NewKerala.com

Key Points

Nasser Hussain questioned Shubman Gill’s leadership aura compared to Rohit Sharma and Virat Kohli after India’s Test defeat. England scripted a record 371-run chase despite India’s five centuries. Dropped catches and middle-order collapses cost India the match. The absence of a seam-bowling all-rounder in English conditions worsened India’s imbalance.

Key Points: Nasser Hussain Says Gill Lacks Rohit Kohli Aura in England Test

  • Hussain calls Gill reactive vs proactive like Rohit-Kohli
  • India lost despite five centuries due to batting collapses
  • England’s 371 chase highest vs India in Tests
  • Bumrah’s workload management adds to bowling woes
3 min read

Gill didn't quite have that on-field aura of Rohit and Kohli, says Nasser Hussain

Ex-England skipper critiques Shubman Gill's reactive captaincy in India's defeat, comparing him unfavorably to Rohit Sharma and Virat Kohli.

"He didn’t quite have that on-field aura of Rohit and Kohli – Nasser Hussain"

New Delhi, June 25

India’s new Test captain Shubman Gill is under the spotlight after his leadership in the series opener against England came under criticism from former England skipper Nasser Hussain, who said Gill “didn’t quite have the on-field aura” of his predecessors, Rohit Sharma and Virat Kohli.

“I saw someone finding his way,” Hussain said on Sky Sports. “He (Gill) didn’t quite have that on-field aura of Rohit and Kohli. I thought he followed the ball a lot and was reactive rather than proactive. When Rohit and Kohli captained, you looked down and immediately knew who was in charge. In this game, I saw two or three captains — captaincy by committee.”

Gill’s first Test as skipper ended in disappointment as India slumped to a five-wicket defeat at Headingley despite a dominant start and five individual centuries across both innings. England, fueled by Ben Duckett’s electrifying 149 and composed efforts from Joe Root (53 not out) and debutant Jamie Smith (44 not out), chased down 371 in the fourth innings — their second-highest successful run chase in Test history, and the highest ever against India.

While Hussain admitted that Gill’s captaincy lacked assertiveness, he also acknowledged that the 24-year-old wasn’t solely to blame. “India lost the match because of two things Gill couldn’t control — dropped catches and batting collapses,” he said, pointing to the team’s fielding woes and repeated middle-order meltdowns.

In a game where India had England at 276/5 in the first innings and later at 333/4 in the second, their inability to close out dominant positions proved fatal. The visitors lost seven wickets for 41 runs in the first innings and six for 31 in the second — collapses that turned the tide despite hundreds from Shubman Gill, KL Rahul, Yashasvi Jaiswal, Rishabh Pant, and Shubman Gill himself in his first innings as captain.

Former England pacer Stuart Broad echoed similar sentiments, saying India had “so many opportunities to put this game to bed” but let England fight back. “Duckett was absolutely outstanding. It’s just incredible how this team keeps doing this,” Broad said.

India’s bowling resources were also stretched. Jasprit Bumrah, who took a five-for in the first innings, is managing his workload and is expected to feature in only three of the five Tests due to a recent back injury.

The lack of a dependable seam-bowling all-rounder in English conditions added further imbalance — a problem Hussain highlighted, saying, “In India, they have spin-bowling all-rounders like Ashwin, Jadeja, Axar. But in England, they’re still searching for someone who can bat and bowl seam.”

- IANS

Share this article:

Reader Comments

Here are 6 diverse Indian perspective comments for the article:
R
Rajesh K.
Nasser Hussain is right about the aura part. Kohli's energy was unmatched and Rohit had that calm authority. But let's not judge Gill after just one match! Even Dhoni took time to grow into captaincy. Give the boy some breathing space 🇮🇳 #InGillWeTrust
P
Priya M.
The real issue isn't Gill's captaincy but our brittle middle order and poor fielding. How many catches did we drop? And that batting collapse was embarrassing! We can't expect a new captain to perform miracles when seniors keep failing under pressure.
A
Amit S.
Why are we always so harsh on our players? Gill scored a century in his first match as captain! England have been playing aggressive cricket for years now. One loss doesn't mean the end of the world. Let's support our team instead of criticizing non-stop.
S
Sanjay T.
The lack of a seam-bowling all-rounder is hurting us badly in England. We need to groom someone like Shardul Thakur properly instead of just using him as a stop-gap solution. Hardik's injury has left a huge void in overseas Tests.
N
Neha R.
I disagree with Hussain - leadership styles differ! Gill might be more low-key compared to Kohli's aggression, but that doesn't mean ineffective. Remember how people doubted Dhoni's calm approach initially? Let's judge after a full series, not one match.
V
Vikram J.
The bigger concern is Bumrah's workload management. We can't afford to lose him to injury again! Maybe we should consider playing him only in must-win matches. Without our pace spearhead, even the best captaincy won't help in England's conditions.

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Minimum 50 characters 0/50