Key Points

Florida Governor Ron DeSantis has launched a fierce attack on the H-1B visa program during a Fox News interview. He labeled the program a "total scam" that allows companies to game the system and replace American workers. DeSantis specifically highlighted that most H-1B workers come from India, creating what he called a "cottage industry." His comments come amid a broader debate within the Trump administration about potential reforms to US immigration programs.

Key Points: DeSantis Slams H-1B Visa Program as Total Scam Hurting US Workers

  • DeSantis claims companies train Americans then lay them off for H-1B workers
  • Argues the program is dominated by workers from one country, India
  • Questions importing foreign labor with rising AI job displacement
  • Disputes the notion that H-1B attracts the world's best talent
3 min read

H-1B program is a scam: Florida Governor Ron DeSantis

Florida Governor Ron DeSantis calls the H-1B visa a "total scam," arguing it replaces American workers with cheaper foreign labor, primarily from India.

"I think you're right to say the H-1B, it's become a total scam. These companies game the system. - Ron DeSantis"

Washington, DC, August 27

Florida's Governor Ron DeSantis slammed the H-1B visa program, calling it a "total scam" and arguing that it allows companies to replace American workers with foreign labour.

During an interview on Fox News on Wednesday (local time), he claimed that companies often train American workers alongside H-1B visa holders, only to lay off the Americans and hire the foreign workers. DeSantis added that this practice is unacceptable and hurts American workers.

When asked by Anchor Laura Ingraham on the divide in the Trump cabinet over the issue of H-1B visas, DeSantis responded, "I think you're right to say the H-1B, it's become a total scam. These companies game the system. Some of these companies are laying off large numbers of Americans while also hiring new H-1 B workers and renewing existing H-1 B visas. Often, people used to say, 'We're getting the cream of the crop from all around the world.' The reality is that's not actually what H1Bs are. "

DeSantis disputed the notion that the H-1B program attracts the "best and brightest" talent, suggesting instead that it has become a system that benefits a specific industry, largely dominated by workers from one country.

"Most of them (H-1Bs) are from one country, India, there's a cottage industry about how all those people make money off this system."

With artificial intelligence increasingly displacing young workers, DeSantis questioned why the US should import more foreign labour instead of prioritising its own citizens.

DeSantis told Fox News, "...Why would we be importing foreign workers when we have our own people that we need to take care of?"

https://x.com/IngrahamAngle/status/1960494331237949913

Remarks by DeSantis renewed attention towards the H-1B Visa debate.

Earlier, United States Secretary of Commerce Howard Lutnick stated that the US intends to modify the current immigration system, specifically the H-1 B visa program and green cards, according to local media reports.

According to Lutnick, the Trump administration plans to introduce a "gold card" program, which would allow wealthy foreigners to invest $5 million in exchange for U.S. residency.

"I'm involved in changing the H1B visa program. We're going to change that program because that's terrible, right? We're going to change the green card," Lutnick said during an Interview with Fox News.

The proposed Gold Card would offer permanent residency to foreigners who invest USD 5 million in the United States. Lutnick claims there is strong interest in the program, with 250,000 people supposedly waiting in line, and potentially generating USD 1.25 trillion in revenue.

In January 2025, Trump reaffirmed his stance to support the H-1B visa program, which allows employers in the US to hire non-immigrant workers for speciality occupations, stating that the country needs "competent" and "great" individuals to come to the US and that this can be achieved through the H-1B visa program.

Notably, during Trump's first term, the administration imposed restrictions on H-1B visas, citing concerns over "abuse" and "economic strain." In 2016, Trump condemned the program, describing it as a means for companies to replace American workers with lower-paid foreign employees.

- ANI

Share this article:

Reader Comments

P
Priya S
This is such a one-sided view. H-1B workers aren't taking jobs - we're filling critical gaps in tech, healthcare, and engineering that American companies struggle to fill locally. The program needs reform, not cancellation.
M
Michael C
While I understand protecting American jobs, the reality is that Indian tech talent has been instrumental in America's tech dominance. Many Silicon Valley companies wouldn't be where they are without H-1B contributions.
S
Siddharth J
The "gold card" proposal is even worse - basically selling residency to the highest bidder while skilled professionals who actually contribute to the economy face uncertainty. This seems more about politics than practical solutions.
A
Anjali F
As an Indian who studied in the US and returned home, I can say the system does need some fixes. But calling it a "scam" ignores how many Indian professionals have helped American companies innovate and grow globally.
D
David E
I work with many H-1B colleagues from India, and they're some of the hardest working, most talented people I know. The program isn't perfect, but blanket statements like DeSantis's don't help solve actual issues.

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Minimum 50 characters 0/50