Key Points

Aakash Chopra suggests Yashasvi Jaiswal has a slight edge over Shubman Gill for India's Asia Cup squad due to his T20 prowess. The selection committee faces a tough call with a settled opening pair already in place. Chopra questions Gill's bench role given his leadership stature in other formats. The debate highlights India's batting depth ahead of the tournament.

Key Points: Chopra Backs Jaiswal Over Gill for India Asia Cup Squad Spot

  • Chopra highlights Jaiswal's T20 adaptability over Gill
  • Selectors face dilemma with settled opening pair of Abhishek and Samson
  • Gill's bench role could disrupt team balance
  • Jaiswal's left-handed batting adds variety to India's lineup
3 min read

Jaiswal slightly ahead of Gill for spot in India's Asia Cup squad, says Chopra

Aakash Chopra believes Yashasvi Jaiswal edges Shubman Gill for India's Asia Cup squad due to T20 suitability and team dynamics.

"As per T20 figures, Yashasvi is little ahead of Shubman. The way he plays T20 and the DNA of the team, he also marries that style. – Aakash Chopra"

New Delhi, Aug 16

Former India opener Aakash Chopra believes Yashasvi Jaiswal has a slight edge over Shubman Gill in the race for a place in India’s squad for the upcoming Asia Cup, citing the left-handed batter’s game being suited more towards T20 game.

The Ajit Agarkar-led selection committee are most likely to meet on August 19 to pick India’s squad for the Asia Cup, to be held from September 9-28 in the UAE. Both Gill and Jaiswal last played a T20I more than a year ago, with Abhishek Sharma and Sanju Samson becoming the first-choice opening pair.

“It is important that you keep an opener with you because, while counting the previous 15-member squad, there was no third opener in the Indian team. We never thought that if Abhishek Sharma and Sanju Samson would lose their form, then who would open. But then, you have to keep a third opener for the World Cup.”

“As per T20 figures, Yashasvi is little ahead of Shubman. The way he plays T20 and the DNA of the team, he also marries that style. Sometimes it also happens that if you pick Shubman as the third opener, who is your Test captain, the ODI vice-captain, now you have him on the bench in T20Is, that will not look very nice.”

“So the selectors will be thinking that if we are going to select Shubman, then we will have to give him a place in the eleven. Though picking Shubman is tempting, but I feel Yashasvi should be slightly ahead in this race,” said Chopra on his YouTube channel on Saturday.

It may not be easy for the selectors to leave out either Gill or Jaiswal, but accommodating them in the squad from the outside looks equally challenging. With a settled opening pair of Abhishek and Sanju, followed by Tilak Varma, Suryakumar Yadav, Rinku Singh and Hardik Pandya, India’s batting line-up already looks formidable with proven performers.

While there could be a possibility of including one of them, the question is at whose expense. “But if that third opener is Shubman, do you want him to sit on the bench? If you don't make him sit and play in the eleven, who will he come in for? If that player's name is Sanju Samson, who will keep wickets?”

“That is the problem because we don't see Sanju Samson playing in the middle order. You would want him at the top of the order. Tilak and Surya will play at number three and four. So, Sanju at fifth? That won't be a good story. If you want someone at fifth, then you will have to think about Jitesh Sharma because he has done very well in the IPL,” added Chopra.

- IANS

Share this article:

Reader Comments

S
Sarah B
As a neutral observer, I find this debate fascinating. Jaiswal's strike rate in recent IPL was phenomenal (187!) while Gill anchors innings better. Tough choice for selectors indeed.
A
Ananya R
Why not both? We need bench strength for World Cup. Jaiswal can be the X-factor player while Gill provides stability. Drop one of the all-rounders instead! 🤔
V
Vikram M
Selectors are overcomplicating this. Gill has proven himself in pressure situations - remember his century against Australia? Jaiswal needs more time to mature. #GillForAsiaCup
K
Kavya N
Left-right combination matters in T20s! Jaiswal being left-handed gives him edge over Gill. Our top order needs this variety. Hope selectors see this angle too 👏
N
Nikhil C
Respectfully disagree with Chopra here. Gill's technique is superior and he's more adaptable to different conditions. UAE pitches might favor his style more than Jaiswal's aggressive approach.

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Minimum 50 characters 0/50