Key Points

Geopolitical expert David Goldwyn believes President Trump miscalculated by using oil sanctions as leverage against India. He calls the policy "deeply hypocritical" since the US has delayed similar tariffs on China. Goldwyn explains Trump operates based on perceived leverage, applying maximum pressure where he thinks he has advantage. The expert concludes that while Trump wants a deal with China, negotiations have stalled due to miscalculations.

Key Points: David Goldwyn Says Trump Miscalculated India Oil Sanctions Leverage

  • Trump underestimated India's resilience to oil sanctions as a pressure tool
  • Goldwyn calls US policy hypocritical for targeting India but not China
  • Trump delayed China tariffs fearing he had less leverage with Beijing
  • Expert says Trump believes he can cut a deal with China but negotiations stalled
3 min read

He is learning, oil not a tool of leverage, India not vulnerable, Geopolitical expert David Goldwyn on Trump's India tariff strategy

Geopolitical expert David Goldwyn analyzes Trump's tariff strategy, calling sanctions on India "deeply hypocritical" while US delays China tariffs.

"What he's learning... is that this oil weapon was not quite the tool of leverage that he thought it was. - David Goldwyn"

Washington, DC September 10

David Goldwyn, leading Geopolitical expert believes US President Trump miscalculated by assuming sanctions could serve as a pressure tool against India.

"What he's learning in this fiasco, really, in terms of diplomatic relations with India, is that this oil weapon was not quite the tool of leverage that he thought it was. India is not as vulnerable... He underestimated the potency of that weapon and really misread Indian history," he said in an interview to ANI.

Goldwyn's comments come amidst what appears to be a thaw in the tug of war over tariffs imposed on India. On Tuesday President Trump expressed confidence in reaching a "successful conclusion" and looked forward to speaking with PM Modi in the upcoming weeks.

"I am pleased to announce that India and the United States of America are continuing negotiations to address the Trade Barriers between our two Nations. I look forward to speaking with my very good friend, Prime Minister Modi, in the upcoming weeks. I feel certain that there will be no difficulty in coming to a successful conclusion for both of our Great Countries!" Trump stated in a post on Truth Social.

The top global energy and geopolitical expert however called out the Trump administration's double standards over tariffs on India and described Washington's sanctions on India over Russian oil imports as a "deeply hypocritical policy."

Goldwyn said, "It is a deeply hypocritical policy. So there's no question about that."

The Trump administration imposed a steep 50 per cent tariff on Indian goods, 25 per cent applied earlier this month, and an additional 25 per cent from August 27 as secondary sanctions, in response to New Delhi's continued purchase of Russian oil. On the other hand, Washington has suspended tariffs on China until November.

When asked why the US hasn't slapped China with a similar sort of secondary sanctions, Goldwyn said Trump believed he had greater bargaining leverage with India than with China.

"The President had a lot of leverage, and he believes he has leverage over India, but he realises he doesn't have a lot of leverage with China. That's why tariffs have been delayed, negotiations extended, and he has not enforced sanctions or tariffs for Chinese imports of Russian crude," Goldwyn said.

Goldwyn further mentioned that Trump avoided sanctioning Chinese ports and ships for fear of upsetting potential trade talks with Beijing. "This is a question of the president's perception of leverage. And the more leverage he thinks he has, the harder a bargain he drives."

Furthermore, when asked if Trump thinks he can force Chinese President Xi Jinping to make a deal with the United States, Goldwyn denied that possibility but mentioned that Trump wants the deal.

"I don't think that he believes that he can coerce Xi Jinping into a deal, but he does believe that there is a deal to be had. He thinks China could make energy purchases or give up some transactions, and that he can cut a deal. But it hasn't gone very well, which is why everything has been delayed," he said.

- ANI

Share this article:

Reader Comments

P
Priya S
The hypocrisy is astounding! Suspending tariffs for China while punishing India? Shows where the real power dynamics lie. Good that experts are calling this out.
A
Aditya G
Trump thought he could treat India like some small nation. Big mistake! Our foreign policy has always been about strategic autonomy. Never underestimate Indian diplomacy.
S
Sarah B
As an American living in India, I can see both perspectives. But the double standard is hard to defend. India has every right to secure affordable energy for its growing economy.
K
Karthik V
This is why we need strong leadership. PM Modi handled this perfectly - didn't bow down to pressure but kept communication channels open. That's how you deal with superpowers!
M
Michael C
While I support standing up for our interests, we should also be careful not to damage the long-term US-India relationship. Both countries need each other in the larger geopolitical context.
N
Nisha Z
Exactly! India has survived sanctions before and emerged stronger. 1998 nuclear tests taught the world that pressure tactics don't work on us. We make decisions based on our national interest, period.

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Minimum 50 characters 0/50