Key Points

A comprehensive study involving over 10,000 participants found no strong evidence supporting alternative autism treatments. Researchers discovered that safety assessments were rarely conducted for therapies like acupuncture and music therapy. The team created an online platform to help people access evidence about different treatments. Despite widespread use among autistic individuals, most studies showed weak or unreliable results for these alternative approaches.

Key Points: Study Finds No Strong Evidence for Acupuncture Music Therapy Autism

  • Study assessed 248 meta-analyses and 200 clinical trials
  • Researchers found weak or poor-quality evidence for most treatments
  • Safety assessments were missing for majority of alternative therapies
  • Up to 90% of autistic individuals report using these treatments
  • Created online platform to share evidence on different CAIMs
2 min read

No strong evidence to show acupuncture, music therapy work for autism: Study

Major study of 10,000+ participants reveals weak evidence for alternative autism treatments like acupuncture and music therapy, with safety rarely assessed.

"It is necessary to carefully consider evidence from rigorous randomised trials before concluding that these treatments should be tried - Professor Richard Delorme"

New Delhi, Aug 28

There is no strong evidence to support the use of complementary and alternative treatments such as acupuncture and music therapy for autism, finds a study on Thursday.

Researchers from the Paris Nanterre University, Paris Cité University in France and the University of Southampton in the UK showed that the safety of these treatments was rarely assessed.

"Many parents of autistic children, as well as autistic adults, turn to complementary and alternative medicines hoping they may help without unwanted side effects," said Professor Richard Delorme, Head of the Child and Adolescent Psychiatry Unit at Robert Debré Hospital in Paris.

"However, it is necessary to carefully consider evidence from rigorous randomised trials before concluding that these treatments should be tried," Delorme added.

For the study, published in the journal Nature Human Behaviour, the team assessed 248 meta-analyses, including 200 clinical trials involving over 10,000 participants.

Researchers investigated the efficacy and safety of complementary, alternative, and integrative medicines (CAIMs) to treat autism.

They looked at 19 types of treatment, including animal-assisted interventions, acupuncture, herbal medicine, music therapy, probiotics, and Vitamin D.

The team also created an online platform to make it easier for people to see the evidence they generated on different CAIMS.

Autistic people can find it hard to communicate, understand how people think or feel, be overwhelmed by sensory information, become anxious in unfamiliar surroundings, and carry out repetitive behaviours.

All of this can interfere with their quality of life, and up to 90 per cent report having used CAIMs at least once in their lifetime.

While some treatments showed potential, most studies were supported by weak or poor-quality evidence, so the effects are not reliable. Concerningly, safety assessments were missing for most treatments, with less than half of CAIMs having had any evaluation of the acceptability, tolerability, or adverse events, the team said.

- IANS

Share this article:

Reader Comments

R
Rohit P
Finally some scientific clarity! In India, so many alternative therapy centers have mushroomed claiming miraculous results for autism. Parents are desperate and end up spending lakhs without proper evidence. We need more regulation in this space.
D
David E
While the evidence might be weak, we shouldn't completely dismiss these therapies. For many families, music therapy or animal-assisted interventions provide moments of joy and connection that conventional therapies might not. The quality of life aspect matters too.
A
Ananya R
The online platform mentioned is a great initiative! Indian parents often rely on WhatsApp forwards and anecdotal evidence. Having accessible, scientific information in regional languages would be so helpful for making informed decisions. 🙏
V
Vikram M
Safety assessments missing for most treatments is concerning. In our desperation to help our children, we might be exposing them to unknown risks. This study is a wake-up call for better research and regulation in alternative therapies.
S
Sarah B
As an autism therapist working in Delhi, I've seen families spend their life savings on unproven treatments. While some complementary approaches can be part of a holistic plan, they should never replace evidence-based interventions like ABA or speech therapy.

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Minimum 50 characters 0/50