed by the sexagenarian Upendra Kushwaha, another former Union Minister who has also turned from one to another organisation about half-a-dozen times.

Samrat Choudhary, currently the Deputy Chief Minister in Bihar, has also been leader of the state's principal political parties before joining the BJP.

Though JD-U supremo and Chief Minister Nitish Kumar has earned the sobriquet of "paltu ram" or the flip-flop man, it has been for changing alliance partners.

It was the same for the late Ram Vilas Paswan, who was known as the political weathercock, who would sense the mandate even before election results are announced and ally with the winning side.

Former Bihar Chief Minister Jitan Ram Manjhi has also been shifting alliance in the past 10 years.

Party hopping is not a recent phenomenon.

In 1967-68, for close to a year, there were several such flip-flops by legislators in several states.

Thus, in 1969, the Y.B. Chavan Committee was asked to address the issue of defections.

Between the first and the fourth general elections (1951-1967), some 540 instances of defections have been reported.

The trend was, and still is, found also among Independent candidates, especially in case of a hung verdict.

It has been observed that, termed as "horse trading", the lure of material gain and office play a dominant part in such decisions of defection.

The Constitution (Thirty-second Amendment) Bill, 1973, was introduced in the Lok Sabha on May 16, 1973, for constitutionally providing for disqualification on defections.

It was referred to a Joint Committee of the Houses of Parliament which became defunct with the dissolution of the fifth Lok Sabha in 1977.

The Constitution (Forty-eighth Amendment) Bill, 1979, introduced in the Lok Sabha in another attempt to check defection was withdrawn, being opposed by members from both the ruling and opposition parties.

After the 1984 general elections, one more move was made through the Constitution (Fifty-second Amendment) Bill in Lok Sabha and an anti-defection law was brought in January 1985 to check such party-hopping.

However, the choice of joining a political party can not be entirely banned, considering a person's right to do so in a democratic setup.

"Aya Ram, Gaya Ram (he comes, he goes)" is often used to reflect the journey of party-hoppers.

In Haryana, Bhajan Lal was once termed the "master of horse-trading" with his inherent power of persuasion and forging alliances across party lines.

Some legislators from the state, like Hira Nand Arya and Gaya Lal, are still recalled for their political somersaults.

Such political travellers are, however, not limited to politics in India alone.

There are several such instances from others nations, like Britain and Australia.

- IANS

Share this article:

Reader Comments

P
Priya S
As a voter from Bihar, I'm tired of this musical chairs game. Every election season, we see the same drama. When will our leaders think about development instead of party-hopping? 😔
S
Sarah B
While I understand the frustration, we should also consider that sometimes politicians might genuinely feel their original party isn't serving public interest. The anti-defection law needs to be strengthened but not eliminate all flexibility.
V
Vikram M
Nitish Kumar being called "paltu ram" is so accurate! 🤣 But seriously, this affects governance continuity. Bihar needs stable leadership to progress.
A
Ananya R
The article mentions this isn't new - since 1951-1967 there were 540 defections! This shows our political system has deep-rooted issues that need structural reforms, not just temporary fixes.
M
Michael C
Interesting to see this happens in other democracies too. But in India, the scale seems much larger. Voters need to be more aware and punish such behavior at the ballot box.
K
Kavya N
When leaders like Nagmani Kushwaha change parties dozen times in 23 years, what ideology do they even stand for? This is pure opportunism. Shameful! 👎

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Minimum 50 characters 0/50