Congress challenges judiciary's credibility when decisions are unfavourable: Assam CM on BJP MP's remarks

Guwahati, April 21: Amid a row over BJP MP Nishikant Dubey's remarks on the Supreme Court and the Chief Justice of India Sanjiv Khanna, Assam Chief Minister Himanta Biswa Sarma sought to discuss the mutliple occasions, where Congress has criticised members of the judiciary, accusing the opposition party of challenging judiciary's credibility when decisions are unfavourable.

"It's imperative for all political entities to approach judicial pronouncements with consistency and integrity. Respecting the judiciary shouldn't be contingent upon the favourability of its decisions. Selective approbation erodes public trust and the foundational principles of our democracy," Sarma posted on X.

He cited the impeachment motion against Justice Dipak Misra, which, the Assam CM said, was initiated by Congress and other opposition parties while alleging "misconduct without substantial evidence."

"Justice Ranjan Gogoi: Subjected to severe criticism following landmark judgments, including the Ayodhya verdict," Sarma posted on X, adding that Justice Arun Mishra was allegedly "targeted" for his decisions and alleged proximity to the executive.

Sarma said Justice Chandrachud, stating that he faced "undue scrutiny over his interpretations in significant cases, reflecting a pattern of disapproval when verdicts didn't align with certain political expectations."

Intensifying his attack against Congress for criticising Justice S Abdul Nazeer as he was appointed Andhra Pradesh Governor shortly after his retirement, Sarma pointed out that such appointments have been made in the past.

"Criticised by the Congress for his appointment as the Governor of Andhra Pradesh shortly after retirement, alleging it threatened judicial independence, despite similar appointments in the past," he added.

Meanwhile, Sarma defended the BJP, stating that the ruling party honours the judiciary's role "impartially" and distances itself from Nishikant Dubey's remarks.

"Adarniya Nadda Ji emphasised that these were personal opinions and not reflective of the party's stance, reiterating the BJP's deep respect for judicial institutions," he added.

This came as Congress raised the issue of remarks made by Dubey, the MP from Godda in Jharkhand at the Supreme Court, which has created huge controversy. He alleged that the apex court was "inciting religious wars" and questioned its authority, suggesting that the Parliament building should be closed if the judicial institution was to make laws.

"Chief Justice of India, Sanjiv Khanna, is responsible for all the civil wars happening in this country," Nishikant Dubey told ANI.

Referring to past court decisions, Dubey further criticised the judiciary for its handling of issues like the decriminalisation of homosexuality and religious disputes.

Reader Comments

R

Rahul K.

Interesting to see CM Sarma calling for consistency when his own party members make outrageous statements about the judiciary. Maybe he should start by addressing that first? 🤔

P

Priya M.

Finally someone said it! The hypocrisy of Congress is astounding. They praise courts only when verdicts go their way. This selective outrage damages our institutions.

A

Amit S.

While I agree with the CM's broader point about respecting judiciary, Dubey's comments were completely unacceptable. The BJP should take stronger action against such irresponsible statements.

S

Sunita R.

The judiciary must remain independent from both political parties. This back-and-forth blaming game helps nobody. Let's focus on real issues affecting common people!

V

Vikram J.

Sarma makes valid historical points, but I wish he'd shown the same energy when his party colleagues attack judges. Principle should matter more than party lines.

N

Neha P.

The MP's comments about CJI were shameful! 😠 Doesn't matter which party you support - we must respect our constitutional institutions. Hope the BJP takes disciplinary action soon.

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.