Key Points

West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee has sharply criticized the central government over the recent GST reforms. She stated that the financial relief from the revised tax rates is coming entirely from state governments' coffers. Banerjee expressed concern about how she will run the state after an alleged loss of Rs 20,000 crore. Despite her criticism of the funding mechanism, she acknowledged that the people will ultimately benefit from the lower prices.

Key Points: Mamata Banerjee Says GST Relief Funded by States Not Centre

  • Mamata Banerjee claims she first demanded insurance be exempt from GST
  • She alleges a Rs 20,000 crore loss to West Bengal from the GST changes
  • TMC leader Kunal Ghosh credits Banerjee for forcing the Centre to revise anti-people rates
  • The new GST structure simplifies rates to 5% and 18% slabs for most goods
4 min read

GST relief will come from the coffers of state govts, Centre did not spend single penny: West Bengal CM Mamata Banerjee

West Bengal CM Mamata Banerjee criticizes the NDA government, stating the Centre took credit for GST rate cuts but states bore the entire financial cost.

"The central government has not spent a single penny on this relief; it has all come from the coffers of state governments. - Mamata Banerjee"

Kolkata, September 22

In the wake of the implementation of the revised Goods and Services Tax (GST) rates from today, West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee criticised the NDA government and said that all the relief will come from the coffers of state governments, and the Centre did not spend a single penny.

CM Mamata Banerjee addressed the inauguration of the 25 Pally Club Durga Puja pandal on Monday.

CM Mamata Banerjee said, "There is no credit to the central government. I was the first to write a letter demanding that insurance be exempt from GST. Many life-saving medicines and small items had GST. The central government has not spent a single penny on this relief; it has all come from the coffers of state governments. They take the credit, but we have borne the cost."

She expressed happiness that people will get benefits, but alleged that the money has been deducted from the state's GST share.

"Will they return our money? Funds for 100 days' work, for Awas Yojana, for roads, for Jal Swapno, for Sarva Shiksha Abhiyan: everything has been stalled. And now, again, a loss of Rs 20,000 crore has been inflicted. How will I run the state in such conditions? Still, I am happy that the people will benefit. But no compensation has been given; this money has simply been cut from our GST share. The so-called 'double engine government' will quietly take it back through back channels," she added.

Earlier, Trinamool Congress leader Kunal Ghosh on Sunday criticised the next GST reforms and credited CM Mamata Banerjee and the All India Trinamool Congress (AITC) for forcing the Centre to make changes in GST rates, which he termed earlier as "anti-people".

Addressing reporters, Ghosh said, "GST rates were actually anti-people...Because people use the product, there is more GST on it; there is more GST on health and life insurance. And when the rich and richest use the product, there is less GST," he said.

He asserted that Mamata Banerjee raised her voice against the GST structure. "Mamata Banerjee raised her voice, and then the entire nation rose up against it. The Centre was forced to change the GST rates. Now they are trying to take credit for this, but why did you introduce such rates in the first place?" Ghosh asked. Then he said, "Because your tariff was anti-people."

"The credit goes to Mamata Banerjee and AITC for pointing out the flaws and forcing them to bring these changes," he added.

The reform in the Goods and Services Tax structure, which was approved during the 56th meeting of the GST Council earlier this month, is set to come into effect from today. The current four-rate system will be replaced with a streamlined two-slab regime of 5% and 18%. A separate 40 per cent slab has been retained for luxury and sin goods.

This new framework is expected to ease compliance, reduce consumer prices, boost manufacturing, and support a wide range of industries, from agriculture to automobiles and from FMCG to renewable energy. It is intended to lower the cost of living, strengthen MSMEs, widen the tax base, and drive inclusive growth.

In the fast-moving consumer goods (FMCG) and dairy sector, major brands like Amul and Mother Dairy have announced substantial price cuts, reflecting the full benefit of the GST reduction.

Items like milk, butter, ghee, paneer, cheese, ice cream, snacks, and frozen foods have been brought under the 5 per cent slab, due to which 100 g of Amul butter will now cost Rs 58 instead of Rs 62, and Ultra High Temperature milk (UHT) has dropped to Rs 75 per litre from Rs 77. Mother Dairy has also slashed prices on milkshakes, paneer, ghee, and frozen products.

- ANI

Share this article:

Reader Comments

S
Sarah B
As someone who recently bought health insurance, I'm happy about the GST relief. But Mamata Banerjee raises valid concerns about how states will manage their finances if their share is being cut.
A
Arjun K
While I appreciate the GST simplification, the timing seems political. States are already struggling with delayed funds for central schemes. ₹20,000 crore is a huge amount for any state to lose! 🤔
P
Priya S
Saw Amul butter price reduced by ₹4 today! Common people are getting some relief finally. But Mamata ji has a point - if state development suffers, ultimately we citizens will pay the price in other ways.
M
Michael C
The GST Council decisions are taken collectively by both Centre and states. While states might face short-term revenue challenges, the simplified tax structure should boost economic activity in the long run. Let's wait and see.
N
Nisha Z
This is typical political blame game before elections. Yes, GST relief is good for common people, but why can't Centre and states work together instead of fighting over credit? 🤷‍♀️
K
Karthik V
As a small business owner, the simplified GST slabs are a blessing. Compliance was becoming a nightmare. But Mamata ji's concerns about state finances are genuine - hope the Centre addresses this properly.

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Minimum 50 characters 0/50