Key Points

Former Indian Ambassador Mohan Kumar has challenged Trump's claim that India is the "tariff king" with high import duties. He reveals that India's actual trade-weighted tariff is only 4.6%, much lower than the simple average of 16% often cited. Kumar argues the US tariff war violates WTO agreements while acknowledging the organization has been ineffective. He emphasizes that India maintains agriculture tariffs to protect farmers, unlike Western nations that provide massive subsidies to their agricultural sectors.

Key Points: Former Ambassador Mohan Kumar Debunks Trump India Tariff King Claim

  • India's trade-weighted tariff is actually 4.6% not 16% average
  • US tariff war violates WTO commitments according to former ambassador
  • US exporters face lower tariffs in India than many Asian peers
  • India protects farmers with agriculture tariffs unlike subsidized Western farmers
2 min read

Former Indian Ambassador debunks 'India's tariff king' myth

Ex-Indian Ambassador counters Trump's "tariff king" allegation, reveals India's actual trade-weighted tariff is only 4.6% compared to US claims of highest rates.

"India was charging us tremendous tariffs, about the highest in the world - Donald Trump"

Washington, Sep 4

Former Indian Ambassador to France and Director General of Jadeja Motwani Institute for American Studies at OP Jindal Global University, Mohan Kumar, has countered the Trump administration's assertion that India is the "Maharaja of tariffs".

In an article in Newsweek magazine on Sunday, titled "Is India a 'Tariff King'? Not Really," Kumar, termed the perception of India's high tariff rates as "widespread but fallacious".

Kumar argued that "tariff war initiated by the US is in violation of its commitments under the World Trade Organisation (WTO) agreements", while acknowledging that the WTO has been "moribund for a while".

US President Donald Trump on Tuesday again pressed his allegation that India's tariffs on US exports are "about the highest in the world".

"India was charging us tremendous tariffs, about the highest in the world. They were about the highest in the world, number one. And we therefore weren't doing much business with India. But they were doing business with us because we weren't charging them foolishly," he added.

The former foreign service officer also attempted to debunk a common misconception about calculating tariffs.

He believed that trade-weighted tariffs is a more useful method as against simple average tariffs because "for most of the goods that come into the Indian market, it is the trade-weighted applied tariff that matters".

He highlighted that India's trade-weighted tariff is a "respectable 4.6 per cent", as compared to simple average tariffs of close to 16 per cent.

Kumar acknowledged that India maintains high tariffs in agriculture to protect its farmers, and the US demands to open India's farming sector would be "akin to asking it to commit suicide, which no elected government in India would agree to".

He asserted that these demands are "egregious" since Western farmers are beneficiaries of direct and indirect subsidies.

Kumar also noted that despite the narrative, US exporters face "equal or lower tariffs in India compared to many Asian peers".

He underscored electronics and technology sectors, where most imports have zero per cent tariffs, as compared to Vietnam's rate of 8.5 per cent and China's 5.4 to 20 per cent.

- IANS

Share this article:

Reader Comments

P
Priya S
Protecting our farmers is non-negotiable. American farmers get massive subsidies while expecting us to open our markets? That's just unfair trade practices. Ambassador Kumar is absolutely right!
M
Michael C
Interesting perspective. The comparison with Vietnam and China's tariffs on electronics is eye-opening. Maybe the US should focus on actual data rather than political rhetoric.
A
Ananya R
While I appreciate Ambassador Kumar's defense, we must also acknowledge that some sectors do have high tariffs that could be rationalized. Balanced approach is needed for global trade. 🤝
V
Vikram M
Trump's "Maharaja of tariffs" comment shows how little he understands about developing economies. We have to protect our domestic industries while gradually opening up. It's about strategic timing.
S
Sarah B
As someone working in tech exports to India, I can confirm that the tariffs are quite reasonable compared to other Asian markets. The narrative doesn't match the ground reality.

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Minimum 50 characters 0/50