Kolkata's Air Crisis: Why Pollution Surpassed Delhi for a Week

For seven straight days, Kolkata's air pollution has been worse than Delhi's, hitting alarming new highs. Environmentalists say the city's seven automatic air quality stations are poorly placed and don't reflect the reality in crowded neighborhoods. They are demanding a network of at least 20 stations in dense areas like Moulali and Shyambazar to get real-time data. Health warnings are escalating, with calls for immediate government action to protect outdoor workers, children, and the elderly from severe respiratory risks.

Key Points: Kolkata Air Pollution Worse Than Delhi for Seven Days

  • Kolkata's AQI hit a hazardous 439, surpassing Delhi's peak of 345 on Dec 11
  • Experts call for 20 automatic monitoring stations, not just 7 in eco-sensitive zones
  • Pollution spiked to an all-time high with PM2.5 levels at 188, triple the safe limit
  • The West Bengal Science Forum urges immediate health guidelines for vulnerable groups
3 min read

Kolkata air worse than Delhi for a week, experts seek more monitoring stations in crowded zones

Kolkata's air quality has been worse than Delhi's for a week, hitting hazardous levels. Experts demand more monitoring stations in crowded areas for accurate data.

"The air pollution situation in the city is extremely critical. - Sourav Chakraborty, West Bengal Science Forum"

Kolkata, Dec 16

After Kolkata's air pollution level surged past that of Delhi for the past seven days in a row, environmentalists have called for a wider network of automatic air quality monitoring stations in the densely populated and traffic-heavy areas to capture a more accurate picture of the city's air quality.

Green technologist and environmentalist Somendra Mohan Ghosh said that Kolkata needed at least 20 automatic air quality monitoring stations across the metropolitan area to obtain reliable, real-time data.

"The seven automatic air quality monitoring stations that we have here were not set up in proper places. We need such stations in densely populated areas and highly congested places such as Moulali and Shyambazar. In the absence of automatic stations, manual machines are used to get data from these areas. But we need automatic stations so that real-time data is received. This will give us the real picture of the city's air quality," Ghosh said.

According to him, most of the existing automatic stations are located in the eco-sensitive zones, which often fail to reflect the actual air quality experienced by residents in crowded areas.

Kolkata recorded higher pollution levels than Delhi between December 6 and December 11. On December 11, at 6.04 p.m., the city's Air Quality Index touched a hazardous 439, while Delhi's highest AQI that day was 345 at midnight.

During the 24 hours from midnight on December 10 to midnight on December 11, Kolkata's lowest AQI was recorded at 3.04 p.m. at 207. Delhi logged its lowest AQI of the day at 4.04 p.m., at 169, which was lower than Kolkata's. However, after 11 p.m. on December 11, Kolkata's AQI shot up sharply, reaching 558. The PM10 levels stood at 239 units against a permissible limit of 100 units, while PM2.5 levels were recorded at 188 units, well above the permissible limit of 60 units. This is believed to be an all-time high for air pollution in the city.

In response to the worsening situation, Paschimbanga Vigyan Mancha, also known as the West Bengal Science Forum, expressed concern and appealed to the State Pollution Control Board and the departments of Health, Labour, and Child Welfare to take immediate steps to curb pollution.

"We have observed that the level of air pollution in Kolkata has reached an alarming state, which is extremely harmful to health. In this situation, the West Bengal Science Forum demands that the State Pollution Control Board immediately issue necessary guidelines for the public. The Pollution Control Board and Health Department should develop necessary joint measures regarding public health. The Labour Department should take necessary steps concerning working people who work outdoors. The government should give utmost importance to the health of children, adolescents, women, and the elderly," the forum said in a statement.

The organisation's general secretary, Sourav Chakraborty, warned of serious health issues if swift action was not taken.

"The air pollution situation in the city is extremely critical. Ordinary people who are going out for work will face various kinds of health problems, especially lung problems and breathing difficulties. We demand immediate action in the public interest, so that we do not see a situation here like the one in Delhi's hospitals," he said.

- IANS

Share this article:

Reader Comments

R
Rohit P
The expert is absolutely right. Only 7 stations, and not even in the most crowded areas? How can we trust the data then? We need proper monitoring in places like Burrabazar and Esplanade to know the real picture.
A
Aman W
Living near Shyambazar, I can confirm the air feels thick and heavy, especially in the evening. Constant coughing and itchy eyes have become normal for my family. More monitoring is good, but we need concrete action on old vehicles and construction dust.
S
Sarah B
While the call for more stations is valid, I respectfully think it's putting the cart before the horse. We already know the air is toxic. The focus and funding should first be on mitigation—better public transport, regulating industries, and green zones. Data alone won't clean the air.
V
Vikram M
AQI of 558? That's terrifying. The authorities need to implement the Graded Response Action Plan like Delhi does during severe pollution. Where are the restrictions on polluting activities? We can't just wait and watch.
K
Kavya N
It's not just Kolkata; many of our metros are choking. But this news is a shocker. The Labour Department must step up for outdoor workers—rickshaw pullers, street vendors, traffic police. They need protective gear as an immediate measure.

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Minimum 50 characters 0/50