NewKerala.com

Calcutta HC Rejects Messi Probe Plea Amid Stadium Chaos and Vandalism

The Calcutta High Court has decided against ordering a central agency investigation into the chaotic events surrounding Lionel Messi's appearance in Kolkata. A division bench found no reason to doubt the impartiality of the ongoing state-level probes. The court heard arguments that Messi's late arrival and preferential treatment for VIPs angered ticket-holding spectators. Ultimately, the bench sided with the state government's position and dismissed the petitions.

Key Points: Calcutta HC Rejects Central Agency Probe for Messi Event Chaos

  • Court rejects plea for central agency probe into Messi event mismanagement and ticket irregularities
  • Bench upholds impartiality of state police SIT and retired judge committee
  • Petitioners alleged Messi's delay and VIP access caused spectator chaos
  • State counsel argued Central Armed Police Forces were responsible for Messi's security
3 min read

Calcutta HC rejects plea for central agency probe in Messi event chaos

Calcutta High Court rejects plea for CBI or ED probe into Lionel Messi event mismanagement at Salt Lake Stadium, upholds state-level investigations.

"At this moment there is no reason to believe that the current parallel probes... were not impartial. - Calcutta High Court Division Bench"

Kolkata, Dec 22

A division bench of the Calcutta High Court, on Monday, rejected the plea for a central agency probe into the "mismanagement" during an event at the Salt Lake Stadium in Kolkata earlier this month involving Argentine soccer star Lionel Messi that ultimately led to chaos and vandalism within the stadium.

The hearing on the public interest litigations demanding a central agency probe in the matter was concluded at the division bench of the Calcutta High Court's Acting Chief Justice Sujoy Paul and Justice Partha Sarathi Sen on Monday afternoon, and the said bench reserved the order in the matter for the time being.

However, finally, on late Monday evening, the division bench delivered the order rejecting the plea for a central agency probe in the matter.

The division bench said that at this moment there is no reason to believe that the current parallel probes conducted by the Special Investigation Team (SIT) of West Bengal Police and the Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee-appointed committee headed by a retired judge of the Calcutta High Court was not impartial.

The demands in the public interest litigations filed in the matter were that the central agency will probe both the event of chaos and financial irregularities behind the sale of tickets during the event.

The counsels for the petitioners said that the central agency probe in both matters was necessary since the parallel probes conducted by the Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee-appointed probe committee led by a retired judge of the Calcutta High Court and the one by a special investigation team of state police were not reliable.

The counsels for the petitioners also added that, besides the scheduled event of Messi at Salt Lake Stadium, an influential section got him involved in some other unscheduled programmes for which the football legend arrived late at the stadium.

Thereafter, the people who purchased tickets for the event at extremely high prices were denied proper visual access to the soccer star as he was surrounded by several politically influential persons and their family members, who irked the spectators and ultimately led to the chaos and vandalism, they said.

The state government counsel said that Messi's security at the stadium was the responsibility of the Central Armed Police Forces.

The lawyer also detailed the actions taken by the state government in the event of mismanagement and chaos at the stadium.

Finally, the division bench did not accept the argument on behalf of the petitioners and rejected the plea for a central agency probe in the matter.

- IANS

Share this article:

Reader Comments

S
Shreya B
As a football fan from Kolkata, I'm still heartbroken. We paid so much just to see Messi from a distance, and then he was surrounded by VIPs. The chaos was inevitable. The High Court should have at least ordered a more transparent investigation. Feels like common fans are always ignored.
A
Aman W
Good move by the court. We don't need to centralize every single probe. The state's SIT and the retired judge committee should be given a chance. Constant demands for CBI or other agencies undermine our federal structure. Let's trust the process.
P
Priyanka N
The article mentions "politically influential persons" taking over. This is the core problem in our country – VIP culture. Whether it's a concert, a temple, or a football match, common people suffer. The probe should specifically look into who these people were and why they had such access.
D
David E
Respectfully, I disagree with the court's reasoning. When there are allegations of financial irregularities and powerful people are involved, an independent central agency probe inspires more confidence. The parallel probes appointed by the state government lack perceived neutrality, which is crucial for public trust.
K
Kavya N
The whole event was a shame for Kolkata's image. We are known for our love for sports and culture. Messi came and this happened! The focus should now be on compensating the fans and ensuring such mismanagement never happens again. Jai Hind!

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Minimum 50 characters 0/50