Key Points

Jaishankar explains how India's security struggles differ from Europe's historically stable environment. He emphasizes the constant threats from Pakistan and China, forcing India to prioritize defense. Europe, he notes, is only now realizing the importance of security amid global shifts. The interview highlights India's long-standing geopolitical realism compared to the West's recent awakening.

Key Points: Jaishankar Says India Faced Nasty World While Europe Was Insulated

  • Jaishankar contrasts India's security challenges with Europe's post-WWII stability
  • Highlights terrorism threats from Pakistan and border tensions with China
  • Explains why India prioritizes security over economic cooperation
  • Notes Europe's current "reality check" on security concerns
3 min read

India dealt with nasty world, which Europeans were insulated from, EAM says

EAM Jaishankar highlights India's security struggles with Pakistan and China, contrasting Europe's historical geopolitical advantages.

"I’ve had to deal with a very harsh world, a very nasty world, which Europeans were insulated from. – S Jaishankar"

Amsterdam, May 22

External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar said that India has had difficult neighbours, which the West has always been insulated from.

In an interview with Netherlands-based NOS, Jaishankar said that the Europe has now woken up to the reality which India had been facing for almost eight decades.

"I've had difficult neighbors, Pakistan and China especially. I've had a continuing problem of terrorism from Pakistan. So I've always had to deal with a degree of realism with a very harsh world, a very nasty world, which I think Europeans were insulated from," he said.

Jaishankar was asked if India puts aside conflicts with its neighbours- China and Pakistan, the three can get rich together. The interviewer then asked to what extent does the situation on the border with Pakistan and China holds India back economically.

"Well, you know, it's a very interesting question which you are asking me as a European. I'll tell you why I find it interesting. Because I think this part of the world is waking up to what it means if you're not given full attention to your security requirements," Jaishankar said.

Jaishankar added that India's security challenges were far more threatening than the case was in Europe. So India had to prioritise security over economic cooperation.

"Our security challenges were far more threatening than yours. So we had to prioritize security. You don't choose between security and economic prosperity. Today you are realizing that. They are part of the same coin," he said.

The interviewer interrupted the EAM, saying, "So my question is naive?"

Jaishankar calmly answered, "So I'm not accusing you of naivety. I'm just saying that your situation was different from mine," he said.

Jaishankar explained how Europe enjoyed a favourable geopolitical situation post Second World War and in the 90s. That led them to think that it was 'normal'.

"No, I think your question comes out of your historical experience. Your historical experience has been that after the Second World War and certainly after 1991-92, you had the good fortune of enjoying a very favorable geopolitical circumstance. And that has conditioned you to think that is a normal. My situation is- I didn't have that situation," he said.

Jaishankar said that today, however, Europe is going through a 'reality check'. He added that one cannot choose between economy and security of a nation.

"But you are today going through a reality check in your own way. I've grown up with that reality over almost eight decades. So for me, it's not a choice between, oh, if you are dealing with your security, does it come at the cost of your progress? I mean, defending your country and your territory is the first duty of any government, any people," he said.

In response to the Pahalgam attack, Indian Armed Forces launched Operation Sindoor in the early hours of May 7, targeting nine terror sites in Pakistan and Pakistan-occupied Jammu and Kashmir (PoJK), leading to the death of over 100 terrorists affiliated with terror outfits like the Jaish-e-Mohammed (JeM), Lashkar-e-Taiba (LeT) and Hizbul Mujahideen (HM).

Following the attack, Pakistan retaliated with cross-border shelling across the Line of Control and Jammu and Kashmir as well as attempted drone attacks along the border regions, following which India launched a coordinated attack and damaged radar infrastructure, communication centres and airfields across airbases in Pakistan. On May 10, India and Pakistan reached an understanding on the cessation of hostilities.

- ANI

Share this article:

Reader Comments

R
Rajesh K.
Dr. Jaishankar has perfectly articulated what every Indian knows deep down - we've been dealing with hostile neighbors since independence while Europe enjoyed peace dividends. The West never understood our security concerns until Ukraine happened. Now they know! 🇮🇳
P
Priya M.
While I agree with EAM's points, I wish our diplomacy could find more creative solutions. Constant tensions with neighbors do take a toll on regional trade potential. Maybe we need Track II diplomacy alongside strong security measures?
A
Amit S.
China's expansionism and Pakistan's terrorism factory - two sides of the same coin threatening India. Europe had NATO protection while we had to fend for ourselves. Operation Sindoor shows we won't take it lying down anymore. Jai Hind!
S
Sunita R.
The interviewer's question shows how privileged Europe has been! They think economic cooperation is simple when you have neighbors constantly stabbing you in the back. Security first, then business - that's the Indian way.
V
Vikram J.
Jaishankar sahab handled this with such class! No aggression, just facts. Europe is finally understanding what we've faced for 75+ years. Maybe now they'll stop lecturing us about peace when they're buying Russian oil through back channels 😏
N
Neha T.
The article mentions Operation Sindoor but not enough about our brave soldiers! While diplomacy is important, we must never forget the human cost of protecting our borders. Salute to our armed forces 🫡

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Minimum 50 characters 0/50