Dhoni vs Sangakkara: Why Parthiv Patel Says Captain Cool Was "Above Everyone Else"

Parthiv Patel has settled the debate about who was the better wicketkeeper-captain between MS Dhoni and Kumar Sangakkara. The former cricketer believes Dhoni was in a league of his own despite playing under Sangakkara at Deccan Chargers. Patel pointed to Dhoni's legendary performance in the 2011 World Cup final as evidence of his superiority. He also weighed in on left-handed wicketkeepers, naming Adam Gilchrist as the complete package over both Pant and Sangakkara.

Key Points: Parthiv Patel Calls Dhoni Better Wicketkeeper-Captain Than Sangakkara

  • Parthiv played under Sangakkara at Deccan Chargers before making comparison
  • Dhoni's unbeaten 91 won India the 2011 World Cup final
  • Sangakkara didn't keep wickets throughout his entire career
  • Gilchrist chosen as best left-handed wicketkeeper batsman over Pant
2 min read

Dhoni as captain, wicketkeeper was above everyone else: Former cricketer Parthiv Patel

Former cricketer Parthiv Patel explains why MS Dhoni was superior to Kumar Sangakkara as wicketkeeper-captain, citing 2011 World Cup final and Deccan Chargers experience.

"There's no disrespect, but Dhoni as a captain, wicketkeeper was above everyone else - Parthiv Patel"

New Delhi, October 16

Former wicketkeeper batter Parthiv Patel believes there is no comparison between 'Captain Cool' MS Dhoni and former Sri Lanka maestro Kumar Sangakkara, as the legendary Indian was "above everyone else" as a wicketkeeper and captain.

Dhoni and Sangakkara, two contemporaries who relentlessly stayed in contention for the number one spot during their era, went head-to-head in the 2011 World Cup final at the Wankhede Stadium in Mumbai. The two captains left their impression with their usual mojo, but it was Dhoni's side that ended the night by lifting the World Cup title.

The flamboyant skipper had saved his best for the last, walloped an unbeaten 91 off 79 deliveries, struck the winning maximum to take India to glory and was adjudged the Player of the Match. While citing his experience of playing under Sangakkara at the Deccan Chargers (now defunct), Parthiv explained that Dhoni was in a league of his own.

"There is no comparison. Mahendra Singh Dhoni was a far better wicketkeeper captain than Sangakkara because I played with Sangakkara in the Deccan Chargers when he was the keeper-captain. It's not that he was bad. There's no disrespect, but Dhoni as a captain, wicketkeeper was above everyone else," Parthiv said on 'The Great Indian Cricket Show'.

Parthiv further delved into the debate of who would be a better left-handed wicketkeeper batsman among Adam Gilchrist, Rishabh Pant and Sangakkara. For Parthiv, the obvious choice was the destructive Australian wicketkeeper Gilchrist, a "complete package" during his playing days. The 40-year-old revealed the premise behind his selection and stated that Pant is a "work-in-progress", while Sangakkara didn't serve as a wicketkeeper throughout his career.

"Adam Gilchrist. Obviously, Sangakkara was a different player in style and grace. But he didn't play his entire career as a wicketkeeper batsman. Sometimes as a batsman, sometimes as a wicketkeeper. Rishabh Pant, I think, is still a work-in-progress as far as white-ball cricket is concerned. But I think Adam Gilchrist is the complete package in terms of white-ball and Test cricket," Parthiv added.

- ANI

Share this article:

Reader Comments

S
Sarah B
While I respect Parthiv's opinion, comparing Dhoni and Sangakkara feels unfair. Both were legends in their own right. Sangakkara's batting elegance was pure class! 🤔
P
Priya S
Dhoni's calmness under pressure was unmatched! Remember how he promoted himself up the order in that final? Pure genius decision making 💙
R
Rohit P
Gilchrist over Pant and Sangakkara for left-handed keepers? Hmm... Pant has already shown so much potential in Tests. Give the young man some time yaar! 🏏
M
Michael C
As someone who watched both Dhoni and Sangakkara throughout their careers, I think Parthiv's assessment is spot on. Dhoni's impact as captain-wicketkeeper was truly revolutionary.
A
Ananya R
Thala for a reason! 🦁 Dhoni's lightning-fast stumpings and cool captaincy made him the complete package. No wonder he's worshipped across India!

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Minimum 50 characters 0/50