Ashes Selection Drama: Why Nathan Lyon Was Dropped and Pat Cummins Almost Played

Australian selector George Bailey has provided some fascinating insight into the team's tough calls for the Brisbane Test. He revealed that captain Pat Cummins was very close to playing but they erred on the side of caution with his back injury. Bailey also explained the controversial decision to drop star spinner Nathan Lyon, acknowledging Lyon wasn't happy about it. Finally, he confirmed that batsman Usman Khawaja needed more time to fully recover from his back spasms.

Key Points: George Bailey on Nathan Lyon Brisbane Test Snub and Pat Cummins Close Call

  • Pat Cummins bowled in the nets but was a late withdrawal due to injury management concerns
  • Selectors dropped Nathan Lyon, favoring an all-pace attack for the Gabba's conditions
  • Bailey admits Lyon disagreed with the decision, similar to a past omission in Jamaica
  • Usman Khawaja missed the Test as his back had not fully recovered to baseline fitness
4 min read

Ashes: George Bailey opens up on Pat Cummins close call, reveals Nathan Lyon's exclusion from Brisbane Test

Australian selector George Bailey reveals the close call on Pat Cummins' fitness and explains the controversial decision to drop Nathan Lyon for the Brisbane Ashes Test.

"I don't think he agreed with it, and that's fine... Nathan will disagree with the decision, and that's perfectly okay. - George Bailey"

Brisbane, December 4

George Bailey, who is the current Chair of the National Selection Panel for the Australian men's cricket team, has opened up on Nathan Lyon's exclusion from the Brisbane Test and also revealed how close Australia's captain Pat Cummins was to playing in the second Ashes Test of the five-match series.

Cummins missed the Ashes opener in Perth after he failed to recover from his back injury. The Australian captain was sidelined from the hosts' squad for the day-night Test in Brisbane against England.

The 32-year-old Cummins bowled this week as a part of his return from his lumbar stress injury. The right-arm pacer was seen bowling at the Gabba in nets on Thursday evening.

"He's going to bowl a certain amount of overs this week. So it's like, 'Well, if you're going to bowl them here (in the nets), can it be there (in the Test)?'" Bailey said during play on day one of the Brisbane Test, as quoted by cricket.com.au.

"The key factors were, what does that look like for post this (Test), and are you accentuating that risk going forward? Then what are the uncontrollables in a game, and does that put other players under pressure? It was going to be a hard number of overs. Once we got up here, saw his training, got as much of the background medical information as well, it became a live possibility," he said.

"Then it was just working through the permutations of what that would look like in terms of the amount of overs, what it would look like going forward as well? It became a live conversation, hence probably leaving some of the other decisions until late," Bailey added.

Australia dropped experienced off-spinner Nathan Lyon during the pink-ball Test against England in Brisbane. The hosts opted for Michael Neser and Josh Inglis. However, Bailey said that Lyon could return for the third Test in Adelaide.

Bailey suggested that the pace of recent Test matches Australia have played has limited Lyon's ability to make an impact on seam-friendly pitches.

"I don't think he agreed with it, and that's fine. I think Beau Webster's in the same boat. That was heavily debated around Inglis and Webster, Neser and Webster. Nathan will disagree with the decision, and that's perfectly okay. I think he disagreed with the decision in Jamaica, and that was perfectly okay. There's no qualms about players feeling like they can impact the game, and the fact of the matter is he could have, " said Bailey.

Bailey revealed that Usman Khawaja, who missed the second Test due to back spasms, is yet to recover fully.

"I think it's just highlighted with 'Gaz' because there have been years where he has managed his ability to bowl long spells, go at two an over, and hold things down, and it just hasn't quite panned out that way (more recently). But when it suits and the time's right, that will still be the case, I imagine. Khawaja also hit the nets during the tea break on Thursday as he attempts to mount a recall case in his return from the back spasms that dogged him in Perth, and which he has not yet fully recovered from," Bailey added.

"He hadn't got his back back to baseline, and if you're not back to the starting point, then it's obviously a heightened risk. He very much felt, I guess it's a guilt ... when you're injured, and you feel like you let the team down, and I think that was something he was conscious of - if it happened again, it'd be an awful feeling. "So sitting this one out buys time to get it right and build it out from there," said Bailey.

- ANI

Share this article:

Reader Comments

P
Priya S
Bailey seems very transparent about the process, which is good. But I respectfully disagree with leaving out a world-class spinner like Lyon. Even on a green top, his experience and control can be vital in the second innings. 🤔
A
Aman W
Cummins' fitness is crucial for the series balance. As an Indian fan, watching the Ashes is always a treat! The intensity is something else. Hope both teams are at full strength soon for a proper contest.
S
Sarah B
The medical and risk management side of selection is fascinating. It's not just about who's the best player on paper, but who can get through the match and the next one. Smart long-term thinking from the selectors.
V
Vikram M
Bailey saying Lyon didn't agree with the decision but it's "perfectly okay" shows a healthy team environment. In our cricket culture, sometimes senior players are not questioned. This open dialogue is good for the sport.
K
Karthik V
The Ashes drama is top-notch! 😄 Missing key players like Cummins and Khawaja is a big blow. But it gives chances to others like Neser. As a cricket fanatic, just hoping for a close series. England looking better this time.

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Minimum 50 characters 0/50