Key Points

Muslim cleric Shahabuddin Razvi has strongly criticized a new order from Delhi's Chief Minister. He says the decision to allow loudspeakers until midnight for Hindu festivals is unfair. Razvi claims this kind of relaxation is never granted for Islamic celebrations. He also argues the move goes directly against the Supreme Court's guidelines on noise restrictions.

Key Points: Shahabuddin Razvi Slams Rekha Gupta Loudspeaker Order as Biased

  • Razvi argues the order contradicts Supreme Court directives on noise pollution
  • He claims similar relaxations are never considered for Muslim festivals like Muharram
  • The cleric cites the recent non-vegetarian shop closures during Navratri as another example
  • The Delhi government approved the loudspeaker use from Sept 22 to Oct 3 for festivities
2 min read

Against SC's directive: Razvi hits out at Delhi govt's decision to allow loudspeakers till midnight

Muslim cleric Shahabuddin Razvi criticizes Delhi CM Rekha Gupta's loudspeaker relaxation for Hindu festivals, calling it discriminatory and against SC orders.

"This decision appears to reflect Rekha Gupta's biased approach. - Shahabuddin Razvi"

New Delhi, Sep 23

Muslim cleric Shahabuddin Razvi on Tuesday criticised Delhi Chief Minister Rekha Gupta's order permitting the use of loudspeakers and public address systems till midnight during Ramlila, Durga Puja, and Dussehra celebrations, arguing that it contradicts the Supreme Court's directions on noise restrictions.

The relaxation, approved on Monday, will remain in effect from September 22 to October 3 after receiving clearance from Lt Governor V.K. Saxena, following a proposal by the Delhi government.

Defending the move, CM Gupta had said, "Hindu festivals used to face difficulties as Ramleela and Durga Puja celebrations cannot conclude at 10 P.M. When Dandiya can go on all night in Gujarat, then what is the fault of Delhiites? That is why we have decided that the speakers can go on till midnight."

However, Shahabuddin Razvi expressed strong opposition, stating the order was discriminatory.

He claimed that such a relaxation would never have been considered for Muslim festivals, suggesting the Chief Minister's "biased approach".

Speaking to IANS, Razvi stated, "After 27 years, the BJP came to power in Delhi. Rekha Gupta issued a series of new decrees. This decree, however, detailed Durga Puja, including the timetable and loudspeaker volume, which was increased. In reality, this contradicts the Supreme Court's decision. The Supreme Court had ordered the music to be played at a very low volume, yet Rekha Gupta's government is issuing a reversal of the Supreme Court's decision."

He further alleged double standards, saying, "If there are Muslim festivals, such as Rabiul Awwal processions or Muharram processions, numerous restrictions are imposed. This decision appears to reflect Rekha Gupta's biased approach."

Razvi also talked about the government's earlier decision to shut non-vegetarian shops during Navratri, noting that while precautions near temples may be justified, extending the restriction across the city was unnecessary.

"Where there are meat shops near temples, the shopkeepers themselves should close their shops. In other parts of the city or places far from temples, where no one's faith is hurt, there is no need to close the shops," he said.

- IANS

Share this article:

Reader Comments

P
Priya S
While I understand the need for festival celebrations, noise pollution affects everyone. The Supreme Court guidelines exist for a reason. Why can't we celebrate with moderate volume? Students and elderly people suffer the most.
A
Aman W
Razvi sahab has a point about consistency. Either the rules apply to all festivals equally or they shouldn't exist. This selective relaxation does create perception of bias. We need uniform policy for all religious events.
S
Sarah B
As someone living near a Ramlila ground, the noise till midnight is really disturbing. Festivals are important but so is peace and quiet. Hope authorities ensure volume limits are actually followed.
V
Vikram M
Good decision by CM! Our cultural festivals are part of our heritage and should be celebrated properly. The comparison with Gujarat's Dandiya is valid - why different rules for different states?
N
Nisha Z
Actually, Razvi makes sense about the meat shops issue too. Restrictions should be area-specific, not city-wide. Common sense approach is needed instead of blanket bans. 🤔
M
Michael C
Living in Delhi for 5 years now. The festival season is beautiful but the noise levels can be overwhelming. Maybe there's a middle path - designated zones where celebrations can go late, while residential areas have stricter limits?

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Minimum 50 characters 0/50