Key Points

Former diplomat Mahesh Sachdev has sharply criticized the US administration's sudden decision to raise H-1B visa fees to $100,000. He compared the rushed implementation and subsequent partial rollback to trying to put toothpaste back in the tube. Sachdev believes American employers likely pushed back against the initial order, forcing the administration to limit its scope to new applicants only. He emphasized that the core problem remains as the move continues to hamper the free flow of Indian technical professionals that US companies need.

Key Points: Former Diplomat Slams Rushed H-1B Fee Hike as Toothpaste Back in Tube

  • US employers pushed back against the sudden $100k H-1B fee hike
  • The order was rushed with less than 24 hours notice for stakeholders
  • The fee now applies only to new applicants, not existing visa holders
  • The move is seen as targeting the MAGA base's perception of job loss
  • Sachdev says US IT unemployment is due to rapid tech changes, not immigrants
  • American companies need foreign experts to pursue innovation without delays
3 min read

H-1B fee hike order rushed, now being rolled back like 'toothpaste back in the tube': Former diplomat Sachdev

Ex-diplomat Mahesh Sachdev criticizes the rushed US H-1B visa fee increase to $100,000, calling it a poorly executed move that hampers the flow of Indian tech talent.

"After having suddenly escalated this issue... they are trying to put toothpaste back in the tube - Mahesh Sachdev"

New Delhi, September 21

Former senior diplomat Mahesh Sachdev criticised the US administration's sudden decision to raise the H-1B visa sponsorship fee to USD 100,000, saying the move was rushed and continues to hamper the free flow of Indian professionals despite partial modifications.

"After having suddenly escalated this issue, giving less than 24 hours practically speaking, over the weekend notice for stakeholders affected by this drastic move, they are trying to put toothpaste back in the tube," Sachdev said.

He added that American employers of H-1B personnel likely pushed back against the initial order, forcing the administration to limit its scope. "The American employers of H1B personnel would have strongly demonstrated to the administration, leading them to circumscribe the order by saying that it will apply only to the new entrants and would apply only once. So I believe it does put an outer bracket on the situation," he noted.

At the same time, Sachdev stressed that the core problem created by the original order remains unresolved. "It will hamper the free flow of personnel, most of them technically qualified from India, who are going to the United States because the United States needs them, but the United States want to have its own way, and the current administration seems to be very focused on the MAGA base, which believes that it has lost out on services," he said.

According to him, this perception is only partly accurate. "Far too many foreigners are coming and replacing United States workers, leading to unemployment in the United States IT industry. It's actually factually only partially correct. The United States IT industry has about 6 % unemployment among the US citizens, as compared to around 3 % for the general public of the United States," Sachdev explained.

He attributed much of the problem to rapid technological changes. "This is mainly because the IT industry is evolving very rapidly. And people with obsolete skills are no longer needed. They have to uh rewire themselves, acquire new knowledge, and this is what hampers unemployment," he said.

Sachdev emphasised that American companies require flexibility to innovate. "The companies won't like to wait; they would like to pursue their goal of innovation, and for that, if they need foreign experts, it's a double whammy. Either you train the locals and wait till they acquire the skills, or you get the skills from wherever they are available," he stated.

Against this backdrop, the United States has introduced a one-time fee of USD 100,000 for new H-1B visa applications, in a measure designed to further restrict the entry of foreign skilled workers.

The announcement, which took effect on September 21, initially triggered alarm among Indian professionals in the US, with several immigration lawyers and firms cautioning that H-1B holders and their families outside the country should return within 24 hours to avoid being stranded.

However, the White House later clarified that the new fee would apply only to fresh applicants and not to existing visa holders, offering relief to current beneficiaries of the programme.

- ANI

Share this article:

Reader Comments

P
Priya S
Sachdev is absolutely right about the "toothpaste back in the tube" analogy. The initial panic caused so much stress for Indian families settled there. At least they clarified it's only for new applicants, but the damage to trust is already done.
M
Michael C
As someone who works with Indian tech teams, this policy confusion hurts both sides. American companies need specialized talent that isn't always available locally. The real issue is skills gap, not immigration.
A
Ananya R
$100,000 fee is outrageous! This feels like discrimination against Indian professionals who have helped build Silicon Valley. Maybe it's time for India to focus on retaining our best talent instead of sending them abroad.
S
Sarah B
While I understand the need to protect American jobs, the approach seems poorly planned. Giving only 24 hours notice for such a major change shows lack of consideration for people's lives and careers. There has to be a better way.
V
Vikram M
The timing couldn't be worse with so many Indian students starting their academic year in US. This creates unnecessary anxiety. Hope both governments can work on more stable immigration policies that benefit both countries.

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Minimum 50 characters 0/50