'Players decide who takes penalties', says Guardiola after FA Cup final loss to Palace

IANS May 18, 2025 328 views

Manchester City lost the FA Cup final to Crystal Palace in a tightly contested match at Wembley. Pep Guardiola revealed that players, not coaches, decide penalty takers during the game. The missed penalty by Omar Marmoush proved critical in the defeat. Despite controlling possession, City couldn't convert their chances and fell short of winning the trophy.

"They take a decision, penalties are like that. I like guys who take initiative" - Pep Guardiola
London, May 18: Manchester City boss Pep Guardiola said he did not dictate who took City's penalty in Saturday's FA Cup final defeat to Crystal Palace.

Key Points

1

Marmoush missed crucial penalty against Palace

2

City dominated but failed to score

3

Henderson made decisive save

4

Guardiola supports player autonomy

City fell behind 1-0 to an early Eberechi Eze strike, despite controlling possession for much of the match at Wembley. Guardiola's side fashioned numerous opportunities, with Omar Marmoush's 36th-minute penalty arguably the most clear-cut chance.

Erling Haaland held on to the ball while VAR checked the referee's decision for a trip on Bernardo Silva before handing it to Marmoush when the penalty was confirmed. The Egyptian hit his effort powerfully but saw it stopped by the diving Dean Henderson.

Asked in his post-match press conference who decided that Marmoush should shoot, Guardiola insisted it was worked out between the two forwards on the pitch.

"I didn't speak with them (Haaland and Marmoush). They take a decision, penalties are like that. I like guys who take initiative and they decide. In that moment, it's how they feel. They decided Omar was ready to take it. Omar took a lot of time when the ball was stopped and after he kicked so it put more pressure on him and Henderson made a good save," Guardiola was quoted by Manchester City website.

Reflecting on the defeat, Guardiola admitted it was a disappointing feeling but added that he was satisfied with the way his side performed.

Congratulations to Crystal Palace on their first FA Cup. It is history. We played a good defensive game and controlled the transitions, and incredible threat except the goal. They are difficult to control at throw-ins and corners and free-kicks but we could not score in the last two games.

"We played better than the Southampton game, we were more active, and I would say we were really good in many things. We created a lot but we didn't score and that's why we could not win," he said.

Reader Comments

R
Rahul K.
As an Indian football fan, I find it strange that Haaland didn't take the penalty. He's their main striker! In our ISL, captains usually decide penalty takers. Guardiola's approach seems too casual for such a big match. 🤔
P
Priya M.
The pressure must have been immense for Marmoush! Reminds me of when Sunil Chhetri takes penalties for India - the whole nation holds its breath. At least Guardiola is being supportive instead of blaming the player. That's good leadership.
A
Arjun S.
City had 72% possession but couldn't score! This is why we Indians love cricket more - at least when you dominate, you usually win. Football can be so cruel despite playing better. 😅
N
Neha T.
Guardiola's graciousness in defeat is admirable. In India, we see too many coaches blaming referees or players after losses. His focus on performance rather than just results is something our coaches should learn from.
V
Vikram J.
Maybe if City had an Indian player like Gurpreet Singh Sandhu in goal, they would've saved that Eze strike! Jokes aside, Palace's defense was solid like our Indian team against Qatar last year. Sometimes underdogs deserve their moment.

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Your email won't be published


Disclaimer: Comments here reflect the author's views alone. Insulting or using offensive language against individuals, communities, religion, or the nation is illegal.

Tags: