Key Points

The Karnataka BJP has strongly criticized Deputy Chief Minister DK Shivakumar for apologizing after singing the RSS anthem in the state assembly. BJP leader R Ashoka questioned whether Congress wants Indians to hail "the lady from Italy" rather than their motherland. Shivakumar clarified he sang the anthem only to tease the opposition leader and apologized if it hurt his party colleagues. The incident has sparked a heated political debate about patriotism and loyalty in Indian politics.

Key Points: BJP Slams Shivakumar Over RSS Anthem Apology as Italy Jibe

  • BJP questions patriotism after Shivakumar apologizes for RSS anthem
  • Asks if Congress prefers "lady from Italy" over motherland
  • Criticizes Congress for defending pro-Pakistan slogans
  • Demands to know who pressured Shivakumar to apologize
3 min read

'If not motherland, should Indians hail Italy's lady': K'taka BJP slams Dy CM Shivakumar over RSS anthem apology

Karnataka BJP attacks Deputy CM Shivakumar for apologizing after singing RSS anthem, asking if Indians should "hail the lady from Italy" instead of motherland.

"If not Mother India, then according to Congress, whom should Indians hail? The Mother of Italy? - R. Ashoka, BJP Leader"

Bengaluru, Aug 26

Criticising Deputy Chief Minister and Karnataka Congress President D.K. Shivakumar for apologising over singing the RSS anthem, the BJP, on Tuesday, chided that if not for the motherland, should Indians hail the lady from Italy (indirectly referring to Congress leader Sonia Gandhi).

Responding to Shivakumar's apology over singing the RSS anthem, the Leader of the Opposition and BJP leader R. Ashoka said, "If Deputy Chief Minister Shivakumar has to apologise for bowing to Mother India by reciting the RSS anthem 'Namaste Sada Vatsale Matrubhume' (Salutations to you, O ever-loving motherland) then according to the Congress, whom should Indians hail? The Mother of Italy? Or the lady who has come from Italy?"

"This is the essence of the first line of the RSS prayer song: 'Salutations to Mother India, who nurtures us all with affection like a mother'. Is it wrong to have this sentiment towards the motherland that gave us birth? Is it wrong to bow to one's motherland?" BJP leader Ashoka asked.

He also criticised the Congress-led state government, saying: "On the one hand, the Congress party defends those who shouted 'Pakistan Zindabad' inside the Vidhana Soudha in Bengaluru, and on the other hand, it places those who bow before Mother India in the position of an offender. Can this be called anything other than an anti-national mindset?"

"After all, who ordered D.K. Shivakumar to apologise? Was it Sonia Gandhi, Rahul Gandhi, K.C. Venugopal or Randeep Surjewala? Or did he apologise because B.K. Hariprasad demanded it?" BJP leader Ashoka asked.

"If Deputy CM Shivakumar had even a little bit of self-respect or courage, he should not have apologised. If there was such immense pressure to apologise, then without hesitation he should have resigned from the Congress party membership. There is a saying: 'He who loves not his country can love nothing,'" he said.

"But in the Congress party, the situation is such that if one has love for the chair, one must give up patriotism. It is the great misfortune of our land today that so-called leaders, who abandon their motherland for the greed of power, are aspiring to become Chief Ministers of the state," BJP leader Ashoka added.

Following criticism after singing the RSS anthem in the state Assembly and speculation about his proximity to the BJP, Deputy Chief Minister Shivakumar clarified on Tuesday that he would "die as a Congressman" and reaffirmed that his loyalty to the Gandhi family was akin to that of a devotee to god.

He also apologised for singing the RSS anthem in the Assembly.

Deputy Chief Minister Shivakumar said, "During the discussion on the stampede tragedy in the recently concluded Monsoon Assembly session, I sang a few lines of the RSS anthem to pull the leg of the Leader of the Opposition, R. Ashoka. That was my only intention. I did not mean it otherwise, nor was it to praise them."

"Anyone who wants to know about my history, commitment, and ideology is welcome. If they want to do politics, let them. But if any of my party colleagues or friends across political lines in the INDIA bloc have been hurt, I sincerely apologise to them," he added.

- IANS

Share this article:

Reader Comments

P
Priya S
This is just political drama. Shivakumar sang it to tease Ashoka, then apologized to keep his party happy. Both sides making mountain out of molehill 🤦‍♀️
A
Aditya G
The Italy reference was unnecessary. We can debate patriotism without bringing personal backgrounds into it. Let's focus on issues that actually matter to common people.
Nisha Z
As a Kannadiga, I'm tired of this constant political fighting. We need governance, not these daily controversies. Both parties should focus on development work please!
S
Siddharth J
The real question is why our politicians are so obsessed with symbolic gestures instead of actual work. We have real problems in Karnataka that need attention!
M
Michael C
Watching from abroad, this seems like much ado about nothing. Most democracies don't have these kinds of controversies over patriotic songs. Interesting cultural difference.

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Minimum 50 characters 0/50