Key Points

The National Crime Records Bureau's 2023 report has sparked a heated political debate after naming Kolkata the safest city in India. BJP has challenged the data, alleging under-reporting of crimes by West Bengal Police. Opposition leaders, including Priyanka Chaturvedi and Surendra Rajput, have strongly criticized the BJP's stance. The controversy highlights the ongoing political tensions between ruling and opposition parties regarding crime statistics and urban safety.

Key Points: BJP vs NCRB Kolkata Safety Report Sparks Political Clash

  • NCRB report confirms Kolkata as safest city for fourth consecutive year
  • BJP questions crime data reliability
  • Opposition accuses BJP of political maneuvering
  • Crime rate in Kolkata significantly lower than national average
2 min read

Oppn slams BJP for questioning NCRB data naming Kolkata safest city

Opposition challenges BJP's critique of NCRB data naming Kolkata as India's safest city amid political controversy

"If the BJP has doubts, they should raise questions to Amit Shah - Surendra Rajput, UP Congress Spokesperson"

New Delhi, Oct 5

As the BJP questioned the National Crime Records Bureau's (NCRB) 2023 report that named Kolkata the safest city in India, the Opposition on Sunday hit back, pointing out that the NCRB functions under the Union Home Ministry, which is headed by BJP leader Amit Shah, and accused the party of doubting its own government's data.

According to the NCRB, Kolkata has retained its position as the safest city for the fourth consecutive year. The city recorded 83.9 cognisable offences per lakh population in 2023 -- the lowest among 19 Indian cities with populations above 20 lakh.

The average crime rate across these cities was 828 per lakh. The data also indicated a steady decline in Kolkata's crime rate over the past two years -- from 103.5 in 2021 to 86.5 in 2022.

The BJP, however, rejected the findings, alleging that the West Bengal Police had under-reported crimes to project the state in a favourable light.

Reacting sharply to the BJP's claims, Shiv Sena(UBT) MP Priyanka Chaturvedi told IANS, "The problem with the BJP is that in the states where they are in power, they fail to ensure safety, especially for women. Limits have been crossed regarding women's security, whether in Madhya Pradesh, Uttar Pradesh or other states."

She said that the BJP-ruled states should adopt the same strategies as Bengal to curb the crime rate.

"Instead of appreciating West Bengal for being safe for women, they are raising questions about it. If the BJP governments follow the principles being followed in Bengal, then maybe their cities will also become safe for women. The parties should rise above politics in this matter," she added.

Uttar Pradesh Congress spokesperson Surendra Rajput also criticised the BJP.

Speaking to IANS, he said, "If the BJP has its doubts, they should raise these questions in front of the Home Ministry and ask Amit Shah about this. NCRB is part of Amit Shah's department. This means that the BJP leaders do not trust Amit Shah, and there is an internal rift in the BJP. The party is not happy with PM Modi's leadership."

- IANS

Share this article:

Reader Comments

R
Rohit P
The hypocrisy is astonishing! NCRB is under Home Ministry but BJP questions its own data? Either the data is wrong or their governance in other states is failing. Can't have it both ways.
D
David E
As someone who has lived in both Kolkata and Delhi, I can say Kolkata does feel safer, especially for women at night. The data seems to reflect ground reality. Maybe other cities should learn from Kolkata's policing model.
A
Anjali F
While I appreciate Kolkata's achievement, let's not make this political. Every city should strive to be safer. Instead of fighting over data, all parties should work together to improve women's safety nationwide. 🙏
M
Michael C
The Congress spokesperson makes a valid point - if BJP doubts the data, they should question their own Home Ministry. This internal contradiction shows political immaturity. Data should be accepted and improvements made where needed.
K
Karthik V
Fourth year in a row! That's impressive consistency. Kolkata police deserve credit for their community policing initiatives. Other states should indeed learn from Bengal's strategies rather than questioning verified data. 👍

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Minimum 50 characters 0/50