Bailey's Bold Response to Waugh: Why Age Won't Dictate Ashes Selection

Former captain Steve Waugh challenged selectors to make tougher decisions about senior players ahead of the Ashes. Chief selector George Bailey responded firmly, defending the selection process and emphasizing that every player earned their spot. The debate centers around aging stars like Khawaja, Lyon, and Starc potentially playing their final Ashes series. Bailey stressed respecting players' hard work while managing the team's transition phase carefully.

Key Points: George Bailey Responds to Steve Waugh Ashes Selection Criticism

  • Steve Waugh urged selectors to make tough calls on senior players for team transition
  • George Bailey defended selections saying every player earned their Test spot
  • Waugh warned against multiple senior players retiring simultaneously creating team gaps
  • Bailey questioned whether critics actually want veteran bowlers Starc and Lyon dropped
3 min read

Australia's chief selector responds to Steve Waugh's 'pick the sides, not players' dig

Australia's chief selector defends team choices after Steve Waugh questions senior player selections for Ashes, stressing every player earned their spot regardless of age.

"I'd like to see the selectors pick the sides, not the players. - Steve Waugh"

Canberra, November 5

Australia's chief selector George Bailey has responded to their former captain Steve Waugh's remarks on team selection ahead of the upcoming Ashes series, stressing that every player chosen has earned his spot, regardless of age, according to Sen.

Waugh had recently urged the selectors to make tougher decisions to allow younger talent to come through, pointing out that several senior players could be featuring in their final Ashes campaign. Usman Khawaja will turn 39 during the series, while Nathan Lyon is 37 and Mitchell Starc is 35.

"George Bailey's going to have to make some tough calls and I think in the past, he hasn't really had the appetite for that at times, so he's going to have to step up to the plate with the other selectors because it is a time of transition," Waugh said before the Australian squad was announced, as quoted from Sen.

"The bowlers are in their 30s and some of the batsmen are getting on as well, but that's natural for every team. You just want to make sure that three or four players don't go out at the same time," he added.

"That leaves a big hole in the team. So, they got to just make sure that it is a transition, but not all at once," he noted.

"I'd like to see the selectors pick the sides, not the players. There's been a lot of players recently picking sides and saying who should be in the team. That's the selectors' job," he said.

When asked about Waugh's comments, Bailey said, "They were not in the selection meeting the players."

"We're aware of the age profile of the team. I'm interested, do they (critics of the age profile) want Starc and Lyon out? There's other ways of attacking that," he added.

"You have to have respect for the fact these guys work incredibly hard to play Test cricket," he noted.

"Give due respect to the guys performing and earned he right to be selected. There would be more names on that list of the players were able to pick," he said.

Meanwhile, Jake Weatherald, who has scored 248 runs for Tasmania in the ongoing Sheffield Shield season, has been handed his maiden Test call-up, edging out Matt Renshaw as speculation continues over who will open alongside Khawaja.

Despite his memorable performance against India last December, Sam Konstas missed out on selection after a difficult start to the domestic season.

Having been dropped earlier in June, Marnus Labuschagne has made his way back into contention, alongside Cameron Green and Beau Webster. Sean Abbott and Brendan Doggett have also been included in the squad but are not expected to feature in the starting XI.

Australia's squad for 1st Ashes Test: Steve Smith (captain), Sean Abbott, Scott Boland, Alex Carey, Brendan Doggett, Cameron Green, Josh Hazlewood, Travis Head, Josh Inglis, Usman Khawaja, Marnus Labuschagne, Nathan Lyon, Mitchell Starc, Jake Weatherald, Beau Webster.

- ANI

Share this article:

Reader Comments

P
Priya S
Bailey's response seems a bit defensive. If senior players are performing, they deserve their spots - just like how Dhoni and Kohli were backed during their careers. Performance should be the only criteria, not age! 👍
J
James A
Interesting to see this debate from an Indian perspective. Our selectors face similar challenges with balancing experience and youth. Waugh's "pick the sides, not players" philosophy makes sense for long-term team building.
A
Ananya R
Khawaja at 39 and still opening! Shows age is just a number if you're fit and performing. Reminds me of how our Indian veterans like Rahul Dravid played till late 30s with great success. Experience is priceless in Test cricket! ✨
S
Sarah B
Respectfully, I think Bailey could have handled this better. Public spats between former and current cricket officials don't help team morale. In India, we've seen how such debates can become distracting for players.
V
Vikram M
Good to see Weatherald getting a chance! Domestic performers deserve opportunities. Hope he gets a proper run like we give our Ranji Trophy stars. Too often talented players get just one match and are dropped. 🤞

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Minimum 50 characters 0/50