Murshidabad violence: Suvendu Adhikari sees silver lining in Calcutta HC's observations on NIA probe

IANS April 18, 2025 275 views

The Calcutta High Court's recent observations have provided an interesting legal perspective on the Murshidabad violence investigation. Suvendu Adhikari, the Leader of Opposition, sees the court's remarks as a significant validation of the Central government's investigative powers. The court highlighted that the NIA can independently initiate investigations without state government clearance under specific legal provisions. Adhikari also expressed gratitude to the Governor and Red Cross for their support to affected communities.

"The Union Government has full discretion regarding deployment of Central Forces" - Suvendu Adhikari
Kolkata, April 18: Although a special division bench of the Calcutta High Court refrained from giving a direct order for National Investigation Agency (NIA) probe into Murshidabad violence, the Leader of Opposition in the Assembly, Suvendu Adhikari, has found a silver lining in the court’s observation.

Key Points

1

Calcutta HC highlights Centre's power to direct NIA investigations

2

NIA can probe suo motu under Section 6 of 2008 Act

3

Adhikari welcomes court's constitutional observations

4

Governor CV Ananda Bose supports relief efforts

According to the LoP, with the court clearly outlining the constitutional freedom of the Union government to decide about the NIA probe, the Centre is now free to take a call on the matter.

“I wholeheartedly welcome the observation of the Calcutta High Court regarding full discretion of the Union Government regarding deployment of Central Forces as well as the observation regarding the Union Government being already empowered to direct an NIA probe,” said Adhikari

More so, the Calcutta High Court’s observation is significant since, unlike the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI), which can take charge of a probe in any state matter only if directed by any court or cleared by any state government, NIA does not require a court direction or state government clearance for enering any investigation in any matter anywhere in India

NIA can make a suo motu entry into any investigation, and the Union Government can direct the agency to investigate a scheduled offence, even without prior report or request from a state government, if it deems it necessary. This power is granted under Section 6 of the NIA Act, 2008.

In fact, the special division bench of Justice Soumen Sen and Justice Raja Basu Chowdhury, in the order on Thursday, had exactly highlighted the authority of the Union government on this count.

“In any event, the Central government has a power under Section 6(5) to direct NIA investigation suo motu if the Central Government is of the opinion that the scheduled offences have been committed, which is required to be investigated under the NIA Act of 2008,” read the order copy.

Adhikari has also expressed gratitude to Governor C.V. Ananda Bose for the latter's earlier direction to the Red Cross Society to provide support to the affected people in the troubled pockets of Murshidabad.

“I also express my heartfelt regards to the Red Cross Bengal for their tireless and extensive relief work. Their compassion and swift action have brought hope and aid to those in need, who are affected by the recent crisis,” the LoP said.

Reader Comments

P
Priya M.
Finally some clarity on the NIA's role! The court's observations make it clear that the central government has constitutional authority to act when needed. Hope this brings justice to the affected families 🙏
R
Rahul K.
While I appreciate the legal analysis, I'm concerned this might become politicized. The NIA should investigate only if there's genuine national security concern, not just because of political pressure from opposition parties.
S
Sneha P.
The Red Cross deserves more appreciation for their work! While everyone debates legalities, they're actually on the ground helping people. More focus should be on relief efforts than political points.
A
Amit D.
Interesting legal perspective! Didn't know about Section 6(5) of NIA Act before. The court seems to have made a balanced observation without overstepping. Hope the violence stops soon though 😔
N
Neha T.
The article explains the legal position well, but I wish there was more context about what actually happened in Murshidabad. The violence details seem missing from this political/legal analysis piece.

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Your email won't be published


Disclaimer: Comments here reflect the author's views alone. Insulting or using offensive language against individuals, communities, religion, or the nation is illegal.

Tags:
Murshidabad Violence Suvendu Adhikari Calcutta High Court NIA Probe West Bengal Politics
You May Like!