Indian Woman, 73, Maltreated in US Detention: EAM Raises Strong Protest

External Affairs Minister S. Jaishankar has informed Parliament about the case of Harjit Kaur. The 73-year-old woman was maltreated while detained in the United States before her deportation. Jaishankar stated that while she was not handcuffed, her treatment was unacceptable. The Indian government has strongly taken up the matter with American authorities.

Key Points: EAM Jaishankar on Harjit Kaur's US Detention Maltreatment

  • EAM Jaishankar confirmed maltreatment of the elderly deportee in US custody
  • Harjit Kaur spent 60-70 hours in detention without a bed after knee surgeries
  • She was deported in September after 30 years living in the United States
  • India has strongly raised the issue of her treatment with the US Embassy
2 min read

Maltreated in detention; raised matter strongly with US embassy: EAM on deportation of 73-year-old Harjit Kaur

EAM Jaishankar confirms 73-year-old Harjit Kaur was maltreated in US detention before deportation, says India has raised the issue strongly with American authorities.

"While Harjit Kaur was not handcuffed, she was maltreated in detention before she was put on the flight. - EAM S. Jaishankar"

New Delhi, December 4

External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar on Thursday informed the Rajya Sabha that 73-year-old Indian citizen Harjit Kaur was maltreated while in US detention before being deported, and the Indian government has taken up the issue "strongly" with the American embassy following her arrival in the country.

Speaking during the question hour in the upper house, the EAM stated that immigration officials of the Indian government routinely interview all deportees upon arrival. In this case, Jaishankar said that the immigration officer clarified that Kaur had not been handcuffed, contrary to some claims.

However, he confirmed that she had been maltreated during her detention in the US before being put on the flight to India.

"Whenever any flight with deportees comes, the deportees are invariably interviewed by the officials of the Government of India. In this particular case, our immigration officer said that she was not cuffed," Jaishankar said.

"While Harjit Kaur (deportee) was not handcuffed, she was maltreated in detention before she was put on the flight. We raised the matter of her maltreatment strongly with the American Embassy and asked the American authorities to look into it," he added.

Harjit Kaur, a 73-year-old Sikh woman who had spent three decades in the United States, was deported by the US Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) to India in September.

Kaur, who had unsuccessfully applied for asylum in the US, was arrested by US Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) officials on September 8.

She moved to California in 1991 with her two young sons and lived and worked there while making several unsuccessful asylum attempts in the US.

She was moved to a holding facility in Georgia on September 19 and deported to India on September 22, never getting to visit her US home or bid a proper farewell to family and friends.

She spent 60-70 hours in detention without a bed, forced to sleep on the floor despite double knee replacements. She was given ice to take medication and denied food she could eat, with guards blaming her for her inability to eat the provided sandwich.

Harjit Kaur has filed multiple appeals, all the way up to the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, and has lost each time.

- ANI

Share this article:

Reader Comments

R
Rohit P
While the maltreatment is unacceptable, we must also be clear. She was there illegally for 30 years after multiple failed asylum attempts. The deportation process itself may be legal, but the way it was done is the issue. Our government is right to focus on the inhumane treatment during detention.
S
Sarah B
As someone who has lived in both countries, I'm appalled. ICE has a terrible reputation, but denying basic dignity to an elderly woman is a new low. Giving ice to take medicine? That's deliberate cruelty. Glad India is speaking up. Hope there is a proper investigation.
A
Aman W
The government's response is good, but it's reactive. We need a stronger, proactive system to protect our citizens abroad, especially the vulnerable. How many more Harjit Kaurs are there? Our embassies need more power and resources to intervene before things reach this stage.
K
Kavya N
Imagine building a life somewhere for 30 years, raising your kids, and then being treated like a criminal in your old age and sent away. The emotional trauma must be immense. Her sons are still there? This family has been torn apart. So sad.
D
David E
Respectfully, I think the government's statement tries to have it both ways. They clarify she wasn't handcuffed (contradicting some reports) but confirm maltreatment. It feels like they are managing the narrative. The focus should solely be on ensuring justice and apology for the lady, not on scoring diplomatic points.

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Minimum 50 characters 0/50