Key Points

Former Deputy NSA Pankaj Saran describes the current India-US relationship as part of a broader global disruption under Trump. He highlights how European allies also face uncertainty about NATO's future due to Trump's unpredictable approach. Saran advises a measured policy response, noting India initially enjoyed a honeymoon period with Trump before recent tensions. The diplomat emphasizes only Trump himself knows the next moves in this geopolitical chess game.

Key Points: Pankaj Saran Says Trump Unpredictability Impacts India-US Ties

  • Saran links India-US tensions to Trump's disruptive global strategy
  • Warns of similar unease in Europe over NATO's future
  • Stresses need for measured policy amid unpredictability
  • Notes initial honeymoon phase in ties turned sour after 7 months
4 min read

'Only Trump knows what's next...': Former Dy NSA Pankaj Saran says India-US strain part of global disruption

Former Deputy NSA Pankaj Saran warns India-US strain reflects global disruption under Trump's unpredictable foreign policy approach.

"There's only one man in the world who knows what's going to happen next, and that is President Trump. – Pankaj Saran"

New Delhi, August 15

India-US relations have entered a turbulent phase under President Donald Trump, with former Deputy National Security Adviser Pankaj Saran warning the strain should be viewed as part of a wider global disruption rather than an isolated setback.

In an interview with ANI, Saran offered a measured assessment of the bilateral relationship against the backdrop of shifting geopolitics and Trump's return to the forefront of American politics.

"There's only one man in the world who knows what's going to happen next, and that is President Trump. Not even his cabinet officials. They're also the last to know, as we are," Saran said.

When asked if the trajectory of the India-US relationship, which had seen consistent growth since George W. Bush's era, is facing a major speedbreaker under Trump, Saran replied, "I think so. I mean, I think so. But we're not the only ones," noting that Europe, too, is feeling the effect of a disrupted global order.

Recalling conversations with European scholars, Saran said that even before Trump's return, there was unease about the future of NATO and the transatlantic partnership.

"I have been visiting Europe and talking to a lot of European scholars, you know, before January, they were all extremely worried about what would be the consequence of a Trumpian foreign policy on the European alliance; they were even talking about the existence of the NATO alliance, the transatlantic alliance. They were even talking about that, it is time has come to maybe de-link ourselves from the United States. Instead of having a US-led NATO, to have a European-led NATO, they even talked about issues about a coalition of the willing, that since Europe is large and diverse, a few of them should get together and handle their own security. So the French, the Germans, the Italians, you know, they started asserting themselves. Recalibrating now," he said.

Saran stressed the importance of placing India's current challenges in a global context. "When we look at ourselves, it's better to look at what we are going through in a larger context. To understand why it is happening. The question is, are we the only ones, or is it part and parcel of a bigger disruption globally that we are going through? And I think we are going through a disruption," he said.

Highlighting the overall situation, he said, "To make a policy response, you have to understand who you're dealing with. And what is the overall situation? If you are making a policy response on the analysis that you're the only one getting hit and everyone else is fine, then there'll be a certain kind of policy response. But if you have figured that you're part and parcel of a bigger global disruption, then you will tweak and modify how you respond."

"So, yes, I think we are to be sure at a difficult moment in the relationship, something which we actually never expected," he added.

"You're dealing with a global power. You can't, you're not an equal, and you have to be realistic. Bravado and being rash and being kind of thumping your chest or the table is not going to help," he said, emphasising the need for a measured approach.

Saran noted that ties initially enjoyed a "honeymoon phase" in the early months of Trump's return to politics but have since soured. "It is now after eight months or seven months that he's turned his attention to us. And we lived through a fairly nice honeymoon phase for the first few months. But now we're getting into his crosshairs," he said.

Reiterating to the unpredictability of Trump's approach, Saran said, "There's only one man in the world who knows what's going to happen next, and that is President Trump. Not even his cabinet officials. They're also the last to know, as we are."

"If we give him the benefit of doubt, he's got it figured in his mind what he actually wants at a very broad macro level. He's looking at the world as a chessboard, as a deal-making platform. He's looking at each country, how it fits into his bigger design. It's quite amazing that the only person who knows the next step is him," he added.

- ANI

Share this article:

Reader Comments

S
Sarah B
As an American living in Delhi, I can see both perspectives. Trump's transactional approach is shaking up traditional alliances, but India has weathered many storms before. The relationship is bigger than any one president.
A
Ananya R
This is exactly why we need to strengthen ties with other nations too - Russia, Japan, EU countries. Putting all eggs in the US basket was never wise. Time for multi-alignment strategy!
V
Vikram M
Saran's analysis is spot on. The whole world is confused by Trump's moves. But we Indians are smart enough to navigate this - remember how we handled sanctions post Pokhran tests? Jai Hind!
K
Kavya N
While I appreciate Saran's balanced view, I wish our diplomats would be more vocal about protecting Indian interests. Why always this defensive posture? We're the world's fifth largest economy now!
M
Michael C
From what I've seen in international relations, India has shown remarkable patience and strategic thinking. The US-India relationship is too important to be derailed by temporary political winds.

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Minimum 50 characters 0/50